This is one of the most common frustrations I hear from clients, and it shows up across every kind of dog I work with. A dog who is fluent in knowing their name in the kitchen turns into a stone statue on the sidewalk. Cues that are rock solid at home seem to evaporate the moment something more interesting shows up when they are out in the real world. It starts to feel personal. Like the dog is choosing everything else in the world over you, and that feeling puts real strain on the relationship. Owners start to wonder if their dog respects them at all.

Here’s the good news. In almost every one of these cases, the dog isn’t choosing to ignore you. Their brain is doing exactly what it was built to do, and once you understand that mechanism, you have a clear, practical path to change it.

Subscribe now

The Attention Economy

Here’s a reframe I want you to consider. You are not the main event in your dog’s environment. You are one stimulus among hundreds: the wind carrying five other yards’ worth of scent, a jogger’s footfall two blocks away, a dog barking behind a fence, a plastic bag skittering across pavement. Your dog’s nervous system is running a constant, automatic calculation about what deserves attention right now, and that calculation is not sentimental. It does not care that you are the one holding the leash and the treats. It cares about intensity, novelty, and relevance to safety.

When your dog blows past a cue that’s fluent in the living room, they are not choosing defiance over you. Their attention has already been claimed by something louder in the moment. Understanding that difference, choice versus capture, is the whole ballgame for staying compassionate instead of frustrated on a walk.

What’s Actually Happening in the Brain

A big piece of this comes down to arousal chemistry. Norepinephrine, the brain’s alertness chemical, and acetylcholine, which sharpens focus and attention, both spike when something new or intense shows up in the environment. That spike is not a flaw. It is the system working correctly. Norepinephrine in particular is tied to how strongly a stimulus grabs attention and how well the brain suppresses competing, quieter signals so it can respond fast. Add adrenaline from the adrenal glands and you get a body primed to act: heart rate up, senses narrowed, muscles ready.

We need this system. Without it, no animal, human or dog, could respond to anything urgent. The problem isn’t that arousal exists. The problem is what happens once arousal tips into overstimulation. Past a certain point, that narrowed, primed state stops being useful information gathering and starts being a full system takeover. The dog isn’t weighing options anymore. Every ounce of available attention is locked onto the thing that triggered the spike, and there’s nothing left over for you, your cues, or your treats.

That’s tunnel vision. It looks like disobedience. It’s actually a nervous system doing its job a little too well.

Nervous Dogs Versus Confident Dogs

Not every dog tips into tunnel vision the same way. Confident dogs tend to move toward stimulation. A squirrel, a skateboard, another dog. Their arousal reads as excitement, and their tunnel vision looks like drive. Nervous dogs tend to move away, or freeze, and their tunnel vision reads as shutdown or panic. Same underlying mechanism, opposite behavioral expression.

A lot of these triggers function as what ethologists call a releasing stimulus, sometimes called a sign stimulus or releaser. This is a specific environmental trigger that activates a hardwired, instinctive response without any conscious decision-making involved. A squirrel darting sideways can trip a chase response. A skateboard’s fast, low, rolling motion can trip a flight or avoidance response. Neither dog is deciding to react. The trigger itself is flipping a switch that evolution wired in long before that particular dog was born.

There’s a useful pair of terms for this from behavioral ecology: neophilic and neophobic. Neophilic animals are drawn toward novelty, curious and approach-oriented. Neophobic animals are wired to avoid it, treating anything unfamiliar as a potential threat until proven otherwise. Most dogs live somewhere on that spectrum, and a lot of dogs shift along it depending on context, fatigue, and what’s happened to them earlier that day. Either way, the practical answer looks the same. Whether your dog is losing their mind with joy over another dog or losing their mind with fear over a skateboard, the path forward is the same process: bring the intensity down until the brain can come back online.

Threshold, and My Favorite Phrase

Threshold is the line where a dog can still think, learn, and respond to you, versus the point where they can’t. Below threshold, a dog is aware of a trigger but still capable of taking a treat, checking in, or responding to a known cue. Over threshold, none of that is available to them. You’ve probably heard trainers say a dog is “over threshold” and wondered what that actually means in practice. It means the tunnel vision has taken over.

You manage threshold with two dials: distance and volume. Distance from the trigger. Volume of the trigger itself, whether that’s how close, how loud, how fast, or how many things are happening at once. Turn either dial down and you buy back your dog’s ability to think.

My catchphrase for the actual process is this: increase the frequency, lower the intensity. Instead of one overwhelming exposure, you’re aiming for many small, manageable ones. A hundred sightings of a jogger at two hundred feet where your dog stays calm and gets rewarded will do more for that dog’s long-term comfort than one dramatic exposure at ten feet ever will. This is desensitization: repeated, low-intensity exposure to a trigger, paired with good things, until the nervous system stops treating it as an emergency and starts treating it as background noise.

The Old Way, and Why It Failed So Many Good Dogs

There’s an old model in gun dog training that I think about a lot. Breeders and trainers used to take young puppies out and fire a rifle close to them, on purpose, to see how they’d react. If a puppy panicked, someone would inevitably say, “that dog won’t hunt”. The logic was that a good hunting dog should be able to handle a gunshot near its ear without falling apart.

Think about how backwards that is. They were testing a puppy’s nervous system against one of the most intense acoustic events an animal can experience, at close range, during a developmental window when the brain is especially sensitive to overwhelming input. Of course, some of those puppies panicked. Any of them would have, at the wrong distance, at the wrong age, without preparation. We will never know how many genuinely talented dogs got written off and discarded because nobody understood threshold. There was a better way then, and there is a much better way now: start ridiculously far away, at ridiculously low intensity, and build up slowly enough that the dog’s system never gets overwhelmed in the first place.

Subscribe now

The Flight Response Is Older Than Training

Underneath all of this sits something even more basic: the startle and flight response. It’s hardwired into mammals for a simple reason. If something large and sudden happens right next to an animal and that animal doesn’t move away, it might not survive to find out whether the danger was real. Evolution doesn’t wait around for an animal to calmly assess risk in the moment. It builds a reflex that says get away first, evaluate later.

Overcoming that reflex around a specific trigger takes desensitization and habituation, the slow, repeated, low-intensity process described above. But there’s another piece that matters just as much: relationship. Other dogs, familiar locations, and you all function as social support that can buffer a startle response. You’ve heard me say this before because I believe it completely. It’s all about relationship.

You can watch this play out in real time in a puppy class. A new dog in the room starts tentative, glued to a corner. Over a few weeks, that same dog gets braver, but watch closely, and you’ll notice something: even as they get bolder, they keep glancing back at their person. That’s not clinginess. It’s a check-in, a quick confirmation that the world is still safe, and it’s one of the clearest signs of a securely attached dog. I see it constantly in my off-leash work. The dogs who do best out in the world are the ones who’ve built a habit of checking back in, not the ones who never look back at all.

A Note on Emotional Associations

One more piece worth understanding: no stimulus is neutral once a dog has built an association with it. A neutral-sounding trigger- a specific jacket, a certain tone of voice, the sound of a particular car- can become massively charged if it’s been paired with something scary or something wonderful. Emotional states like fear, joy, and attachment all interact with the same arousal chemistry we talked about earlier, which is why two dogs can have wildly different reactions to the exact same event. The stimulus was never really the whole story. The association is.

You Don’t Need a Professional to Start

Here’s what I want you to take from all of this. You don’t need a behavior consultant to make real progress with a dog who struggles with tunnel vision. You need a focused approach: figure out your dog’s threshold distance for a given trigger, start well outside of it, and use frequent, low-intensity, well-rewarded exposures to slowly build tolerance. Increase the frequency. Lower the intensity. That’s the whole formula.

What trips people up more than anything else isn’t the mechanics. It’s the fear of doing it wrong. I want to take that fear off the table. You don’t have to get the distance perfect on day one. You don’t have to know the exact right rate of progression before you start. You just have to start somewhere, watch your dog’s response, and adjust from there. Start with more distance than you think you need. Always. You can get closer over time. It’s much harder to walk back a dog who got thrown into the deep end too soon.

Your dog was never ignoring you. Their brain was just doing exactly what it evolved to do. Once you understand that, the walk stops feeling like a battlefield of wills and starts feeling like what it actually is: a chance to help your dog’s nervous system learn that the world is safer than it thought. Even Pat Benatar could understand that.

Further Reading

If you want to go deeper into the science behind this, here are a few sources worth exploring.

Simply Psychology, on the major models of attention: simplypsychology.org/attention-models.html

The Decision Lab, on selective attention and why the brain filters what it takes in: thedecisionlab.com/reference-guide/neuroscience/selective-attention

PMC, a research overview relevant to attention and arousal in the brain: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3731537

NCBI Bookshelf, background on stress physiology and the body’s arousal response: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK557825

Verywell Mind, on acetylcholine and its role in attention and arousal: verywellmind.com/what-is-acetylcholine-2794810

That question is where I start every conversation about setting a dog up for a professional future, and it is worth walking through here, because it applies just as much to the dog on your couch as it does to a future facility dog.

Subscribe now

There is a word for the thing happening in the room before any of us are consciously aware of it: neuroception. It describes the nervous system’s constant, wordless scanning of the environment for cues of safety or threat, running underneath our awareness long before our thinking brain has a chance to weigh in. A baby coos at a familiar face and cries at a stranger’s approach for the same reason an adult’s shoulders drop the moment a calm dog settles at their feet. None of it is a decision. It is biology, doing its job before we ever notice it is working.

A dog who is genuinely relaxed becomes a signal flare inside that system. Weight even, mouth soft, breathing slow. To a nervous system scanning for danger, that dog is telling the truth in the only language that matters here, and the human nearby borrows some of that calm without ever choosing to.

Meg Daley Olmert traced the chemistry behind that borrowed calm in her book Made For Each Other. She points to oxytocin, the same hormone that floods a mother during birth and nursing, and shows that friendly contact between a person and an animal releases it in both directions at once. She describes it as an anti stress chemical, one that shifts us out of guarded and into open. That softened posture I look for in a working dog is not just a pleasant sign. It is very likely a small hormonal event happening in two nervous systems at the same time.

I think about Edward O. Wilson’s idea of biophilia often when I teach this material. Wilson argued that humans carry an innate pull toward other living things, a bond built into us by millions of years spent alongside the rest of the natural world. Olmert’s research gives that pull a mechanism. If biophilia is the why, oxytocin and neuroception are the how. Long before anyone put a vest on a dog, we were already wired to respond to a calm animal nearby, and built with the exact chemistry to make that response feel good.

Here is the part I need my students to sit with before they get excited about any of this. That whole chain, the neuroception, the borrowed calm, the oxytocin, only works in one direction if the animal is genuinely thriving. Not tolerating the work. Not performing it well enough to pass. Thriving.

If a dog is scared, overwhelmed, or being asked to hold themselves in a way that costs them something, the chain breaks, and it can run backward. A nervous system that is any good at its job will pick up on that dog’s stress even when nobody names it out loud. The visit that was meant to help can quietly do the opposite, and everyone involved may still walk away believing it went fine.

This is why I tell every student the same thing before we talk about training or handling skills at all. Your first job is not obedience. It is advocacy. You are the only one in the room who can speak for that dog, and you are making a decision, every single time, to put another being in a situation they did not choose. That is a real responsibility, and it deserves to be treated like one, whether you are heading into a hospital wing or just bringing your dog along to your kid’s soccer game.

A lot of programs ask whether a dog can perform the behaviors a visit requires. Fewer ask whether the dog is a willing participant, session by session, moment by moment. I push my students further and ask whether the dog can meaningfully consent, in the only way a dog is able to: through choice.

The clearest way I know to protect that choice is to build in degrees of freedom. Can the dog move away if they need to. Can they end an interaction? Can they signal for a break instead of being held in a down stay because the schedule says it is time. A dog with options can tell you the truth about how they are doing. A dog with no options can only comply, and compliance can look identical to willingness right up until it is not.

Dogs make this easier for us than almost any other species could. They have spent thousands of years alongside humans, and in that time they have become remarkably fluent readers of us, and remarkably readable in return. A lowered head, a tucked tail, a long slow blink, a hard stare at the door. None of it is subtle once you know to look. The information is there. Our job, whether we are handling a facility dog or just living with one, is simply to keep looking.

Citation:

Porges SW. Polyvagal Theory: A Science of Safety. Front Integr Neurosci. 2022 May 10;16:871227. doi: 10.3389/fnint.2022.871227. PMID: 35645742; PMCID: PMC9131189.

Olmert, M. D. (2009). Made for each other: The biology of the human-animal bond. Da Capo Press.

Nothing is wrong with him. He was never taught how to handle a world where machines start moving without a human touching them. Neither was your dog, probably. Neither was mine, until I built it in on purpose. It’s incredible what we normalize in our minds.

Happily, dog training has moved away from a focus on control and obedience over the last fifteen or twenty years, and toward the idea that a sentient being deserves some autonomy and choice in its own environment. Choice and control is most definitely in the zeitgeist at the moment. Most people who care about dogs have heard some version of this by now. It sounds great but almost nobody explains how you actually do it.

It does not mean your dog has free run of the house or gets to wander off leash near a busy road. It means you build things gradually, on purpose, through training and environmental design, so your dog earns more freedom because he has the skills to handle it. Autonomy is not something you hand a dog. It is something you build toward, one rep at a time. Think of it like a fitness routine. You start small, building habits like moving from the car into the house after returning from a walk. Then the next time you build the cue “go inside” or “let’s go home” as you point to the door. The next rep you drop the leash and your dog drags it. Eventually, you have a pattern of returning home and telling your dog to “go inside” and at the end you have a savvy dog who habitually hops out of the vehicle and takes himself to the front door.

Subscribe now

For a long time, the advice was pretty simple: socialize your dog with people and other dogs and you’re set. That advice made sense in a world that stayed relatively still. The concept of socializing dogs is rather lost on people. Especially for people who are becoming less social themselves.

We have become more isolated. We started living more sedentary lives, socializing through screens instead of building real-world connections. The idea of a well-socialized animal is one that is resilient and can handle changes in the environment with ease. An animal who has social capital through rich and meaningful interactions. Who enjoys the experience of encountering new creatures and aspects of the living and ever-changing world.

Our technology kept building things designed to startle: Halloween decorations with motion sensors and animatronic jump scares, vacuums that start themselves, cameras that let us talk to our dogs from an app while they hear a tinny, disembodied voice with no context for where we actually are. A dog who cannot tolerate all of that gets labeled as anxious or broken, and gets handed off for obedience work or medication to fix what is really a mismatch between his skill set and our world.

That is backwards. The dog is not malfunctioning. He was never taught how to cope with a world this unpredictable. We must be so careful when we pathologize behavior. Behavior has a function. If an animal has a startle response, it is there for a reason. If our animals startle at things and events in their own environment, it is because we have not done our job to help them be around those stimuli, and we have a duty to help them.

Here is what makes me uncomfortable. Our dogs are struggling at alarming rates, and their struggle is a mirror of our struggle. We eat too much processed food and move too little. We avoid discomfort instead of building the capacity to handle it, then wonder why we fall apart under real stress. We have done something similar to our dogs. We built training philosophies around avoiding all stress, all friction, all discomfort, and then act surprised when a dog completely unravels at the sight of another dog on leash that he cannot get to, even though we did “everything right.”

Dogs and humans co-evolved as social, adaptable, resourceful creatures. Somewhere along the way we started raising both species to be fragile instead of capable. If we want dogs who can actually live in this complicated, human-centric world, we have to give them behavioral range that matches the complexity of the environment we are asking them to live in.

This is why I will always bet on building skills over obedience. Obedience is compliance in the moment. Skills are what a dog can draw on when the moment gets hard, unfamiliar, or completely new.

It is also why dog training will never be replaced by artificial intelligence. Training is relationship work. A dog who listens to one person in the household and ignores another is not confused about hierarchy. He has a different relationship with each of them, built through different histories of trust and communication. You see the same pattern in families where kids expect immediate compliance because someone convinced them dogs need a “pack leader.” That mindset does not transfer to a broken relationship, and it was never really about leadership to begin with. It was about connection.

If you brought a dog into your home, you signed up for more than feeding him and walking him around the block. You signed up to learn how dogs actually learn, what a biologically appropriate life looks like for your specific dog, and what his breed or individual temperament is built to do. Is barking actually a problem, or just inconvenient or embarrassing? Should he be allowed to chew and bite things that are appropriate to chew and bite? Is a stepping it out paced walk around your neighborhood really meeting his needs, or just checking a box?

Training needs to become part of your lifestyle the same way movement and whole foods are supposed to be part of yours. You already know what happens to your own ability to cope when you are not sleeping, not moving, not eating well. Hold that same mirror up for your dog.

And if you are falling short of what your dog needs, get creative before you get discouraged. Is there someone who can take him somewhere new during the day while you are at work, somewhere with actual sniffing and exploring instead of the same three blocks? Could he spend time with a canine friend who challenges him a little? The goal was never a dog who obeys everything. The goal is a dog with enough skills to meet the world as it actually is, and recover when it throws something new at him.

Maybe you have not proactively taught your dog anything since that puppy class you took years ago. Sign up for a new class, teach your dog a new skill or game. Stop making excuses about being busy and get back to cultivating and designing behaviors to help your dog be more successful.

That is the standard I want for every dog I work with. It should be the standard for yours too.

But here is what I keep coming back to. That hunger for connection, for presence, for something that will look at us and ask nothing in return except our attention, has an answer that has been sitting in our living rooms for about fifteen thousand years. It does not require a subscription. It does not require a Wi-Fi signal. It requires some love, a bag of treats, and it gives twice as much as it takes. Dogs of course.

Chapter One: Your Dog Is the Original Attention Economy

We used to get a dog when we felt disconnected. The empty nesters replacing the kids who left for college. The couple testing the waters before they had a baby of their own. The lonely child who repetedly asks for a friend. Dogs have always been there when we needed a connection in the world.

Here is the part that matters, though. A dog is not a chatbot with fur. An AI wants nothing from you. It will validate you endlessly and ask for nothing in return, which sounds lovely until you realize that is not actually how love works. Dogs want something back. They need you to notice their individual quirks and preferences, to meet them halfway, to give a little so they will give a little (or a lot). That is not a design flaw. That is the entire point. It is a real relationship, with give and take, the same as the ones we have with the people we love. Learning to be a good partner to your dog is, in a very real way, practice for being a good partner to your people.

Share

Think about the folks who fly across the world and pay a small fortune to sit quietly near a family of mountain gorillas or watch a pride of lions doze in the sun. They are not simply chasing luxury. They are chasing a feeling: being a participant in something wild and alive, instead of an observer scrolling past it. We have through selective breeding, designed dogs, essentially, to give us a shortcut to that same feeling, right here, without the plane ticket and Yellow Fever Vaccine. Underneath all that domestication is still a thread of something undomesticated: the play bow, the nose that lifts on the wind, the zoomies that come out of nowhere. That is the wild world, available to you on a Tuesday afternoon in your own neighborhood for your convenience.

And your dog is a genuinely excellent scientist of your attention. Teach a recall, a hand target, a "go to your bed from ten feet away," and you get instant, honest, serve-and-return feedback. No algorithm curating what you see next. Just a dog, watching you, waiting to see what you do. If you have been feeling the particular fog that comes from too much scrolling, you are not imagining it. "Brain rot" was actually named Oxford's Word of the Year for 2024, defined as the perceived decline in someone's mental sharpness from consuming too much low-value online content, and researchers are now taking it seriously as a real pattern rather than just a meme. The symptoms they are tracking include hours lost to screens, restlessness when a device is not close at hand, and a diminished ability to focus on the things that actually matter. A pretty good argument for leaving the phone at home on the next walk. Your dog does not care about your engagement metrics. They just want you to look up.

None of this means AI is some sinister force plotting to replace your relationships. It means the antidote to digital loneliness was never going to be a smarter chatbot. It was always going to be presence, attention, and something warm and slightly muddy sitting at the other end of a leash.

Chapter Two: A Warning to Caring Canine Guardians

To everyone out there Googling their dog’s behavior problem at eleven at night laying in bed with anxiety. I understand. But I want to leave you with a genuine caution. Dr. Google and AI tools want to prescribe you a medicine to soothe your worry. A pill for every ill. It will give you an answer; that’s its job.

AI tools are confident. They are also, quite often, wrong, and they will tell you both the correct answer and the dangerously incorrect one with the exact same tone of authority. There is no reliable way, as a non-professional, to tell which is which just by reading it. A dog displaying resource guarding might be in pain, might be afraid, might be responding to something happening at home that has nothing to do with the dog at all. That kind of read requires someone in the room with your dog, not a chat window.

If your dog is guarding a bone, showing new aggression, struggling with anxiety, or doing anything that scares you or someone in your household, please find a certified, force-free professional in your community rather than trusting a search bar to diagnose it. Look for credentials, ask about methodology, and do not be shy about asking whether a trainer’s approach is grounded in current welfare science rather than tradition or vibes. Your dog cannot advocate for themselves in that conversation. That is what we are here for.

AI is not going anywhere, and honestly, used well, it is going to make a lot of things about this profession better. But it was never going to replace the walk, the eye contact, the hand on the leash, or the person who shows up in your living room and actually looks at your dog. That part is still on us. That part was always going to be the good part anyway.

Find a qualified professional near you, click here.

Subscribe now

Paid subscribers, this next chapter is for you: a practical, no-fluff look at how those of us working with dogs professionally can actually put AI to use, plus a plain-language walk through a new code of ethics built for this exact moment.

Chapter Three: For My Fellow Dog Pros, a Note on Using AI Well

Now let me talk to the trainers, behavior consultants, and canine professionals reading this, because I use AI in my own practice, and I think that is not just fine, it is smart, as long as we are honest about where the line sits.

There is genuinely exciting work happening at the research end of this field. Researchers at NC State have built wearable sensor systems and AI algorithms that measure a working dog’s motion, physiology, and environment, giving guide dog organizations objective, repeatable data to identify temperament traits early instead of relying purely on subjective scoring. That is AI doing something it is genuinely good at: crunching physiological signals at a scale no single trainer’s eyeballs could match, in service of a decision that still gets made by qualified humans.

But you do not need a lab full of sensors to get real value out of this stuff day to day. A lot of dog professionals are already finding, or should be finding, practical everyday uses for AI, so long as it is applied with discretion and a clear-eyed sense of its limits. This is where I have found the most genuine, unglamorous value in my own practice:

Read more

The first time most of my clients really do it, no long line trailing behind them, no fence within sprinting distance, they look like they’re about to hand their wallet to a stranger. Something in their chest tightens. Their breathing changes. The second that dog hits open ground and disappears into the brush at full speed, they turn to me with a face that is equal parts terrified, furious, and completely lost.

That’s usually when I smile.

I grew up outside of town on five acres that backed up to open space: cattle ranches, a big looming butte, deer, bears, the occasional mountain lion. We had dogs my whole childhood and I can picture exactly one leash in that house. Red nylon, hung on the top rack of the coat rack in the mudroom. I’m not sure I ever saw it come down. Our dogs had one job: be part of the family. They came when we called because calling them meant something good was about to happen, a walk, a game, dinner, a car ride somewhere worth going. The idea that a dog wouldn’t come back wasn’t really part of our vocabulary, because we’d never given them a reason to weigh their options.

That’s not the world most dogs live in now. The urban and suburban dog goes from crate to baby gate to fenced yard to leash to back seat and starts the cycle over the next morning. Every transition in their day is managed by someone else. We tend to gloss over this, calling our dogs best friends, family members, spoiled babies. But if you look honestly at how we structure their lives, companion dogs have more in common with captive animals than they do with any natural, free-living species. We control how they move, what they eat, when and where they toilet, who they interact with and for how long. The autonomy deficit in the average pet dog’s life is real, and we largely ignore it. Instead, we try to meet their needs through a very human-centered lens: costly daycares, subscription boxes, and matching bandanas. Material solutions to what are fundamentally behavioral and biological needs. We dog trainers do our best to work around it: longer leashes, choice-based games, autonomy built into structured protocols. These are good tools. But I’ll be honest with you: they’re a workaround. They’re not the same thing as real freedom, and dogs know the difference.

I had a client, a genuinely rule-following guy who lived a block from one of Denver’s most popular parks, where dogs go off-leash illegally approximately thousands of times a day, who had never once let his dog run free because he is, in fact, a very good boy. His dog was a seventy-pound goldendoodle I’d been working with since puppyhood. Solid recall on a long line, great relationship with his owner, by every measure a well-trained dog. But off leash? Never. So I asked him to drive forty-five minutes south to a big open dog off leash area near a reservoir, early on a weekday morning, and just see what his dog could do.

We parked, walked through the cattle gates, and I told him to unclip the leash. He did. His dog looked at him, looked at the horizon, and ran. Ten feet, twenty, thirty, gone into the brush like he’d been shot from a cannon. His owner looked at me like I’d just cost him a dog.

Start counting, I told him.

What?

Start counting. Out loud. Slowly.

He got to eight before his dog came rocketing back out of the brush at the exact same speed he’d left, did a full speed hairpin turn about eight feet in front of us, and vanished in the other direction. His owner did not laugh. Not yet.

Here’s what I wanted him to see: his dog already knew where he was. The whole time. He wasn’t gone, he was out. There’s a difference. A dog with a good relationship doesn’t abandon you in open space, they orbit you. The radius gets big, sometimes very big, but you’re the center of gravity. What erodes that orbit isn’t distance, it’s irrelevance. It’s the owner who plants their feet and checks their phone. The dog at the dog park while you scroll your social media feed. The checked-out parent stares at their phone at the playground while the kid completely disengages. The dog does the math quickly: I know exactly where you’ll be, so I don’t need to check.

We spent the rest of that morning running a simple recall game. Call the dog once, good tone, wait. When he came in, we’d bow our shoulders, back up, make ourselves exciting. Big reward, a couple of treats, real praise, then off you go. I ran him out of food by the halfway point on purpose. After that, all he had was his relationship. His dog kept coming anyway.

Subscribe now

I teach three recalls to every dog I work with and they are not interchangeable. The first is the formal recall: dog runs to you, sits in front, looks good, photographs well. Limited practical application in the real world, but it builds precision and the habit of coming all the way in. The second is the let’s go: I turn my shoulder, I start moving, the dog folds in beside me. No sit, no ceremony, just: we’re leaving, come with me. This is the one you’ll actually use seventy percent of the time. The third is the emergency recall and it is sacred. I protect it the way you’d protect a fire extinguisher: it lives behind glass, you don’t touch it unless something is actually on fire. Every single time a dog hears that cue in training, something extraordinary happens. Rotisserie chicken. Leftover brisket. Something absurd and wonderful. The cue gets conditioned to mean drop everything, this is the best thing that has ever happened to you. The dogs I work with hear that sound and they come like they’re being pulled on a string.

My client saw his dog splash out of a shallow cove that morning to check in on him. Saw him choose a game of fetch over chasing another dog. Saw him keep one eye on us as we moved down the trail, adjusting his range to match our pace, never quite letting us out of sight. That’s not a trained behavior. That’s a relationship made visible.

The leash is a tool; it is not the relationship. And sometimes the best way to truly connect with your dog is to disconnect the leash. Let go, start counting, and watch them come back to you.

Want a rockstar recall on your dog? Colorado Canine Consulting is taking new clients for our online coaching program. We'll teach you how to build a reliable recall from the ground up and start distraction-proofing your dog for the real world, not just your living room. Paying subscribers get a free online coaching session on us. Subscribe and let's get started.

Share Drew Webster's K9 to 5

There’s a big difference between blaming yourself and taking extreme ownership. Blaming yourself is the story you keep telling, the one that loops in your head like a confessional you never quite finish. Extreme ownership is something else entirely. It’s taking responsibility for how you respond, even when you’re at your worst.

I have to do this all the time with my clients. The shame someone feels when their dog steals the medicated cream off the counter. The sadness when she lunges at every dog in the neighborhood and the owner just wants to disappear into the sidewalk. One client cried for an hour after her dog snapped at the baby. Real, ugly crying. But here’s the thing. The dog made a choice based on which behavior was going to give him the greatest advantage in that moment. Behavior can change. What we have to take responsibility for is how we respond when our dogs make us feel unsafe, frustrated, angry, or ashamed. That’s the part we can actually work with. That’s where the power is.

This isn’t about fault. It’s about autonomy. When I stop saying it’s my fault and start saying here’s what happened, here’s how I responded, and here’s what I want to do differently, something shifts. I’m not defeated anymore. I’m in the driver’s seat.

Subscribe now

Here’s something we learn early in the behavior consulting world. We learn to separate subjective from objective. When I started out, behavior history forms gave me the logistics, frequency of events, duration, how long the problem had been going on. Over time I learned to also ask, how did that make you feel? No judgment, just, how did you react? That question changes everything. It gives me a fuller picture of what’s actually happening between a person and their animal.

I also had to learn to read between the lines. When someone tells me a story about their dog, I have to hear it from the dog’s perspective too. Oh, the dog figured out that stealing the underpants and sprinting laps around the house is a fantastic way to end boredom, generate attention, and control access to something in the environment. This behavior works. It’s worked for a long time. Why on earth would the dog stop?

I’ve had more than a few sessions where I basically talked someone out of an expensive multi-week training protocol and just gave them one quick tip. And that’s what everyone wants, right? Ten hacks to stop your dog from being a monster. The trouble is, tricks work once or twice, and then learning happens. That’s just the nature of the game.

I had a client whose dog had multiple surgeries from eating non-food items, usually clothing. She called me one day and said, he’s got a tube sock in his mouth, what do I do? I told her to walk out the front door. She was stunned. What? That’s your advice? What if he eats it? I said, what are you going to do if you chase him? She said, he’ll eat it. Exactly. Walk out the front door, and bonus points if you ring the doorbell on your way out. She did. The dog spit out the sock. Oh, she said. I see. So it’s all my fault. If I had only known to do that from the beginning, he wouldn’t have needed three surgeries.

No, I told her. Dogs have natural resource guarding tendencies, and consuming something is a very effective way to guard it. All she did was show him she wasn’t going to get involved in the conflict. He could have the sock if he wanted it. Turns out, he didn’t really want to eat the sock. Now, there was still a behavior program needed for this dog, because that situation was going to come up again and that particular trick wasn’t going to hold forever. Either the human or the dog was going to have to get smarter.

We hold so much judgment when we observe behavior in others, human or animal. We are storytellers by nature. It’s how oral history was passed down, through accurate recounting and through fable, through folklore that got the lesson right even if it got the facts a little sideways. We want to fill in the blanks. Why did my dog do that? Because she’s mad. Because he feels guilty. Because she’s judging me.

That’s not the why of behavior.

In my university classes, I ask psychology and social work students a question I borrowed from Dr. Susan Friedman, one of many things I say out loud that makes me sound smarter than I am. What is vision for? What is hearing for? What is behavior for? People nail the first two and then look at me like I’ve lost my mind. But when you ask what behavior is for, most people go blank.

Oversimplified but probably accurate answer: behavior exists to gain access to reinforcers and escape punishers in the environment. Another way to put it is that behavior gives a living thing some degree of control over itself and its world. Behavior has a function. We teach everyone to ask WTF, what’s the function? What is the animal trying to gain or protect by doing this particular thing?

Once people start thinking in terms of function, they stop reading behavior as personality. Why does the dog bark and lunge at other dogs on leash? Before, the answer might have been, because he’s aggressive, because she’s a jerk. Now ask, what does the behavior actually achieve? It makes the other dog go away. That’s a negative reinforcement contingency. I bark, I lunge, the threat retreats. This behavior is wildly successful, so of course the dog repeats it. That’s why sticking cheese in front of his nose or yanking him with a painful collar doesn’t fix anything. You haven’t addressed what the behavior is for. You’ve just suppressed it temporarily without ever protecting what mattered to the dog.

As a culture, we’re obsessed with finding fault. I hear it from parents and kids constantly; it’s not my fault. I see it in couples sitting in a therapist’s office trying to figure out who’s to blame. There’s a real difference between taking responsibility for a mistake and hunting for fault in someone else. If you made a choice and you can see that choice led somewhere worse, that’s the moment to step up. Not because you’re bad, but because you’re the one in the room who can do something about it.

In any relationship, there’s usually one person who is more capable in a given moment. That person has to make the first move. This isn’t blame. It’s just who’s going to step up. If your role is to lead, whether you call that parent, guardian, pack leader, I honestly don’t care what you call it, then you are the one with the power. You control your own behavior. You have enormous influence over the environment, over what reinforcers are accessible, over what opportunities exist for the unwanted behavior to keep rehearsing itself. The fact that so many people feel powerless in their own homes genuinely puzzles me. Step back and look at what you actually control. It’s a lot.

Share

Living with and training dogs is like holding a furry little mirror up to your face. If you want the behavior around you to change, change your own reaction first, then get strategic about designing the situations you want to see. A proactive handler is the architect. A reactive handler walks into the building and threatens to blow it up if the walls don’t rearrange themselves.

The real shift happens when you separate behavior from personality. When you stop saying your dog is aggressive and start saying she lunges at other dogs on leash, you’ve just described a behavior. A behavior you can change. A personality, an internal state, a fixed identity, those aren’t things you can train. But a behavior strategy the dog has learned because it works? That you can absolutely work with.

That’s where it starts.

You hear the car pull up. You hear the familiar jingle of a collar. The gate swings open, and suddenly there’s an outside dog in your space — or your dog is the outside dog, stepping into someone else’s territory — and the humans are all smiling and saying “they’ll be fine!” while the dogs are doing that stiff-legged, over-the-top-of-the-shoulder sniff thing that makes your stomach drop just a little.

Maybe it is fine. Maybe it goes sideways in the first thirty seconds and now there’s a scuffle and hurt feelings and someone’s putting their dog back in the car. Maybe it’s technically fine but your dog spends the whole afternoon either hiding under the deck or bouncing off the walls. You wanted a fun afternoon. You got a part-time job managing dog stress.

Here’s the thing: none of that is inevitable. With a little forethought and a different approach to what “introducing dogs” even means, that backyard afternoon can actually be what you pictured.

Subscribe now

We’ve Been Thinking About Socialization Wrong

When most people hear “socialize your dog,” they picture a dog park. A pile of dogs. Chaos, zoomies, the occasional scuffle, someone’s Lab stealing everyone’s ball. It looks like fun. Sometimes it is. But socialization isn’t really about exposure to other dogs — it’s about building a dog’s confidence and trust. There’s a difference between surviving an interaction and thriving in one.

Think about what we’re actually asking of dogs at a traditional introduction. Two strangers, dropped into a confined or semi-familiar space, expected to negotiate boundaries, manage arousal, and figure out who they are to each other — all at once, all in real time, with no exit ramp if things get weird. We wouldn’t do that to ourselves. (Well, most of us wouldn’t.)

Here’s a better analogy. Think about how you make friends as an adult. You don’t usually become best friends with someone by being locked in a room with them. You become friends by doing something together — a hike, a meal, a shared project. You build trust through shared experience, not through proximity alone. You have context. You have something to talk about. You have a reason to be there.

Dogs are the same way. Cooperation builds trust. Conflict — even minor, unresolved conflict — erodes it.

The Problem With Wrestle Play (Yes, Really)

Wrestle play looks fun. It can be fun. But it’s worth understanding what’s actually happening during those tumbling, mouthing, body-slamming sessions: the dogs are constantly negotiating. Every body slam, every pin, every mouthing gesture is a question — is this okay? What about this? And this? — and the answers have to come back clearly and quickly for the interaction to stay safe.

That works fine between two dogs who know each other well, who have a history, who have what I’d call a shorthand. Think of it like a secret handshake — something built over time. I have a 10-year-old corgi and a seven-year-old goldendoodle who used to hang out constantly when they were young. Now they see each other occasionally, and when they do, there’s a quick wag, a sniff, and then they’re ready to get on with the hike. Zero drama. Total trust. That’s the shorthand. They earned it.

But two dogs without that history? Wrestle play is a high-stakes negotiation with no established rules. If one dog misreads a signal, if one dog gets overstimulated, if one dog has a bad moment — now you’ve got a conflict. And repairing a relationship after a conflict is so much harder than building a solid one from the start.

The first interaction sets a tone. You want that tone to be: this is safe, this is calm, this is good.

Shared Activity Is the Secret

The reframe I use with my clients is this: stop trying to introduce dogs to each other and start introducing dogs to an experience together.

A walk is magic. A hike is magic. Moving together in the same direction, with shared purpose (sniffing that tree, investigating that smell, keeping up with the humans), takes the social pressure completely off. Dogs on a parallel walk aren’t staring each other down — they’re moving forward. Forward motion is decompressing. Forward motion says we’re on the same team.

The dogs don’t have to interact at all at first. They just have to exist in the same world, doing the same thing, at a comfortable distance. That’s it. That’s the foundation. And from that foundation, you can build almost anything.

The goal isn’t for your dog to love every dog they meet. The goal is for your dog to feel safe — and for you to feel confident that you’re setting them up for success, not hoping for the best.

Share

A Note on Age, Hormones, and Why Your Dog Isn’t Broken

Before we go further, it’s worth mentioning something that comes up constantly with my clients: age and hormonal status matter a lot in canine social dynamics.

A younger dog often wants to be in the action — sniffing everyone, bouncing off walls, recruiting anyone and everyone into a game. An older dog might be perfectly happy to acknowledge a new acquaintance and immediately move on. Neither of these is wrong. They’re different stages of life, with different social appetites.

What does matter: intact dogs (especially past seven or eight months) bring a hormonal variable that can turn an otherwise calm interaction sideways. In group settings like daycare or dog parks, intact dogs are generally not recommended in the general population for exactly this reason. Hormones, as a rule, make things complicated.

If your dog isn’t perfect around other dogs — reactive on leash, overly aroused, a little too enthusiastic about saying hello — that doesn’t mean they’re broken. It means they need a slower introduction protocol, a smarter setup, and a handler who knows how to read what’s happening and back off before things go sideways.

Which brings us to the good stuff.

How to Actually Do This: The Systematic Introduction Protocol

The following section is available to paid subscribers.

Here’s the step-by-step framework I use with my clients to build safe, positive canine introductions from the ground up. This is the protocol I rely on whether I’m working with a mildly over-aroused Lab or a more genuinely reactive dog. The principles are the same: distance is your friend, cooperation is the goal, and your dog should always feel like they have a choice.

Start With a Neutral Dog — Not the Dog

Before you introduce your dog to the family dog or your friend’s dog, we practice with what I call a neutral stimulus — a dog your dog already knows and likes. Think of it as a dress rehearsal. You’re not working on the actual relationship yet; you’re building the skill of calmly existing near another dog and staying connected to you. That skill transfers. Get it solid first.

All three approaches below use the same core logic: your dog should be able to take treats and respond to familiar cues at every step. The moment they can’t — the moment they’re staring, ignoring you, or refusing food — you’ve gone too far, too fast. Back up. Give distance. That’s not failure; that’s the protocol working exactly as designed.

Approach One: You Move Toward a Stationary Neutral Dog

Start 20–30 feet away. The neutral dog (and their handler) stands still. You and your dog begin moving toward them — not in a straight line, but in wide, slow zigzags. This matters. A direct approach is socially intense for dogs. Zigzagging signals I’m not a threat, I’m just passing through. It gives both dogs time to process.

As you move, ask your dog for familiar cues — a sit, a hand touch, a check-in — and mark and reward generously for calm, responsive behavior. Frequently back up to give your dog a break. The zigzag isn’t just spatial; it’s rhythmic. Approach, reward, back up, breathe.

Only decrease distance if your dog remains able to take treats and respond to you. If they go stiff, start scanning, or blow past your cues — back up and add distance. This isn’t failure; it’s information. Work at the distance where your dog is still a partner.

If the zigzag approach goes smoothly, you can try a more direct path. But earn it. Don’t assume it.

Approach Two: Moving Together

This variation adds movement on both ends — you and the neutral dog’s handler are both in motion, moving in wide arcs, circling around each other with generous space between. You can think of it as two boats giving each other a wide berth.

Same starting distance (20–30 feet), same cue-and-reward protocol, same rule: distance decreases only when your dog is fully responsive. The shared movement here actually helps — dogs often regulate more easily when everyone is moving, rather than one party standing still and “being stared at.”

Approach Three: Stationary Dog, Moving Neutral Person

This one flips the script. Your dog holds still (or holds position near you) while the neutral dog and their handler approach. Before you begin, establish what I call a safe cue — a word or signal that tells the approaching person to stop and back up. I like “Touch” or simply “Safe.” Your dog needs to know there’s an exit ramp. That knowledge alone reduces anxiety.

The neutral dog’s handler approaches in wide zigzags, same as before. You’re cueing your dog, rewarding for calm observation, and using your safe cue any time your dog shows stress signals — tight body, stiff tail, whale eye, inability to take treats. Back them off. Reward the recovery. Try again.

The goal isn’t for your dog to tolerate the approach. The goal is for them to feel genuinely okay with it.

What Success Actually Looks Like

Not: dogs greeting face-to-face, wagging, wrestling.

Yes: your dog taking treats near another dog. Your dog responding to their name. Your dog choosing to look at you rather than fixating on the other dog. Your dog’s body staying loose and soft. Your dog being able to disengage — look away, sniff the ground, check in with you — rather than locking onto the other dog with a hard stare.

Disengagement is a green flag. It means your dog trusts the situation enough to look away. That’s confidence. That’s the goal.

The Rules That Never Change

Distance is your friend. Use it generously. If your dog is staring fixedly, ignoring your cues, or not taking treats, you are too close — full stop. Back up. Don’t try to talk them through it, don’t wait it out, don’t hope they’ll snap out of it. Move.

Never pet or reach for a dog who is over threshold. The risk of redirection is real, and it can happen in a fraction of a second.

And perhaps most importantly: your dog should learn from every one of these sessions that they have choices — they can disengage, they can back up, they can check in with you — and that you will always be the predictor of good things. You become their safe zone. Not because you forced it, but because you earned it.

That’s the real goal of all of this. Not two dogs tolerating each other. Two dogs — and two humans — who trust that they’re in good hands.

Colorado Canine Consulting — Building stronger relationships through positive training methods.

I’m not talking about the Force from Star Wars. Although, for what it’s worth, I do think George Lucas was probably reading a lot of Taoism when he wrote that script. I’m talking about something much more attainable than that. Something rooted in physics, in habit, in the unglamorous and deeply human act of just showing up.

I’m talking about momentum.

Subscribe now

Pushing Uphill

Momentum is a strange thing. Think about pushing a stalled car on the side of the road. If you run at it with your full force, you’re just gonna smack into it. But if you stand there, your little body versus this huge hulking machine, and you just start gently pushing, something interesting happens. You build a rhythm. The car begins to rock forward and back, forward and back, and then all of a sudden you give it one good push and the car begins to roll. You dig your toes hard into the ground, lean your shoulder in, press with everything you’ve got, and it starts to move. And once it’s moving? It wants to keep moving. All of a sudden it takes almost no strength at all. It’s moving, baby.

Now you just need to keep pushing. It’ll roll and roll, so long as you’re on flat ground. Hit a hill and you’re going to have to dig in again. You might even get stuck. Slip and stop pushing and that car is going to stop. But you already know this, because this is not actually about a car. It’s a metaphor for life. And specifically, it’s a metaphor for your dog.

We’ve all been the person who stopped pushing

Think about anyone who’s ever tried to start working out regularly. First you go and everything’s great. Then an injury happens, or a scheduling conflict, or just a week that swallows you whole, and suddenly the habit is gone. Starting again feels almost harder than starting the first time. But once you do? You’re rolling. And once you’re rolling, it feels like you’ll never stop.

But inevitably, life happens. That’s not pessimism. That’s just the deal.

I see this play out constantly in my training programs. People come in skeptical, a little slow to get going, and before long they are on a roll. Their dog is different. They are different. They don’t want to stop. But then week six arrives and they graduate and despite whatever speech I give them, the only ones who keep the momentum going are the ones who sign up for the next class.

Does that sound like I’m trying to sell you a pyramid scheme? I promise I’m not. It’s accountability. People are genuinely terrible at holding themselves accountable. I include myself in that. A class gives you a community. People notice if you skip a week. The other puppies are lying down beautifully and your dog is staring at the ceiling and you can feel everyone looking at you. Shame is a surprisingly effective accountability partner, sadly.

I know you love your dog

Look, loving your dog is the easy part. Even when they’re less than perfect, especially when they’re less than perfect, there is love. I believe completely in the human animal bond. I think the relationship people share with their dogs is one of the most reliable and meaningful relationships we have. And right now, at a moment when we are more disconnected from each other than ever before, that bond has never mattered more.

We’ve over-indexed on our immediate circle. Our extended family has become our dogs. For a lot of people, that’s a beautiful thing: a reason to get outside, to meet neighbors, to build a little community around a shared love of these ridiculous animals we’ve invited into our homes.

But if you’re like millions of people, your dog’s behavior is quietly keeping you away from all of that.

Every dog I see with reactivity toward other dogs, toward kids, toward men in hats and beards: it creates distance. Think about the lady in the park with the reactive German Shepherd and the guy with the out-of-control Labrador who just wants to run up and say hello to everyone. These two should be fast friends. They’re both dog people who care deeply about their animals. Instead they’re mortal enemies. He doesn’t understand why his dog can’t just go say hi. She doesn’t understand how he doesn’t see that he’s about to undo four years of reactivity training she’s worked on relentlessly. Training that cost her what could have been a semester of college tuition. Just because his dog can’t read the room.

That’s the gap that lost momentum creates. And that’s the gap I want to help you close.

So how do you get things moving again?

You don’t sprint at it. You don’t wait for the perfect conditions. You just show up and start gently pushing. You build the rhythm. You find something that creates just enough accountability that stopping feels worse than continuing.

That might be a class. It might be a training partner. It might be putting a non-negotiable appointment on your calendar, one you genuinely cannot book over, and treating it like a date with your dog. Because that’s what it is. If you want to improve any relationship, you make time for it. This one is no different.

What I’ve learned after years of doing this is that the process matters infinitely more than the goal. Goals are just a compass. A practice, something you do consistently, something that becomes part of how you live: that’s the thing that actually changes your dog. Think about the difference between someone who goes to one yoga retreat and someone who has a yoga practice. One is an experience. The other is a life.

That’s what I want for you and your dog.

For paid subscribers

Your first one on one coaching session with me is completely free. We talk about your dog: where you are, what’s not working, where you want to be. Then we build a real training map together. Not generic advice. A specific plan with your dog’s name on it, and a follow up call two weeks later to make sure the car is still rolling.

That follow up is the secret. Knowing someone is going to ask changes everything. It’s the gentle push that keeps you from stopping.

One last thing before you go

I want to come clean about something. I have been training dogs professionally for a long time. I talk about it, write about it, teach it. And there have still been seasons of my own life where my dogs’ training fell completely apart. Not because I forgot how. Because life happened and I let the momentum die.

I’m not writing this from a pedestal. I’m writing it from the couch, same as you, with a dog who is currently staring at me with the focused intensity of someone who knows exactly where the treats are and is simply waiting for me to slip up.

We’re in this together. Now let’s get the car moving.

Heads up: July spots are opening

I’ll be accepting new online coaching clients starting in July and spots will be limited. If you’re not quite ready, you can join the waitlist and I’ll reach out when the doors open. But if you’re ready to go right now, upgrading to a paid membership jumps the line and locks in your free consultation immediately. No waiting, no wondering. Just you, your dog, and a plan.

Either way, I’d love to work with you. Let’s make July the time to get you rolling.

— Drew

From the day they came into your life, your dog has been watching you, cataloging you, learning the architecture of your moods and the meaning behind your movements. They know what it means when you put on your shoes. They know the difference between the coat you wear to take them out and the coat you wear when you leave without them. They know when you are happy and when you are sad and when you are pretending to be fine. They have become, over thousands of years of living at our sides, perhaps the most sophisticated readers of human behavior on the planet.

And most of us? We can barely read them at all.

But here is what is easy to miss in all of that. Your dog is not just watching you. They are listening to you. Deeply, carefully, neurologically. Not just the words you choose but the music underneath them. The pitch, the warmth, the conviction, or the total absence of it. Your voice is a rich stream of data, and your dog is processing every bit of it.

Here is what the science says. In 2016, a research team led by Attila Andics at Eötvös Loránd University in Budapest put dogs into an fMRI machine. Awake, untrained, lying still because they chose to, which is its own small miracle. The researchers watched what happened in the dogs’ brains while they listened to their trainers speak. What they found rewired how I think about communication.

Dogs have a left-hemispheric bias for processing the words we use. The left hemisphere, the same side humans use for language, lights up when dogs hear meaningful words versus meaningless ones. But here is the part that should give every trainer and every dog owner a long pause. The reward center of the dog’s brain only fully activates when both things line up. The right word, said with genuine warmth and praise. The meaning and the music.

Hollow praise is hollow. Your dog knows.

Subscribe now

Let’s Do Your Vocal Warm Ups!

Over twenty-plus years of training dogs, I’ve had a lot of conversations I didn’t expect to be having. One of the most common? Vocal coaching.

I cannot count the number of big, broad-shouldered men, the kind with voices that could narrate a nature documentary, who I’ve had to pull aside and say, very gently: we need to find your inner Fun Smurf. That deep, authoritative baritone that commands a boardroom? Your dog hears it and thinks something is wrong. Or worse, something is boring. When we want a dog to feel the joy of being praised, to feel the warmth of having done exactly the right thing, we need to sound like we mean it. High, bright, expressive, alive. Not professional. Not composed. Delighted.

The other end of the spectrum is just as common and just as tricky. Soft-spoken clients, often wonderful and naturally gentle people, sometimes deliver a recall cue that sounds less like a command and more like a suggestion whispered at a dinner party. “Come? Maybe? If you want to?” And the dog, standing at the far end of a field with its nose in something extraordinary, does a reasonable cost-benefit analysis and decides: hard pass.

The recall cue isn’t a request. It needs to carry weight. Not anger, never that, but clarity. Intention. The kind of vocal delivery that comes from your diaphragm, not your throat. The kind that says: this matters, I mean it, and something good is waiting for you when you get here.

Bellissimo

If you want to understand what I’m talking about in about thirty seconds flat, go watch any video of Claudia Fugazza working with her dogs.

Claudia is a researcher and trainer working with the Family Dog Project at Eötvös Loránd University in Budapest, the same remarkable research group behind the fMRI studies. She developed a training methodology called Do As I Do, which is worth an entire essay of its own: a beautifully structured approach to imitation-based learning that deepens the bond between dog and handler in ways that click-and-treat alone simply can’t replicate. But the reason I’m bringing her up here isn’t the methodology. It’s the moment she praises her dog.

“Bravo! Bravo!”

Watch the dog. Watch what happens in that animal’s body the moment Claudia’s voice lifts and opens up with genuine Italian expressiveness. The tail, the posture, the eyes, everything changes. The dog doesn’t just know it did something right. It feels it. The information is landing emotionally, not just cognitively.

I had the privilege of hosting Claudia at the University of Denver a few years ago, and I watched something beautiful happen in the weeks that followed. Students who had been fairly restrained in how they praised their dogs, technically correct, hitting their markers, running clean sessions, started to open up. More expression. More warmth. More presence in their communication. The dogs noticed. Of course, they noticed.

Subscribe now

What the Clicker Gave Us (And What It Quietly Took Away)

I want to be careful here, because I believe in the clicker as a useful training tool. Precision matters. Marking the exact moment of correct behavior is a genuinely powerful tool, and the science behind it is solid. But something happened in the culture of positive reinforcement training that I’ve been thinking about for a long time.

We got a little robotic.

When the clicker became the gold standard of the marker, some trainers, and I include myself in this early on, started to let the warmth leach out of the rest of the interaction. Click, treat, reset. Clean, efficient, effective. And increasingly... cold. The dog stopped being a partner and started feeling, at least from the communication side of things, like a subject in a study. A very well-fed subject. But still.

Here is something the research actually tells us. A team led by Cinzia Chiandetti at the University of Trieste took 51 pet dogs and trained them on a novel task using three different approaches: a clicker paired with food, a spoken word paired with food, and food alone. They expected to find the clicker group pulling ahead. It did not. All three groups learned equally well and generalized equally well to new situations. A few years later, Gilchrist and colleagues at Arizona State University ran three separate experiments across roughly 250 shelter puppies testing the same question in different ways, different behaviors, different levels of complexity, different distances. The result was the same. No reinforcement method outperformed any other. And in one of their experiments, there was a detail I find quietly remarkable: the food-alone group actually performed significantly better than the group trained with a verbal secondary reinforcer. Not because words don’t matter. But because a neutral, robotic, habituated voice may matter less than silence followed by a treat delivered right on time. That is a finding worth sitting with. The clicker is a delivery mechanism. The relationship and the communication around it are what carry the real weight. A warm, clear, well-timed verbal marker, the word bravo said like you mean it, is every bit as effective as a mechanical click. And it keeps you in the conversation. One caveot with the study, therse are shelter dogs not dogs living as companions in homes so the verbal marker didn’t have any significant relationship attached to it.

Dogs are not Skinner’s pigeons. They are not lever-pressing rats working through a variable ratio reinforcement schedule in isolation. These are animals who have been co-evolving with us for somewhere between fifteen and forty thousand years. They have developed, through that astonishing process of mutual selection, an almost uncanny sensitivity to human emotional expression. They read our faces. They track our gestures. They respond to our moods before we’re even fully aware we’re having them.

There is a wonderful post from Patricia McConnell reflecting on a seminar she attended with Ken Ramirez, the legendary trainer and Training Director at Shedd Aquarium, who has worked with exotic animals for over thirty years. Ken spoke about secondary reinforcers, the verbal praise and warmth we pair with primary rewards like food. His point was not that praise is magic. His point is that it has to be earned through real association and maintained over time. You cannot phone it in. You cannot let it go hollow. And the part that has stayed with me: animals respond with more enthusiasm and higher accuracy to trainers with truly clean, clear, committed communication. The quality of your cue, the quality of your praise, the quality of your presence in the moment all feed directly into the quality of the animal’s performance and their engagement with you. Ken sees this across species. I have seen it across twenty years of working with dogs and their people. I loved reading Patricia McConnell recounting lessons she learned from Ken, these are two of my trianing heros talking about how they take little tidbits from each seminar and apply them into their own methodology. This is what good synthesizers do. I regularly admit I am a mash up of everything I have ever read, seen or heard and I’ve never had an original thought in my career. I do keep seeking and synthesizing to my credit.

I believe a companion dog living by your side deserves more from us than a click and a piece of chicken. They need connection, so give it up. Years ago when my boarder collie started losing her hearing, I switched to a lot of verbal cues with her. Then I watched a video of me training her. I stopped talking to her, I had no expression on my face, just rigid clean hand signals. I thought I was being clever but I had taken all of my visual relationships out of my feedback. I started telling all clients with deaf dogs you have to talk to your dog out loud. Be authentic and treat them the same way you would any other dog with your praise.

Share

Humans Are Lazy Communicators

Humans are, on the whole, remarkably lazy communicators. We are so dependent on spoken language, on the words themselves, that we’ve become nearly blind to the enormous richness of the non-verbal channel that is available to us every single moment.

We miss tone. We miss prosody. We miss the emotional current running underneath the words. We miss what our bodies are saying while our mouths are saying something else entirely. And our dogs, who live in that non-verbal channel, are picking up everything we’re not saying, and often getting confused by the gap between the two signals.

Think about what it’s like from the dog’s perspective. You’re calling them in from the garden, and your words say “come here, good dog” but your voice is flat and distracted because you’re half-reading a text. Or you’re issuing a “sit” cue but your body is turned away, and your energy is somewhere else entirely. The words say one thing. Everything else says another.

The research from the Family Dog Project, one of the world’s leading centers for studying dog cognition and behavior, has shown us again and again that dogs are exquisitely attuned to human communicative signals. They follow our gaze. They respond to our emotional expressions. They synchronize with our social rhythms in ways that other animals, including our closest primate relatives, simply don’t. They are, in a very real sense, built to receive us, built for this conversation we’ve been having together across thousands of years.

The least we can do is show up to that conversation fully.

The Secret To Reconnecting

The next time you work with your dog, in a training session, a walk, or even just a moment of connection in the backyard, pay attention to what you’re actually transmitting. Not just the words. The whole signal.

When you praise them, mean it. Let it into your voice. Let your face do something. If your dog does something that genuinely delights you, let yourself be delighted, audibly, visibly, fully. It doesn’t have to be theatrical. It just has to be true.

When you deliver a cue, be present. Speak clearly and with intention. Not loudly, clarity isn’t volume. It’s the difference between a suggestion and a request, between mumbling and meaning it.

And when your dog does something spectacular, truly, joyfully, spectacularly right, for the love of everything, tell them so. Say bravo like you mean it. Because somewhere in that beautifully wired brain of theirs, both hemispheres are listening.

The Family Dog Project at Eötvös Loránd University continues to produce extraordinary research on dog cognition, communication, and the human-dog relationship. Their work is worth following closely. The 2016 fMRI study on word and intonation processing in dogs was published in Science (Andics et al., 2016) and is well worth a read, or at least the NPR coverage of it, which brings it down to earth beautifully.

Further Reading and Exploration

The science behind the fMRI study Andics et al. (2016), Neural mechanisms for lexical processing in dogs, published in Science. Read the study

NPR’s accessible take on the research A great entry point for anyone who wants the findings without the journal format. Their Masters’ Voices, NPR Health Shots

The Family Dog Project at Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest One of the world’s leading research centers on dog cognition, behavior, and the human-dog relationship. Visit the Family Dog Project

Duke Canine Cognition Center Fascinating research into how dogs think, learn, and read human cues. Explore the Duke Dog Lab

Patricia McConnell on secondary reinforcers and Ken Ramirez A thoughtful blog post reflecting on what Ken shared about the power, and the fragility, of verbal praise. Using Secondary Reinforcers: Wisdom from Ken Ramirez

Clicker vs. verbal marker vs. food alone: the research A clear and accessible summary of the Chiandetti et al. (2016) study, which found no difference in learning outcomes between a clicker, a spoken word, and food alone. Clicker Training vs. Treat: Equally Good in Dog Training

The original study Chiandetti, C., Avella, S., Fongaro, E., & Cerri, F. (2016). Can clicker training facilitate conditioning in dogs? Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 184, 109–116. View on ScienceDirect

A larger replication with three experiments Gilchrist, R.J., Gunter, L.M., Anderson, S.F., & Wynne, C.D.L. (2021). The click is not the trick: the efficacy of clickers and other reinforcement methods in training naïve dogs to perform new tasks. PeerJ, 9, e10881. Read the full study (open access)

Claudia Fugazza and Do As I Do training Watch Claudia work with her dogs and pay close attention to her verbal praise. That is the whole lesson right there. The Family Dog Project

Share Drew Webster's K9 to 5

There’s a viral video of an impala being caught by a jaguar. The jaguar has the impala in it’s jaws. It looks like it’s over. And then, interrupted by a hyena, the impala escapes it’s fate. The impal…

Read more

There’s a famous optical illusion called the Coffer Illusion. Two people look at the exact same image. One sees circles. One sees squares. Neither is wrong. Neither is lying. Their brains, shaped by …

Read more

I hear the same thing all the time. “I just don’t have time to train.” I get it. Somewhere along the way, we turned dog training…

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

Read more

We want them happy. We want them healthy. We want a home that feels good — for them and for us. And so we do what we’ve been told: we exercise them, we socialize them, we fill their lives with stimulation and activity. We try hard. We love them completely.

And still, something feels off. The house is chaotic. The dog is restless. The relationship carries a friction we didn’t expect and can’t quite name.

Here’s what I’ve come to understand after years of working with dogs of every temperament, background, and history: most of that friction doesn’t come from bad intentions. It comes from not yet knowing how to listen.

Dogs have needs — real, specific, deeply felt needs — and when we learn to recognize them, something remarkable happens. Caring for your dog stops feeling like management and starts feeling like a relationship. The paradigm shifts from control to understanding. From mastery to love. And from that place, creating a life of genuine wellness — for your dog and for yourself — becomes almost effortless.

There is something profound that happens when you slow down and pay close attention to the creature living beside you. You begin to notice things. The way they move. What settles them and what doesn’t. What lights them up. And in that noticing, you start to feel something that’s hard to articulate but impossible to ignore: the deep, quiet connectivity of all living things. Your dog isn’t a problem to be solved. They’re a being asking to be understood.

That’s what this is about.

One place to start: the well-meaning advice that a “tired dog is a well-behaved dog.” There’s a grain of truth in it — but exhaustion and calm are not the same thing, and chasing exhaustion as a strategy tends to backfire. Dogs are the most adaptable species on earth. When you consistently push a high-energy dog toward intense physical stimulation — rough play, daycare, fetch marathons — you’re not creating an outlet. You’re raising the floor. Their nervous system recalibrates around that level of arousal, and now you need more just to get back to neutral. What you intended as relief becomes the new baseline.

The good news? We can work with this. Dogs learn. They adapt. And every practice I’m going to share with you is going to use that adaptability in your favor — toward calm, resilience, and a dog you can genuinely take anywhere.

“If you can start the day without caffeine or pep pills, If you can be cheerful, ignoring aches and pains, If you can resist complaining and boring people with your troubles, If you can eat the same food every day and be grateful for it, If you can understand when loved ones are too busy to give you time, If you can overlook when people take things out on you when, through no fault of yours, something goes wrong, If you can take criticism and blame without resentment, If you can face the world without lies and deceit, If you can conquer tension without medical help, If you can relax without liquor, If you can sleep without the aid of drugs, Then you are probably a dog.”

― David Chernikoff

Subscribe now

Around the House: The Art of Stationing

Every single dog I’ve ever trained — from animals-assisted therapy dogs to dogs with severe aggression and anxiety — learns one foundational behavior before anything else: stationing and relaxation protocol.

A station is simple. A dog bed, a mat, a rug, a towel — any defined physical surface your dog learns to associate with settling. It becomes their anchor. Their safe place. The behavioral equivalent of “when in doubt, go here.”

Here’s how to build it:

Start by choosing a word or sound that marks the exact moment your dog does something right. “Yes!” works great. A clicker works great. The principle is the same: that sound means you nailed it, and food is coming within one second. Don’t overthink it.

Then, simply reward your dog for touching the mat. That’s it. Touch the mat — mark — treat. Once they’re seeking out the mat on their own, begin luring them into a down. I want to be clear: luring, not commanding. The goal isn’t a dog that lies down when told. The goal is a dog who sees their bed and wants to go lie down. We want the bed itself to feel like relief. Like a reward. Like home.

Read more

People ask me all the time for recommendations for board-and-train facilities. I always ask them first: what are your goals? What do you hope to accomplish…

Read more

Read more