CROCODILES DO NOT SWIM HERE

There is a saying among the crowd I roll with: Words mean shit.

Reading these signs, I am reminded of several other examples of humanity attempting to communicate with itself and somehow wandering into traffic:

SLOW CHILDREN PLAYING

SLOW DOWN CHILDREN

And now: CROCODILES DO NOT SWIM HERE

Armed with these fine examples of the English lexicon, one can only wonder whether the person charged with making the crocodile sign was operating with limited money, limited metal, limited wood, limited punctuation, or simply limited intelligence.

Admittedly, English is a confusing language. There is a children’s book that makes fun of this titled P Is for Pterodactyl: The Worst Alphabet Book Ever. It contains words that are pronounced almost nothing like they are spelled because English was apparently assembled during a bar fight by several languages that already hated one another.^[i]

We cannot surrender the English language to dumb motherfuckers. We must give it a fighting chance. A colon would have helped and so would changing the DO NOT SWIM HERE to bold red:

CROCODILES: DO NOT SWIM HERE.

That makes the sign a direct order to human beings.

A comma, however, produces an entirely different message:

CROCODILES, DO NOT SWIM HERE.

That makes it a direct order to the crocodiles.

Imagine some county employee walking down to the shoreline every morning with a clipboard to check for compliance.

“Dammit, Clarence. We have discussed this.”

(Clarence is our imaginary non-complying Crocodile)

Without the colon and bold red lettering, the sign becomes a statement of fact:

CROCODILES DO NOT SWIM HERE.

That makes me ask a dumbass question… If Crocodiles don’t swim, how the fuck do they travel?

Do they walk along the bottom? Take the bus? Carpool? Stand beside the lagoon waiting for tourists to come ashore?

Perhaps the crocodiles read the sign, accepted the jurisdiction of local government officials, and simply dipped the fuck out.

I only have what my eyes can see and a rapier wit.

WARNING: I may or may not continue to be an asshole.

Let us begin with some data.

The American crocodile is the only crocodile species native to the United States. Its American range is concentrated along the coastal areas of southern Florida, including the Everglades, Biscayne National Park, the Florida Keys, and surrounding coastal regions.^[ii]

I placed this swimming area somewhere in the Florida Keys.

A lot of tourists travel to the Keys, which creates an abundance of opportunities for stupid shit to happen. Tourists in sufficiently large numbers will eventually do something remarkably stupid because percentages demand it. Add oppressive heat, lots of sunscreen, expensive rum, rental cars, and the supernatural confidence of a man wearing an ill-fitting Hawaiian shirt he bought eighteen minutes earlier. Public math is relatively simple and I won’t insult you.

Crocodiles sleep, hunt, eat, mate, and shit in the same water tourists want to play in. To a crocodile, humans have entered its territory and willingly inserted themselves into the food chain. I am no sage… Shit is going to happen.

Think about this from the crocodile’s perspective.

On any given day, it may choose from fish, birds, snakes, turtles, and small mammals. Then suddenly, a 200-pound meat sack cannonballs directly into its hunting grounds, splashing and flailing like an enormous wounded animal while screaming:

“COME ON IN, BOB! THE WATER’S GREAT!”

Millions of years of predator-prey programming cannot be switched off simply because humans found a scenic lagoon with enough shade and scenery that strips them of their inhibitions, their clothing, and finds them naked swimming around and reconnecting with nature.

Oh boy, a reconnection is going to happen.

And… It may happen at roughly 3,000 pounds per square inch.

Nerd Data: American crocodiles living in South Florida and the Keys are generally smaller than the largest specimens found farther south. Big males can still grow beyond 13 feet, however, and exceptional animals elsewhere in the species’ range have been reported at considerably greater lengths, up to 20 feet and weights of 2,000 pounds.^[iii]

Muted cheering for us. We are still going to fucking die.

The exact maximums vary by source, but this distinction probably becomes academically unimportant when several hundred pounds of ancient reptile clamps onto your ass.

At that moment, nobody floating nearby is going to say:

“Relax, Steve. This individual appears to be slightly below the upper end of the species’ documented weight range.”

With all the truth laid at our feet, the absurdity of the sign does not escape me.

Maybe crocodiles really don’t swim there. Maybe they just got tired of our non-stop bullshit.

Humans are an insufferable fucking species. We wantonly kill one another for no reason, many reasons, justified reasons, unjustified reasons, imaginary reasons, religious reasons, political reasons, and reasons we invent after the bodies are discovered.

We have committed so many different varieties of killing that ordinary murder has become linguistically inadequate.

We have done so much fucking killing we have had to create a multitude of categories…I am not making this shit up:

Patricide: Killing one’s father.

Matricide: Killing one’s mother.

Filicide: Killing one’s child.

Fratricide: Killing one’s brother. The term is also used for military friendly fire.

Regicide: Killing a king or reigning monarch.

Genocide: The deliberate destruction of a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group.

Democide: The killing of people by their own government.

Suicide: Killing oneself.

Ecocide: The widespread destruction of the natural environment.

That is not merely a list of words.

It is the table of contents for human history. And this is not the entire list. I stopped because I wanted to finish this story before somebody invented a specialized term for killing a writer who would not shut the fuck up.

If you get the itch, search the subject yourself. The sheer number of words we have created to describe the ways we kill will blow your mind.

We kill fathers, mothers, brothers, sisters, children, friends, strangers, kings, political opponents, entire populations, the environment, and ourselves. Then we create increasingly sophisticated terms to file the bloodshed into its proper bin.

A crocodile has no such vocabulary.

It does not kill because of territory drawn on a map, wounded pride, political doctrine, religious disagreement, racial hatred, inheritance, revenge, nationalism, an insult on Facebook, or a goddamn argument over where someone parked.

It does not need propaganda.

It does not hold elections.

It has never developed a bureaucracy to determine which crocodiles may be legally eaten by other crocodiles.

A crocodile kills because it is hungry, threatened, or defending what millions of years of evolution taught it to defend.

It is cold-blooded by biology…not because someone posted a photograph of it on Instagram beside the words: “ABSOLUTE MONSTER.”

The crocodile is not cruel, because cruelty requires imagination.

But, humans… Humans have an almost limitless imagination.

We also have supermarkets. Crocodiles do not have the luxury of DoorDash or ordering ahead from Walmart and swinging by to have groceries loaded into the family SUV.

Crocodiles have the environment: lagoons, lakes, rivers, estuaries, and coastal water where saltwater meets fresh water. That is their grocery store, their bedroom, their neighborhood, and their entire known universe.

Then some sunburned asshole tourist carrying six rum punches, half a bottle of sunscreen, and the immortal confidence of a man who rented a luxury Airbnb for the weekend arrives and plunges directly into the meat department.

What the fuck does anyone expect?

The sign says:

CROCODILES DO NOT SWIM HERE.

For the sake of this story, maybe they don’t, maybe they walk.

Maybe they wait beneath the surface, silently observing the shoreline and wondering why the most destructive species on Earth is also the only one stupid enough to require written instructions not to become lunch.

Maybe the sign was never intended to warn us about the crocodiles.

Maybe it was put up for them.

An act of mercy from some nameless park ranger who understood the truth:

This was not one species warning its own.

It was one predator warning another.

HUMANS SWIM HERE.

They kill when they are not hungry.

^[i] P Is for Pterodactyl: The Worst Alphabet Book Ever - Kindle edition by Haldar, Raj, Carpenter, Chris, Beddia, Maria. Children Kindle eBooks @ Amazon.com.

^[ii] https://iere.org/which-states-have-crocodiles/

^[iii] American crocodile | Size, Habitat, Range, & Facts | Britannica

Leave a comment

Sometimes we are reminded how small and insignificant we are. This morning was one of those days.

The sun went black over eastern New Mexico.

I have never considered myself particularly superstitious. But I have lived long enough to develop a deep and profound understanding of my relationship with Lady Luck. If a meteor crosses six billion miles of empty space only to land somewhere in eastern New Mexico, there is a reasonable chance my truck is going to be smashed with me sitting in the driver’s seat.

When the sun turned black, I didn’t immediately jump to conclusions. I didn’t assume the old gods were angry. Never one to take things for granted, I just figured I was going to be blamed for this shit… BOHICA…somehow…somewhere… I had fucked up...again.

*Bend Over Here It Comes Again: BOHICA

For most of human history, that wouldn’t have been a joke, because the sun had one job.

Rise in the eastern sky. Burn like a motherfucker all day. Set in the west. Rise again.

It did that yesterday. It did it the day before. It had been doing it long before there was even a New Mexico.

If we actually give two shits about counting days…it has been doing this cycle eons before there was anyone standing here to give a shit.

The sun was the oldest promise we had…until the morning it wasn’t.

Daylight began to die right before my eyes.

I started to imagine myself standing beneath the sky and not knowing why this was happening.

Picture this: No astronomer had told you this was coming. Nobody had calculated the path of the moon. Nobody had told you exactly when the darkness would begin or promised you the light would return.

You only knew that yesterday there was a sun.

And now something was taking it away.

This scene unfolds real time: Your children are standing beside you along with your neighbors and all the people you love. Somewhere inside that gathering darkness is a question human beings have been asking since we first created gods to explain things we feared and didn’t understand…

…What did we do?

That is the forgotten part we don’t remember...time has dulled our senses…today we watch an eclipse knowing the light will return.

They didn’t.

And when people believed the heavens were speaking, they sometimes answered.

The Inca could interpret an eclipse as danger or divine displeasure. Their sacred world also included Capacocha, one of the empire’s most solemn sacrificial rites. Children chosen for their purity and status could be taken into the high Andes and offered at sacred places, including mountains called apus, where the human world met the divine.

Whatever else can be said about the ancient world, those motherfuckers took the gods seriously.

News Flash Bitches: We got off easy.

Fast-forward to eastern New Mexico this morning. No one screamed and made an ass of themselves when the sky darkened, started randomly praying to whichever god might still be taking calls, or ran into the street demanding that God explain Himself. Most importantly, no one had their children taken into the desert and offered at sacred places to appease an angered God.

Apparently, we had other shit to do.

As I looked around, people were doom-scrolling TikTok and Facebook, answering emails, arguing with strangers about nonsensical shit on their phones, and watching thirty-second videos of people they don’t know doing stupid shit.

What. The. Fuck. The sun disappeared and humanity had notifications to attend to.

Me? I stood beside the road with a cup of coffee in my hand and watched the moon cut the heart out of the sun.

There was still some light showing around the edges. It looked like a thin ring of fire was burning where the sun should have been.

All in all, that made looking at it worse.

Darkness I understand.

It lives in my heart and I fucking hate it.

I fight that demon every day.

War taught me something about darkness I wish I didn’t know.

There are places where the thing you are afraid of becoming is exactly the thing that gets you through alive. In war you feed it, give it room, become someone else. You learn to put things somewhere inside yourself because there isn’t time to understand them while people are trying to kill you.

You feed the monster because he is going to keep you alive.

Sometimes it works.

Then one day the shooting stops.

The darkness doesn’t.

I don’t live that life anymore.

At least not a sanctioned one.

My war is quieter now.

It is keeping that part of me locked away.

Maybe that’s why I recognize darkness so quickly when I see it somewhere else, and that’s why it scares me so badly.

I know what happens when you let it in.

Darkness is not our friend.

Out here, on the High Plains of New Mexico, we give it thousands of square miles.

Eastern New Mexico darkness is different. You have to spend some time on the Llano to understand that. After sunset, the horizon disappears…but the prairie doesn’t end. It simply stops letting you see it. On a moonless night, there are places outside Portales where the darkness simply swallows everything beyond the reach of your headlights. There are no mountains or trees worth mentioning… there isn’t a big city glow. There is absolutely nothing to tell you where the prairie ends and the sky begins.

Just distance… Miles of it swallowed by blackness.

Out here, darkness doesn’t fall. It absorbs the land.

It gathers in abandoned houses where curtains haven’t moved in over forty years. It settles into dry stock tanks and empty barns. It fills arroyos and forgotten wells. It stands beneath windmills that turn slowly when there isn’t enough wind to explain why they’re moving. It waits along fence lines that run straight toward nowhere and occupies the spaces where homesteads used to be.

Those places are the ones that bother me the most. You’ll see them if you know what you’re looking for. A broken foundation. A windmill. Three dead fence posts. Maybe a lilac bush growing where somebody’s front yard used to be.

Everything else is gone.

Houses… Barns… Families…their arguments…Sunday dinners…children running through the yard…Mothers standing in kitchen windows… The old man dying in the bed he was born in.

Gone.

But the darkness stayed.

After dark, you can drive past one of those places and feel something tug at the primitive part of your brain.

You don’t stop.

You keep driving.

Your headlights illuminate maybe two hundred feet of highway ahead of you, and beyond that little tunnel of light is an entire prairie you cannot see. That’s when the imagination starts doing what imagination has done since human beings first gathered around fires.

Something could be standing out there.

Ten feet beyond the headlights.

Watching.

You tell yourself, don’t be a whiny little bitch…grow the fuck up…sack up motherfucker or some other testosterone laden mantra to soothe your nerves. It could any number of things… Coyotes. Cattle. Fence posts. Mesquite. Shadows. There is an explanation for everything… There usually is…

…Still...you don’t pull over.

Because there is another rule people who spend enough time in empty country like eastern New Mexico eventually learn:

You don’t have to believe something is out there to know better than to go looking for it.

I have driven those roads after midnight. I know that darkness. And you can bet your sweet ass I respect that darkness. As a matter of fact, I fucking fear that darkness.

But this morning was different.

This morning darkness violated the arrangement.

It came out in daylight.

I stood beside the road with coffee in my hand and watched it climb into the eastern New Mexico sky. There was still light around it. That was the part that bothered me. A thin ring of fire remained where the sun should have been. It was almost perfectly bright (if there is such a thing) and it was burning around a black center so complete that staring at it awakened something primal in me.

My mind knew exactly what I was seeing.

Moon. Sun. Earth. Orbit. Shadow. Physics.

My body didn’t give a shit.

Every ancient alarm buried beneath sixty years of life was telling me the same thing:

Do not look at that.

So, of course, I looked at it… yep…me…fuck… Humanity in one sentence.

The longer I stared, the less it resembled something covering the sun. The black center was too round. Too complete. Too still.

It looked like a pupil.

That’s when the thought entered my mind. No thunder and lightning…no voice. No revelation. Just one quiet thought that arrived fully formed and immediately made me wish it hadn’t.

Maybe the darkness wasn’t coming from the eclipse.

I lowered my coffee.

The prairie had settled…everything had stopped moving. Everything was eerily still…and suddenly I understood why.

The darkness wasn’t looking down at eastern New Mexico.

Eastern New Mexico was looking back.

Then the birds stopped making noise…not slowly...all at once.

That was when shit got real.

I hadn’t noticed them before.

Did you know that you rarely notice ordinary sounds until they disappear? That is because nature doesn’t give a shit about you or me.

But this is where things gets turned around. I don’t think the world had become silent just to be a dick. I think it went silent to become attentive.

I thought about the stop sign beside me.

STOP.

Stop driving. Stop talking. Stop naming. Stop pretending. Stop believing the world requires your understanding before it is allowed to exist.

For once in your brief, ridiculous life:

Stand Still.

I stood still beneath the black sun…and something happened that I will not be able to prove.

Nothing moved.

Nothing appeared.

No voice came from the sky.

No dead rancher stepped from behind a windmill.

No ancient thing crawled from beneath the caliche.

I fucking wish something had.

Monsters are comforting. A monster gives fear a body. You can shoot a monster. Run from it. Lock the door against it. Pray against it.

You can at least name the goddamn thing.

What frightened me was the possibility that nothing was there at all.

That the universe was exactly what science tells us it is.

Vast.

Ancient.

Violent.

Beautiful.

Indifferent.

And how is it that we had somehow convinced ourselves this was less terrifying than gods?

A god might hear you.

The universe doesn’t have to.

In our world, there are people who can and will tell you exactly what happened.

They have diagrams, know the distances, and understand angles. They can tell you where the moon was, where the earth was, where the sun was, how fast everything was moving, and year and day it will happen again.

I believe them…every word. Science works.

The moon passed between us and the sun.

That’s what happened.

But knowing how a door opens doesn’t tell you what’s standing behind it.

Human beings have always struggled with that distinction. We name something and think we have conquered it. Lightning. Cancer. Gravity. Death. Give the terror a Latin name and suddenly we can sleep again.

An eclipse.

There, now we have nothing to worry about. It is just celestial bodies moving according to laws older than life itself.

No reason to lose sleep over this…it is all predictable and perfectly natural…. But…

…So was the asteroid.

Long before there was a New Mexico, the prairie was here. Long before the United States declared themselves a sovereign nation, the prairie was here. Before Spain crossed the Atlantic Ocean and planted its flag in someone else’s dirt, the prairie was here. Before the first church bell called for men to kneel, the prairie was here. Before the first fence post declared that one patch of eternity belonged to one man and another patch belonged to someone else…

The prairie was already here.

Then we arrived.

We brought: Flags. Bibles. Rifles. Deeds. Survey chains. Barbed wire.

We hammered stakes into ancient ground, then drew straight lines across a land that had never needed them, and decided those lines made it ours.

Then we gave everything names and put them on maps, as though the prairie had been waiting all those millions of years for us to arrive and straighten out the paperwork.

We divided it into sections, townships, counties, states, and Native American nations. We recorded the boundaries in courthouse books. We argued over them. Fought over them. Killed over them.

Eventually, we buried ourselves inside the lines we drew.

The quiet part out loud? The prairie never signed anything… It simply waited.

The prairie was here...and is still here. Thirty-two thousand square miles of High Plains stretching farther than the eyes can see. Coronado crossed it and struggled to describe the emptiness. I am not even sure his language had words to describe places where a man could travel for days without finding anything tall enough to measure himself against.

That does something to people.

Mountains give you something to look at. Trees break up the horizon. Cities fill every empty space with buildings, streetlights, traffic, and enough noise to keep you from thinking too hard about where the hell you are.

The Llano doesn’t give you any of that.

Out here, there is nothing between you and the horizon.

No mountains.

No forests.

No place for your eyes to stop.

Just dirt beneath your boots and a sky so goddamn big you can damn nearly feel yourself disappearing underneath it.

That’ll cure a man of thinking he’s important.

Maybe we started putting up fences, not to contain cattle, but to reassure ourselves.

This belongs to me. That belongs to you. Here is my road. Here is my house. Here is my church. Here is my county. Here is my country.

Here is my God.

We drove fence posts into the dirt, stretched barbed wire between them, and then told ourselves that meant something.

The prairie watched.

The prairie is good at watching.

It watched the buffalo disappear. It watched Comanche horses disappear. It watched homesteads rise from the dirt and collapse back into it. It watched families arrive carrying Bibles, seeds, children, and the stubborn belief they were going to make a home out of this place.

Some survived… Some left.

Some buried children beneath cottonwoods that have long since died themselves.

For many, their houses are gone, their barns have collapsed under their own weight, their names are slowly disappearing from headstones, worn away by wind, sand, and time. Sometimes the only thing left is a line of fence posts leading to a house that hasn’t been there for fifty years.

The prairie never needed to defeat them.

It simply waited… That is the terrible advantage of the land.

It has more time than we do.

Maybe that is why old places frighten us. Not because they remember the dead.

Because they remember when the dead were alive.

They remember the hammer striking the first nail. The first baby crying inside the house. The first supper placed on the table. The first grave dug behind the church. They remember the people who stood on their porches and looked across the prairie believing there would always be another morning.

Then one morning there wasn’t.

The prairie remained.

It always remains.

Our ancestors wouldn’t have understood what happened that morning.

They couldn’t explain the eclipse.

But they understood what it meant to be humbled by something bigger than themselves.

They knew there were moments when a human being should shut the hell up and stand still.

We have forgotten how.

We narrate everything. Births. Deaths. War. Grief. Dinners. Fucking hell, we photograph funerals. We livestream disasters. We turn somebody else’s suffering into clicks, views, followers, and money before the goddamn blood has even dried.

If God Himself split the sky tomorrow and lowered one burning hand through the clouds, somebody would yell:

“Hold on, I need to get this vertical.”

Maybe that’s our problem.

We don’t know how to witness anything anymore without making ourselves part of it.

Gods. Death. Grief. War.

Even a black sun.

Everything becomes something to photograph, post, share, monetize, argue about, or scroll past on the way to the next fucking thing.

And here I was, narrating it too.

That thought shut me up.

About then, the sun began returning…one sliver at a time.

A blade of light appeared along the darkness. Then another. The black circle slowly moved away and the prairie began coming back with it.

A bird called somewhere behind me… Then another… Wind moved through the grass.

I wasn’t ready for ordinary yet, so I stayed beside the road a little longer. My coffee had gone cold. Above me, the sun was slowly becoming the sun again.

Fence. Mesquite. Road. Sky.

Everything returning to where we had decided it belonged.

Or…it appeared to.

Nothing had actually changed. The universe had followed its laws. The astronomers had been right. No gods had descended. No mountains had demanded blood. No ancient thing had crawled out of the caliche.

The sun had returned.

Science had won.

I was almost disappointed… Almost.

I looked at the stop sign one last time.

STOP.

Then I got into my truck, started the engine, and put the cold coffee in the cup holder.

That was when I noticed the jackrabbit.

It stood beside the fenceline maybe thirty yards from the road. It was perfectly still. I watched it for a few seconds.

It didn’t move. I expected it to bolt when I put the truck in gear.

It didn’t.

The birds had started calling again. The wind had returned. Traffic moved along the highway. The world had resumed being the world.

But the jackrabbit remained beside the fence.

Watching.

Not the sun.

The prairie.

I followed its gaze… There was nothing there.

All I could see was: Grass. Fence posts. Mesquite. And miles of High Plains.

Miles and miles of eastern New Mexico.

Nothing I hadn’t seen a thousand times before.

I looked back at the rabbit. It hadn’t moved.

For reasons I still can’t explain, I considered getting out of the truck. Just for a second or two...maybe walking over to the fence...maybe figuring out what the hell had its attention.

My hand reached for the door handle…Then I stopped myself. I remembered something.

Something every person who spends enough nights driving empty roads out here knows.

You don’t have to believe something is out there to know better than to go looking for it.

I took my hand off the door and drove home toward Portales.

The jackrabbit remained beside the fence, watching the prairie.

I never saw what it was looking at…maybe there wasn’t anything there at all.

I’ll never know.

The sun had returned. The birds were calling. Somewhere ahead of me people were buying groceries, pumping gas, answering phones, and getting on with the ordinary business of being alive.

Everything was back where we thought it belonged.

The moon had crossed the sun exactly when the astronomers said it would. The darkness had come exactly when they predicted. It had lasted exactly as long as their calculations said it would.

They had been right about everything.

As I drove, my thoughts drifted back to those ancient people standing beneath a black sun with their children beside them, watching daylight disappear and wondering what they had done to anger the gods.

Science tells us differently today.

We know the gods aren’t angry. We know the distances, the angles, the orbits. We can calculate when the darkness will come and, more importantly, when the light will return.

Hell, we even know how the door opens...

...and not a damn thing about why some part of us is still afraid to look through it.

I looked one last time in the rearview mirror.

The jackrabbit was gone. So was the fence. The road behind me had narrowed into the distance until there was only prairie.

Ancient.

Patient.

Waiting.

For thousands of years, human beings have looked into the darkness and given names to whatever they feared might be looking back.

Spirits.

Demons.

Gods.

Eventually we stopped believing in them.

Maybe belief was never part of the arrangement.

Truth is...whatever is out there doesn’t give a damn what we believe.

Leave a comment

Prologue

The New Mexico prairie was old well before people started naming pieces of it. Before Portales became a town… Before Clovis became a town… Before wagon wheels carved ruts across the Llano and called them roads, millennia before fences were built by men believing they could divide something that never really belonged to them in the first place.

Wind crossed this country then, exactly as it does now… combing the grass, humming through fence wires, rattling listless windmills, and carrying caliche from one end of the Llano to the other, without ever caring whose name happened to be on the deed that year. It polished old bones white beneath the unforgiving sun and bent the grama with patient hands.

The prairie did the remembering.

The New Mexico prairie is not just a place; it is a memory. It remembers the Ancestral Harvests, the Spanish herds, the Pueblo Revolt, the Navajo migrations, and the resilience of generations of settlers who labored on its soil. Its grasses, sagebrush, and wind hold these stories close… The prairie always remembers…because people don’t.

I’ve also learned most places never write down the stories that made them.

Every one of them seems to carry something the maps don’t. You won’t find it in a courthouse archive or a history book either. What you will do is hear about it in the local diner where the waitresses won’t pour you another cup of coffee if you’re headed west just before noon. Or folks will talk about the UPS delivery driver who leaves thirty minutes early every Thursday, even though his route hasn’t changed over the last fifteen years.

Out here, you learn that making sense of something and living with it are two different things.

I’d been surveying Roosevelt County roads for twenty-eight years before Eddie Salazar mentioned the daytime ghost. It wasn’t what he said that bothered me. It was how ordinary he made it sound. He never looked up from his coffee… Never smiled at me or made eye contact to see if I believed him. He talked like the ghost was just another part of the county, like caliche roads and cattle guards. I remember thinking I’d spent almost three decades mapping the eastern side of this state and I didn’t know anything about this story.

We were sitting beneath the equipment shed behind the county yard, drinking coffee that had been on the burner since sunrise. Just three road hands gathered beneath a ribbon of shade still clinging to the concrete… Beyond it, the caliche shimmered until fence posts bent and the county road seemed to float.

Eddie folded a county map along an old crease and stated flatly, “You’ll see him today.”

I looked up from my cup. “See who?”

“The man on County Road U.”

“What man?”

“The daytime ghost.”

I snorted coffee through my nose.

“One of you boys been into the whiskey?”

I didn’t get an answer…they just looked at me.

Eddie slid the map beneath one hand and looked toward the prairie. Heat shimmered above the machinery. Beyond the yard, the Llano unfolded beneath a pale blue sky polished by generations of relentless sun.

“I don’t believe in ghosts,” I said.

He shrugged. “You ever seen the wind?”

“I’ve felt it.”

“That’s not what I asked.”

I opened my mouth, then shut it again.

Eddie smiled into his coffee.

“We only ever see what the wind carries.”

That should have been enough warning.

By 11:45 a.m. the other two guys suddenly found “reasons” to not travel with me to County Road U. Both gave terrible excuses: paperwork supposedly forgotten in Portales, and a power steering leak that didn’t exist ten minutes earlier.

Nobody told me not to go… They just made damn sure they weren’t going with me.

County Road U was less of a road and more of an old disagreement between men and weather. Caliche drifted across the cracked asphalt in pale ribbons the county grader could never quite erase. Needle grama and buffalo grass crowded the shoulders as though the prairie had grown tired of waiting for permission to reclaim them.

Broken fence wire sagged between cedar posts bleached almost silver by generations of relentless sun, each strand answering with a low metallic hum whenever the wind remembered its name. Telephone poles marched toward the horizon in perfect intervals until the distance consumed them one by one, creating an illusion the road continued somewhere worth going.

The old McAfee place had stood a mile west of there, though you would never have known it without the county plat book. The county map still carried a penciled square and a family name. The prairie remembered both the way it remembered buffalo trails, dry creek beds, and fallen fence posts; It had never considered one more permanent than the other.

The house burned down in the summer of 1974. The barn surrendered to the prairie a few winters later. The windmill turned until its bearings finally seized, then spent the next forty years rusting towards the earth one slow season at a time. Lilac bushes bloomed every spring where the front porch used to be, because flowers remember foundations long after people forget addresses. The road was still there… The ranch wasn’t.

Where there should have been a barn, a windmill, and a stand of cottonwoods against the horizon, there was only open prairie beneath the noon sun.

The road simply kept going west, as though it was still expecting someone to come home.

I eased the county truck onto the shoulder beside an old cattle guard whose timbers had been polished smooth by decades of truck tires and cattle hooves. When I stepped onto the prairie with my survey rod, the silence reached me before the heat did.

There was no wind… That bothered me.

Twenty-eight years surveying the Llano teaches you that silence isn’t natural. There’s always wind somewhere, humming a tune through fence wire, or rattling an old gate that hasn’t hung straight since Eisenhower was president.

That afternoon the silence was deafening.

The grass stood motionless.

The fence wire held its tongue.

Even the dust refused to move.

The sun stood directly overhead… My shadow collapsed beneath my boots until only a dark stain remained, with nowhere left to run. Above me, the pale blue sky stretched from one edge of the Llano to the other. Heat lifted from the road in slow, transparent waves, making telephone poles waver, bending fence posts, and coaxing the horizon upward until the prairie itself appeared to breathe.

Out here, distance has spent thousands of years making liars out of good eyes.

That was when I saw him.

About a half mile away, an old rancher crossed the prairie with the slow, deliberate gait of a man who had spent his entire life measuring distance against the weather instead of clocks.

His hat had once been black. The sun had argued with it for so many summers neither could remember who was winning. Its brim had softened and curled beneath the rain, sweat, and pressure of one hand lifting it from his head at gravesides and kitchen doors. His denim shirt had faded into the same blue gray as distant rain that promised itself to the horizon but rarely honored the agreement. Leather gloves hung from his back pocket, stiff with caliche and years of hard work.

He carried a dented aluminum lunch pail polished smooth where one calloused hand had gripped it through decades of broken windmills, stubborn cattle, snapped wires, dry wells, and mornings that began hours before daylight kissed the prairie.

His boots looked less like something he had worn and more like something the land had slowly grown around his feet. Caliche filled every crease…each scuff earned. The heels were worn down by a thousand trips between barns, gates, corrals, and houses that had now returned to dirt.

Nothing about him appeared haunted.

Everything about him appeared worked.

Worked raw by the sun and wind.

Worked bone dry by drought.

Worked to death by grief.

Worked by people who remembered his labor long after they’d forgotten his name.

He walked the way old ranchers walked, carrying the stubborn belief that if they put up one more fence, dug one more well, and mended one more gate, the prairie might finally agree to become a home instead of a wilderness.

The prairie remembered where he had walked... His name had long since blown away.

Fence posts had rotted into gray splinters… Windmills had lost their blades… Homesteads had settled back into the earth until little remained but broken foundations and lilac bushes growing where somebody’s yard used to be. The mailboxes were the last to lose the fight… Names peeled away in the heat, the last stubborn proof that someone had once lived here.

Yet, the old rancher continued walking exactly as though the land still expected him to finish before supper.

Not towards a house, a barn or a truck.

Just walking… a steady, patient pace.

Like somewhere beyond the shimmer waited one last gate with his name on it.

I raised my hand… He stopped, and for a moment neither one of us moved. Then he tipped his hat. Nothing more... Just the ordinary courtesy of one working man acknowledging another across open country.

Then… He resumed walking.

For one impossible heartbeat, he did not look like a ghost crossing the prairie.

He looked like the last honest man who had ever kept a promise he made to it.

The heat shimmer drifted between us… The horizon breathed… Then, the old rancher simply was not there anymore.

The prairie gave no sign that anything had changed… Neither did the wind.

I don’t know how long I stood there…but then I just went back to work.

The survey rod felt familiar in my hand. Numbers remained numbers. Distances remained distances. The road still ran north and south. The fence was still eleven feet from the easement marker.

On my way back to Portales, I stopped at a ranch a few miles east of County Road U. The house stood beneath a cluster of cottonwoods whose leaves had turned their pale undersides toward a wind I still could not feel. An older woman opened the door before I reached the porch.

“You saw him,” she said.

It was not a question.

“The rancher?”

She nodded.

“I waved.”

“He always waves back.”

“Who is he?”

She looked beyond me toward the pasture.

“There hasn’t been a ranch over there since the McAfee place burned.”

“I just watched a man cross it.”

“I know.”

“Was he a McAfee?”

She looked at me for a long time.

“Might have been.”

“You don’t know?”

“Knowing his name wouldn’t change what you saw.”

“Why doesn’t anybody talk about him?”

“They do.”

“When?”

A small smile moved across her face.

“After dark.”

I laughed, thanked her, and headed back to Portales. Every measurement I’d taken that afternoon had checked out. The only thing left to doubt... was myself.

That evening I spread the survey photographs across my kitchen table.

Fence lines.

Power poles.

Drainage culverts.

Section markers.

Every picture looked exactly as I expected… Until the fourth frame.

There I stood beside the survey rod. Half a mile behind me, the old rancher stood beside a weathered gate that leaned against nothing. His hat was pulled low. His lunch pail hung from one hand. He was looking directly into the camera.

Not at me… At the camera.

I reached for the next photograph.

Different road… Different fence line.

Nearly two miles farther south, the rancher stood beside the same gate. I laid another photograph beside it.

Different pasture.

Different section.

Same gate.

Same man.

Same lunch pail.

I moved through the stack. The next photograph showed a drainage culvert three miles east.

Same gate.

The next showed a section marker near an abandoned well.

Same gate.

Another showed the highway shoulder with my truck parked in the distance.

Same gate.

It wasn’t the rancher.

It was the gate.

I had driven more than twelve miles that afternoon. That gate had no business appearing in every photograph.

That gate had no business existing at all.

I unfolded the county plat map across the table and found the old McAfee property. A penciled square marked where the ranch house had once stood. A faded line indicated the original road. Near the western boundary, somebody had drawn a gate.

The fire took the house.

The wind took the barn.

The prairie took everything else.

Except the part that still expected a man to come home before supper.

I gathered the photographs into a neat stack and returned them to their envelope. I never showed them to anyone. I already knew what they would say.

The gate in the photograph stood exactly where the old plat said it should.

There wasn’t a gate there when I took the picture.

I have been retired six years now. Folks chalk it up to worn-out knees, a bad back, and too many miles under the New Mexico sun. I let them believe their own stories. Their explanations are easier to carry than mine. But…every now and then, somebody asks why I don’t drive county roads around lunchtime anymore. I tell them the heat gets to me. The conversation usually ends there.

People tell ghost stories after sunset because darkness gives them permission to believe impossible things. Out here, the prairie has never needed permission to do anything. It buries roads beneath drifting caliche, wears fence posts smooth with the wind, and remembers every boot that ever crossed it. The dead have always known that… They don’t wait for midnight.

They wait until the sun stands directly overhead, when nobody thinks of looking for them.

That’s why nobody believes in daytime ghosts.

The prairie never forgot him.

We did.

Leave a comment

Like clockwork, every morning we find the world waking up, scratching itself in all of its itchy places, then plugging themselves in to the internet, and going to work inventing more hilarious, yet, untrue historical facts.

Today’s victim was none other than Sun Tzu, the Chinese military general, strategist, philosopher and writer who is traditionally credited as the author of The Art of War, the world-famous classic on military strategy.

I opened my social media account and… There it was…. A solemn statue… A black background… An inspirational font (it was well done too).

“Anyone can piss on the floor. It takes a real man to shit on the ceiling.” Sun Tzu, The Art of War.

What. The. Fuck. There were forty-seven thousand shares and twenty-one thousand comments… Someone said four history professors had simultaneously slammed their foreheads into identical desks and gotten concussions.

I must have blacked out on freedom when I read The Art of War, because I had somehow missed that chapter…or I had bought the NSFW copy and didn’t get the adult version.

So… I bought another copy of The Art of War.

Again… WTF?

Chapter One…. Laying Plans.

Chapter Two…. Waging War.

Chapter Three... Attack by Stratagem.

There was no Chapter Twelve: Tactical Defecation.

There was no Appendix B: Achieving Ceiling Altitude.

And there were No illustrations… I want pictures… I felt cheated.

Then, three nights later, I was kicked in the ass and shaken violently awake by someone standing over me looking utterly fucking exhausted.

“You motherfuckers are impossible,” he sighed.

“I’ve been dead for almost twenty-five hundred years… ever think to leave me the fuck alone?”

“…holy shit…Sun Tzu, it’s you… You invented psychological warfare,” I said.

He looked at me like he was contemplating kicking me again… “No shit.”

“So...” I pointed toward the meme. “...did you say it?”

He pinched the bridge of his nose.

“No.”

“But...”

“No.”

He reached into his robes and pulled out an ancient bamboo scroll.

Across the top it read: The Lost Fourteenth Chapter

My heart started to pound… here it is… History was about to change… The scroll unfurled… There was one sentence.

“People will believe dumb shit if you put it beside a statue and use bold white letters.”

I blinked… “That’s it?”

Sun Tzu nodded and looked at me like I was a complete fucking idiot.

“It has become my greatest victory.”

He wasn’t wrong... I checked all of my social media accounts, Facebook… Instagram… X…

Someone had already posted:

“Never trust a man who reheats fish in the office microwave.” Sun Tzu.

The count was already at seventy-eight thousand likes.

I hit the refresh button.

“A warrior who replies ‘per my last email’ has already chosen violence.” Sun Tzu.

Holy shit… there were ninety-four thousand shares.

I hit the refresh button again.

“The dildo of consequences rarely arrives lubricated.” Sun Tzu.

I couldn’t believe the count… Three hundred thousand reactions.

Sun Tzu stared at my phone… “I never said any of that.”

My phone dinged… Another notification popped up…

“Live. Laugh. Leave no witnesses.” Sun Tzu.

Sun Tzu looked at me like he was ready to die a thousand more deaths.

“I spent decades studying logistics, terrain, deception, discipline, and leadership.”

I just sat there taking face shots for all of humanity.

“Instead, you’re remembered as the patron saint of bathroom graffiti.”

He closed his eyes… “I should’ve burned the manuscripts.”

Before disappearing, he offered me some words of advice.

“Never interrupt your enemy while he’s confidently quoting bullshit from the internet.”

Then he vanished… I looked down at my phone.

Someone had provided a citation to the original meme… Page 247.

There are only 109 pages in my copy.

In a nod to Sun Tzu, I acknowledge humanity continues to conquer new frontiers in strategic stupidity.

Which, when you think about it...

...is the highest form of vertical dominance

Leave a comment

Lucifer had survived falling out of Heaven, exorcists, televangelists, and the 1970’s disco craze…. but… nothing prepared him for County Road 13, a few miles outside of Portales, New Mexico.

It was a moonless night, the kind that is as dark as a well digger’s ass, when the green and blue lights started flashing out of nowhere.

Lucifer’s pickup stalled… Then the radio exploded…

“...Well,” he muttered. “...this can’t be good.”

Three hours later, a massive light shot his spasming ass back onto the prairie like a kid spitting a watermelon seed in contest at the County Fair.

He looked like a bag of ass that had seen better days.

One of his horns was broken completely off, the other was tattooed pink, and his tail had been braided into something that looked suspiciously feminine.

He slowly folded himself back into his truck with the slow, movements of a man who might or might not have been recently emasculated.

To make matters worse, New Mexico roads suck donkey dick and are not well maintained at all…. Every pothole between County Road 13 and Highway 70 became a personal insult to his entire lower region.

To his credit, he didn’t act like a bitch and cuss or whimper once…well maybe once or fifteen times, but no more than that.

By the time Lucifer got back to the office he was limping like a bitch.

Unfortunately, Hell noticed that shit pretty much immediately.

A demon asked him, “Hey…Boss... why are you walking funny?”

Lucifer kept moving, ignoring the question…. “... Fuck off dickhead.”

“Boss, for real… You’ve been standing through every meeting.”

“I prefer to stand up, mind your own fucking business.”

The demon kept pressing, “Me and the other demons just got to noticing you brought your own cushion.”

“Eat a dick… I like lumbar support.”

The look Lucifer gave the demon convinced the room the game of 20 questions was over.

That still didn’t change the fact that Lucifer wasn’t sitting down anytime soon.

Lucifer moved through Hell like a man avoiding anything with a geometric design… it was as if everything with an angle was a threat to his backside and he was triaging the shit out of it.

Demons watched him (while trying not to bust out laughing) hover over a chair at a conference table… it was like he was afraid the fucking thing might bite him.

“Boss… you’re standing weird.”

“Fuck you… stop looking at my ass… I’m standing normal.”

“You’re leaning weird like you’ve got scoliosis.”

“It is called posture discipline… it’s good for the spine”

Nobody in hell bought that shit.

Three days later, a chupacabra found Lucifer sitting on an upside-down five-gallon bucket beside an abandoned windmill.

The prairie was deathly quiet except for the rusty squeak of old windmill bearings cranking from the wind.

The chupacabra eased his way over to Lucifer and sniffed the air… something smelled suspiciously like some kind inflammation ointment.

Without giving anything away, the chupacabra innocently asked, “Hey, the bucket more comfortable?”

Lucifer never looked up… He just growled at the chupacabra, “Mind your own goddamn business.”

The chupacabra studied him for a moment.

“They get you pretty good, huh?”

Lucifer lit another cigarette…

“...I said mind your own goddamn business.”

“Fair enough.”

They sat in silence for a long time.

Dust blew shit all over and the bearings continued to squeak. Lucifer just sat there smoking… staring out on the horizon… not saying a word… it was like doing anything else would just kill him twice.

A tumbleweed rolled past… like it had somewhere else better to be.

Finally, the chupacabra broke the silence.

“You ain’t looked right since Roswell.”

Lucifer exhaled a long stream of smoke and locked eyes with the chupacabra.

“Roswell has nothing to do with it.”

The chupacabra froze...

“...You mean...”

Lucifer closed his eyes… “Don’t finish that sentence.”

The chupacabra swallowed… was it, “County Road 13?”

Lucifer’s eyelid twitched… the chupacabra knew.

“…Those little gray bastards.”

Neither of them spoke for another ten minutes.

Some stories don’t need details… They need a bucket.

To this day, whenever someone claims they were abducted by aliens, Lucifer doesn’t laugh...

He simply nods once... and hands them some ointment.

Leave a comment

Pangram reminds me of a real shitty B-series science-fiction movie where the machine believes it is the smartest motherfucker ever created.

The Terminator.

HAL 9000.

The Matrix.

Every one of them suffered from a flawed assclown posing as a threat.

These assholes mistook pattern recognition for a LLM understanding… it was coded by a human to identify other humans as “slop” writers

Pangram doesn’t investigate writing… It fucking ricochets off the furniture, gets stuck under our couches and then misidentifies a goddamn dust bunny for the smoking gun… then this reckless AI program proudly declares, “case closed… AI assisted or AI written.”

Pangram isn’t investigating anything… It’s a pissant Roomba with a fucking badge and a progress bar… It bumps into a “pre-programmed statistical pattern” and then mistakes a wayward dust bunny for the smoking gun, and “boom” declares the case closed.

Unfortunately, folks on Substack are using this “progress bar” as evidence dedicated, honest to goodness writers are dishonest AI slop junkies.

Proof of this stupidity: Mary Shelley apparently didn’t write Frankenstein.

Also, other notable novelists who’ve published their work chapter by chapter for years didn’t write theirs either, because Pangram says the LLM has passed down mad note from the digital hand of God himself.

Fuck me folks, we keep this shit up and we are going to be told, Shakespeare certainly outsourced Hamlet, Ernest Hemingway absolutely had a secret OpenAI account, and Cormac McCarthy wasn’t a real person… he was just three dehydrated coyotes sharing a keyboard somewhere west of Tucumcari, New Mexico.

Then my snarky side created the boardroom discussion:

The Pangram Improvement Process

Step 1: Falsely accuse the writer.

Step 2: Require the writer to explain why you’re wrong.

Step 3: Collect the correction.

Step 4: Improve the detector.

Step 5: Repeat.

Somewhere, an executive calls this a success metric.

A PowerPoint slide proudly labels it “Continuous Improvement.”

Everyone applauds.

You know the most fucked-up part?

Nobody seems to be asking why the Substack community is now expected to fix the company’s mistakes. Here’s why… Our reputations are on the line… Not Pangram’s… Not the executives’… Not the product managers’…

…Ours.

The AI detection algorithm gets it wrong (again)… Then (we) the writer gets accused.

(We) The writer explains why the AI detection algorithm got it wrong… The dickheads who built the algorithm are supplied (free) better data.

I have realized the joke isn’t that Pangram gets things wrong… hell, humanity always gets shit wrong.

Apparently, the fucking joke is how quickly folks have passed digital assessment authority to something that never witnessed our writing processes.

Pangram never watches us write.

It never sees the first draft… Our second, third and fifteenth drafts.

The paragraphs we delete because they simply sucked ass… Pangram only gets to see the final product.

This reminds me of someone asking a metal detector, “who buried the coin?”

The metal detector doesn’t know… It just starts beeping to tell you something is buried below it… The machine just beeps… a simple flashing light and sound…

…Humans supply the accusation… We’ve always been frighteningly good at that.

Salem.

McCarthyism.

The Red Scare.

The Satanic Panic.

Different centuries.

Different villains.

Same species.

History proves our accusations have always been easier than conducting an investigation.

History is full of people destroyed because someone mistook a signal for proof.

I brought Pangram a snack

Leave a comment

Most folks around the High Plains like to say the Devil’s greatest trick was convincing everyone he doesn’t exist. Those people have clearly never spent a Thursday evening behind the First Baptist Church skate park.

He exists… Nobody believes him.

He shows up every Thursday around six driving a faded red 1996 Toyota Tacoma with 666,666 miles perpetually stuck on the odometer. Original transmission. Two hundred and third set of tires. One cracked headlight held together with duct tape. The bumper sticker reads:

MY OTHER RIDE IS A PALE HORSE.

He wears Vans, cargo shorts, and a faded Misfits T-shirt. His horns are polished. His tail disappears neatly down one pant leg. Most people assume he’s just another divorced guy who still says he could’ve gone pro if his knee hadn’t blown out.

Then he drops in. The first run is always a warm-up.

Kickflips.

Impossible.

Hardflips.

Varials.

The sort of skating that makes fourteen-year-olds question every life decision they’ve ever made. Someone always asks if he’s sponsored.

He shrugs, “I used to have an angel investor.”

Nobody laughs… Not because the joke isn’t funny… Because he isn’t joking.

A youth pastor approaches him.

“You aren’t really Satan.”

Lucifer sighs.

“I literally am.”

“No.”

“I led the rebellion in Heaven.”

“Cosplay.”

“I tempted Christ.”

“Method acting.”

“I invented temptation.”

“Deep lore.”

Lucifer stares at him for a long moment.

“I just landed a 900 while reciting Leviticus backwards.”

The youth pastor nods.

“CGI is getting incredible.”

Lucifer rubs his temples. Some miracles simply aren’t worth performing. An old deacon wanders over carrying a Styrofoam cup full of burnt church coffee.

“If you’re really the Devil,” he asks, “where’s your private jet?”

“The televangelists all have one.”

Lucifer blinks… Then sighs.

“I’ve corrupted kings.”

“Started wars.”

“Toppled empires.”

“I’ve been whispering bad ideas into good people since Cain.”

He looks genuinely offended.

“But I have never told a widow that God needed her credit card.”

He shakes his head.

“Have some self-respect.”

He tucks the skateboard beneath one arm.

“I’m the Devil.”

The old deacon nods slowly.

“Fair enough.”

Then Lucifer drops in again… Hell starts chanting.

LU-CI-FER!

LU-CI-FER!

LU-CI-FER!

Then he reached into the Old Tricks.

The forbidden ones.

The tricks whispered over campfires.

Argued over in empty pools.

Remembered by old men whose knees predicted the weather...

...and who always got quiet before they mentioned them.

Every witness told a different story.

That was how you knew they were telling the truth.

The board stopped riding the concrete… The concrete leaned into the turn.

Gravity looked away… It knew better.

He landed…

…Nobody cheered…

…Nobody clapped.

The youth pastor frowned.

“I still don’t believe you’re the Devil.”

Lucifer looked up.

“Told you so!”

Somewhere beyond the clouds... Someone laughed.

Leave a comment

Agent Mara Ellison pinned the first map to the wall because the conference table had become its own disaster site. Reports, photographs, transfer authorizations, and journals lay buried together like the wreckage floodwater surrendered only after it had finished with the dead. The map showed the continental United States in pale government colors. Highways in red. Rivers in blue. State boundaries in thin gray lines that suggested order…without proving it.

She marked Bellwether with a black pin. Paul Dent stood behind her with a cardboard box balanced against his hip.

“Beginning or end?”

“Neither.”

She pressed the pin deeper.

“Home.” Outside, Bellwether continued its ordinary morning. School buses crossed Main Street. The diner opened at six. Mercer & Sons received two deliveries. The town had learned that federal agents could occupy a building without making the world look different.

Dent set the box on the table.

“Denver.”

Ellison opened it.

Inside were photocopies from the National Funeral Directors Association conference held in 1998. Attendance sheets. Hotel receipts. Vendor lists. Banquet photographs. A program printed on heavy cream paper beneath the title:

SERVICE WITH DIGNITY.

Silas Mercer appeared on page twelve among three hundred other names.

No photograph.

No handwritten note.

No reason to remember him.

Dent removed a second file.

“Orlando. Two thousand two.”

Ellison placed a blue pin in Florida.

“New Orleans,” he said.

A red pin in Louisiana.

“Joplin.”

Missouri.

“Houston.”

Texas.

“Paradise.”

California.

“Biloxi.”

Mississippi.

“Albany.”

New York.

The map spread across the wall one pin at a time.

Conferences received blue.

Disasters received red.

Bellwether remained black.

By noon, several states had begun to resemble wounds.

Dent stood back and studied them.

“He traveled.”

“So do funeral directors.”

“He volunteered.”

“So do decent people.”

They had both learned to distrust any sentence that made Silas sound unusual. The extraordinary drew attention. The ordinary passed through checkpoints without being remembered. His usefulness had depended on becoming another face beneath a reflective vest, another signature on a transfer form, another man everyone assumed belonged there.

Nobody remembered the man who belonged everywhere.

Ellison opened Journal 1985–1991.

The leather spine creaked… The handwriting inside remained unchanged from the first page to the last… Narrow… Upright… Patient…

…No blots…

…No corrections…

…No places where the hand had hurried.

Dent watched her turn pages.

“You sleep?”

“Some.”

“That means no.”

“That means some.”

He poured coffee, smelled it, and set it down untouched. Ellison stopped at a yellow tab.

October 17, 1987. Interstate rest area west of Tulsa. Male, approximately forty. Wedding band removed prior to discovery. Inscription overlooked during initial examination.

No admission. No description of death. Only the failures surrounding it.

Dent leaned over her shoulder.

“Did he kill him?”

“We don’t know.”

“He wrote it down.”

“He wrote everything down.”

She turned the page.

February 4, 1988. Female. Bus terminal. Reported intoxicated by witnesses. Medical distress mistaken for behavior. Property removed during transport. Identification delayed.

Dent frowned.

“That could be anything.”

“Yes.”

“That’s the problem.”

“Yes.”

The daylight withdrew without announcement. Outside dissolved into darkness without either of them looking up. Only when Ellison reached for another pin did she find the map staring back from the darkened glass.

Names migrated from one spreadsheet to the next until they became easier to sort than to remember. Dates crossed state lines until cause and consequence no longer occupied the same file. The system never intended to forget anyone. It simply remembered processes better than people.

Missing-person reports were requested from departments that no longer stored paper records in the buildings where they had first been filed. Some archives had flooded. Others had burned. Entire collections had been scanned into formats no current employee could still open.

A police department in Oklahoma mailed a box containing eight microcassettes and a handwritten note apologizing that the recorder had been discarded in 2009.

A county clerk in Missouri sent the complete file for a different tornado. Nothing about it was wrong. It simply belonged to someone else’s dead.

A hospital in Texas informed them that every relevant record had been destroyed in accordance with its retention policy.

Policies had been followed… Nobody had violated procedures.

Silas had never needed people to make mistakes. He only needed them to do their jobs.

Dent read the letter twice.

“How long?”

“Seven years.”

“The woman’s been missing nineteen.”

Ellison held out her hand… He gave her the letter.

At the bottom, beneath the administrator’s signature, someone had written:

WE REGRET ANY INCONVENIENCE.

Ellison placed it beside the journal. The two documents looked as though they belonged together.

By the third day, the table had disappeared beneath the dead.

School portraits.

Driver’s licenses that had once lived inside worn leather wallets.

Wedding photographs trimmed from family albums.

Employee badges still clipped to faded lanyards.

Job applications.

Hospital wristbands.

Photocopies passed through too many copiers until faces began to disappear.

Missing-person flyers printed years earlier on cheap office paper.

Storefront windows and courthouse bulletin boards had bleached the ink until the smiles themselves seemed to disappear.

Every document had a place.

The people didn’t.

A woman in Boise standing beside a Christmas tree.

A bartender in Houston laughing behind a tray of drinks.

A man in Tennessee photographed in a work uniform with his name stitched above the pocket.

A girl named Maribel smiling into a camera she did not yet know would become evidence.

Ellison held that photograph longer than the others. The copy had come from Louisiana. The original report had been filed four days after the flood.

Mother reported juvenile daughter missing after evacuation separation. Possible runaway history. No confirmed last location. Family displaced. Contact information unreliable.

The file contained three follow-up attempts: Two numbers disconnected. One address returned undeliverable. Case administratively suspended after eighteen months.

Dent stood on the other side of the table.

“That her?”

Ellison looked at the cheap bracelet visible around the girl’s wrist.

“Maybe.”

“In the journal, he heard the mother.”

“Yes.”

“He knew her name.”

“He heard a name.”

“He wrote it down.”

Ellison returned the photograph to the file.

“That isn’t proof.”

Dent stared at her.

“No. It’s just what happened.”

She looked toward the wall… Louisiana had spread again.

Red pins had multiplied throughout the afternoon, creeping across parishes and river roads until the clusters began to swallow the names printed beneath them.

Temporary morgues… Church fellowship halls… Refrigerated trailers backed against warehouse loading docks… Hospital receiving bays… School gymnasiums where basketball goals still hung above rows of military cots.

Every pin marked the moment a building stopped asking who someone was and started asking how many it could hold.

Nobody expected it to last… They only needed it to last long enough.

Ellison crossed the room and nudged one pin half an inch north… Dent watched her.

“What?”

“The church was here.”

“You sure?”

“The coordinates in the responder log were wrong.”

“How wrong?”

“Three miles.”

“That matter?”

She looked at the map.

“Everything matters after someone decides it doesn’t.”

Dent said nothing.

A knock came at the door.

A young analyst entered carrying another file box. He had arrived from Little Rock that morning and still possessed the careful energy of someone who believed every answer existed if the right database could be persuaded to produce it.

“We received the crematory transfers.”

Ellison cleared a place on the table.

“From where?”

“Eleven states.”

“How many records?”

“Four hundred and six.”

Dent drew a slow breath through his teeth.

Nobody looked up.

One analyst circled a date in red ink without breaking stride. Another tucked a photograph beneath a growing stack of reports and reached for the next file. Across the room, someone peeled another red pin from its box and pressed it into Louisiana with the practiced motion of someone who no longer had to think about where it belonged.

The copier down the hall hummed, paused, then fed another sheet into the tray.

Dent closed his mouth.

No one in the room expected this to be the last box of files.

“Some are duplicates. Some may be routine disaster processing. Several facilities no longer exist.”

He opened the box.

Inside were death certificates, transfer authorizations, transit permits, cremation releases, chain-of-custody forms, and invoices.

Every form bore signatures. Initials crowded the margins beside dates, file numbers, and case identifiers. The paperwork had never stopped moving… The people had.

Ellison separated the files by year… Dent took half the stack without asking.

The analyst hesitated near the doorway.

“There’s something else.”

Neither agent looked up.

“One of the facilities in Mississippi listed Mercer & Sons as the receiving funeral home for three unidentified remains after Hurricane Katrina.”

Ellison stopped.

“Did the remains arrive?”

“No receiving record.”

“Follow-up?”

“None.”

Dent turned toward him.

“How do three bodies disappear between two funeral homes?”

The analyst glanced at the boxes covering the table.

“The sending facility recorded them as transferred.”

“And Mercer?”

“No record they were received.”

“So where are they?”

The analyst looked at Ellison… Ellison already knew the answer.

Not where… Between.

That was where Silas had lived.

Between departments.

Between jurisdictions.

Between the signature releasing a body and the signature acknowledging its arrival.

Between the last person required to care and the first person permitted to forget.

Ellison reached for the oldest transfer document.

The paper had gone soft where decades of hands had folded and unfolded it. Carbon impressions bled faint purple shadows through the page. A rust-colored stain marked one corner where a paper clip had surrendered years ago.

Three unidentified adults… No fingerprints available… Dental records pending… Transport authorized due to overflow.

Receiving representative: Silas Mercer

The signature crossed the bottom in neat blue ink.

Measured… Deliberate.

Not a flourish out of place.

Dent leaned closer.

“The journals.”

Ellison nodded.

“The same hand.”

Neither of them spoke for several seconds. Around them, folders opened. Pages turned.

A printer somewhere down the hall woke to life, coughed once, then began feeding paper into its tray. Ellison laid the document beside the journal.

The signatures matched.

Silas Mercer had never hidden.

He had simply signed where no one thought to look.

“There.”

Ellison studied the page.

It was the first document they had found that placed the living man directly beside the missing dead. Still, the form proved only that he had been entrusted with them.

Silas had never needed to disappear.

The paperwork made him ordinary.

She carried the document to the wall. A red pin marked Biloxi. She tied a black thread around it and drew the thread back to Bellwether. The line sagged between the states.

Dent stepped closer.

“First connection?”

“First one we can put on a wall.”

By the end of the week, the wall no longer held a map.

It held lines.

Black thread crossed red.

Red crossed blue.

Thumbtacks crowded the cork until the map nearly disappeared beneath the tightening web. Conference cities led to disaster zones. Disaster zones led to crematories, county morgues, and missing-person reports separated by decades and county lines.

The threads ignored geography… They followed paperwork.

Shipping manifests.

Transfer orders.

Signatures.

Some threads ended at Bellwether… Others reached a single pin and stopped.

No destination.

No receiving agency.

No explanation.

The unfinished lines drew the eye… They weren’t dead ends.

They marked the place where the record stopped...

...and the bodies kept moving.

Dent stood beneath the map in shirtsleeves. His jacket lay folded across a chair no one had sat in for two days. Three empty coffee cups stood beside a fourth he could no longer remember pouring. The legal pad in his hand had become so crowded with names, dates, and arrows that there was nowhere left to write except the margins.

“How many?”

Ellison sat at the table with Journal 1998–2005 open before her.

“Thirty-two we may be able to prove.”

“May?”

“Bodies linked to transfers. Travel records. Missing reports. Journal entries.”

“And the rest?”

She looked toward the shelves.

Two hundred and seventeen journals filled the evidence room.

Thousands of entries waited inside them.

Some recorded murders.

Some recorded opportunities.

Some recorded only the moment a person passed from being missed into being processed.

“We don’t know what the rest are.”

Dent rubbed both hands over his face.

“Victims?”

“Maybe.”

“Witnesses?”

“Maybe.”

“People he found already dead?”

“Maybe.”

“That’s not an answer.”

“No.”

He turned toward the wall.

Entire towns had disappeared beneath the pins.

From a distance, Louisiana no longer looked like a state.

It looked like evidence.

Dent walked closer.

“Christ.”

Ellison looked at the map.

Then at Maribel’s photograph lying among the forms.

She stood. Crossing the room, she tucked the photograph beneath the Louisiana cluster. For a moment, the girl’s smile disappeared beneath the crossing threads… Dent watched her.

“No one had to break anything,” she said.

“They only had to keep signing.”

Neither of them spoke. The fluorescent lights hummed overhead. Somewhere in the building, a copier woke, fed another sheet through its rollers, and fell silent again. Dent reached for the journal nearest him. He opened it to a page already marked. The handwriting crossed it in the same careful script they had seen on transfer forms decades old.

Systems do not conceal the dead. They lose track of who was supposed to care.

Dent read the passage twice.

“You think he believed it?”

Ellison never took her eyes off the board.

“I think he built his life around it.”

Near midnight, the county custodian came in to empty the trash. He stopped just inside the doorway. His eyes moved across the photographs. The archive boxes. The colored thread. The pins. The names written, crossed out, and rewritten until the corkboard resembled another map laid over the first.

“What is all this?”

Ellison looked at the wall. It had stopped being a case board sometime that afternoon. She just hadn’t noticed when. She looked at Maribel. At three unidentified adults signed into transport and never signed out.

At conference cities.

At disaster zones.

At counties connected by paperwork instead of highways.

At black thread crossing red.

Red crossing blue.

At a country that had documented nearly every transfer...

...except the last one.

“An archive,” she said.

The custodian nodded politely, as though that answered the question. He changed the trash bag. Tied it shut. Wheeled the cart back into the hallway… The door eased closed behind him.

Dent stepped beside her.

“An archive of what?”

Ellison didn’t answer immediately… She looked across the board.

The signatures.

The transfer orders.

The receiving agencies.

The empty endings where every trail ended the same way.

She finally said,

“Everyone we stopped looking for.”

Silence settled over the room.

Somewhere down the hall, the copier woke again.

Another sheet slid into the output tray.

Leave a comment

Chapter Nine: Volunteer Work

Before the funeral home… Before the journals… Before anyone thought to look for patterns.

In 2005, Silas Mercer stood ankle-deep in brown water outside of a Louisiana church and watched names disappear. Bodies lay beneath tarps in the heat. There were lines of white sheets, blue tarps, and black bags. All of them had numbered tags… Names if anyone knew them… Numbers if nobody did.

The air smelled of river mud, gasoline, mold, sewage, and the sweet, enlarging odor of human endings. Helicopters beat the sky into submission while volunteers moved with masks over their mouths and exhaustion in their eyes.

Silas wore rubber boots, gloves, and a yellow vest marked MORTUARY SUPPORT. He was fifty-two then. A young National Guardsman vomited behind a flooded minivan. Silas handed him a bottle of water.

“First one?”

The soldier nodded.

“Don’t fight the body,” Silas said. “It knows this is wrong before the mind does.”

The soldier looked at him with gratitude. Disasters made people grateful for ordinary kindness… Silas moved through the churchyard with a clipboard.

Male. Approximate age sixty.

Female. Unknown.

Child. Unknown.

Female. Approximate age nineteen. No identification.

He stopped at the last one.

The girl lay half-covered beneath a tarp near the church steps. Dark hair. Thin wrist. Cheap bracelet. No shoes.

A runaway, probably… Or abandoned… Or both…

…Experience taught him those words usually meant the same child.

Runaways became missing persons… Missing persons became cold cases… Cold cases became boxes on warehouse shelves… Eventually they became names no one called anymore.

“Has anyone asked for her?”

A responder shook his head.

“Not yet.”

Not yet.

During disasters, those two words carried families on their backs.

Not identified yet.

Not reported yet.

Not found yet.

Not notified yet.

Not buried yet.

Sometimes... Not missed yet.

Silas crouched beside the girl. Her eyes were open… Clouded… Waiting for someone who had not yet arrived. He preferred the dead before families arrived. Families have always complicated bodies with ownership. Before names, the dead belonged to processes.

“Sir?”

Silas looked over.

“We’re short transport for the overflow site.”

“I can take her.”

The volunteer glanced at the clipboard.

“You sure?”

Silas nodded.

“She shouldn’t stay in the heat.”

That was true.

The best lies wore the skin of truth.

He carried her carefully… Tenderly…

…Anyone watching would have seen a good man.

No one questioned kindness performed with confidence.

Silas loaded the girl into the temporary transport van with six others.

Six legitimate dead.

One possible life no one had yet accounted for.

At the edge of the parking lot, a woman shouted a name into the chaos.

“Maribel!”

Silas paused.

The woman stumbled through the mud, clutching a photograph sealed inside a plastic sleeve. The photograph had been folded so many times the girl’s smile had cracked in two. Someone had written Maribel across the back in fading blue ink.

Dark hair.

Thin wrist.

Cheap bracelet.

Silas watched her from across the lot.

A man could still step forward.

He could point toward the van.

He could tell her to hurry.

A good man would.

The woman turned toward him. Their eyes met. For one moment, he considered answering.

A helicopter passed overhead, swallowing every other sound.

When the noise faded... Silas was already driving.

…The helicopter dissolved into the low hum of tires on pavement.

Silas looked through the arrangement room window as two dark SUVs rolled beneath the cottonwoods and into the parking lot of Mercer & Sons Funeral Home.

Government plates.

He adjusted the knot of his tie… Smoothed one sleeve… Walked to the front door before anyone had the chance to knock.

“Good morning,” he said.

“I’ve been expecting you.”

Chapter Ten: The Journals

The FBI believed they were opening an investigation… They were opening an archive.

Just after sunrise, two dark SUVs rolled beneath the cottonwoods lining Mercer & Sons Funeral Home. By eight-thirteen, the front door was unlocked. They expected trophies. Symbols. Newspaper clippings. Blood maps. Souvenirs. Some theatrical evidence of madness.

Madness was comforting. It kept the monster separate from the tax base.

Silas Mercer offered them coffee. Agent Mara Ellison declined. Agent Paul Dent realized his hands were shaking halfway through the cup. Silas sat across from them in the arrangement room while two evidence teams worked below.

“Mr. Mercer,” Ellison said. “We’re going to ask you about your travel history.”

“Of course.”

“You attended the National Funeral Directors Association conference in Denver in 1998.”

“Yes.”

“Orlando in 2002.”

“Yes.”

“New Orleans in 2005.”

He nodded.

“Disaster support.”

“Joplin in 2011.”

“Tornado response.”

“Houston in 2017.”

“Flood recovery.”

Ellison looked up.

“You remember all of these clearly?”

Silas folded his hands.

“I remember the dead.”

Dent glanced toward the hallway.

“What about the living?”

Silas met his eyes.

“Less reliably.”

Neither agent smiled. A shout echoed up from the basement… Then hurried footsteps.

The evidence technician reached the doorway. He had forgotten to knock.

“Agent Ellison.”

She stood.

Silas remained seated.

They found the false wall behind the crematory controls. The false wall opened easily. Beyond it was a narrow concrete room.

Shelves.

Hundreds.

Every one full.

Not body parts.

Not weapons.

Not trophies.

Books.

Two hundred and seventeen leather journals arranged by year.

Gold numerals had been stamped into each spine.

Ellison stepped inside. The room smelled of dry paper, leather, and ash. Dent weighed the journal in his hands. Then he opened it. Ellison chose another. The first journal’s leather was worn smooth. The last looked as though it had been closed only yesterday. There were no gaps between them.

Thousands.

Names when possible.

Descriptions when not.

093. Male, approximately forty-two. Oklahoma rest stop. Unreported. Wedding band removed before discovery. Nobody checked the inscription.

147. Female, approximately nineteen. Flood zone. Female voice calling “Maribel” nearby. Helicopter masked further communication. Transport successful.

226. Elderly male. Nursing home evacuation. Staff believed transferred. Receiving facility had no record. Both institutions preferred administrative error.

309. Child remains. Tornado. Mother identified backpack before body. Family stopped saying the name after the second day.

444. Conference hotel. Woman from Boise. No family contact listed. Police assumed voluntary departure. Useful assumption.

Dent stopped turning pages.

601. Wildfire evacuation. Male transient. Officials grateful for the reduction in unidentified backlog.

Ellison turned another page… Then another… Every volume spoke in the same voice.

Measured.

Precise.

Attentive.

Not a single page contained a correction.

Silas recorded the dead with more care than most people remembered the living.

Near the bottom of one page, a single sentence had been underlined once.

Most people are not lost because someone kills them. They are lost because eventually nobody continues asking where they went.

Ellison closed the journal. She did not reach for another.

“How many?” Dent asked quietly.

The technician looked slowly around the room.

“Two hundred and seventeen.”

No one spoke.

Upstairs, Silas Mercer waited exactly where they had left him.

Chapter Eleven: Pastor Creed

Pastor Lowell Creed began seeing lilies. At first, only where they belonged.

Funeral sprays.

Church vestibules.

The arrangements sent to Emily’s mother.

Then elsewhere.

In grocery carts.

In ditches.

On the pulpit.

Once, he opened his Bible and found a pressed white lily between Leviticus and Numbers, its petals browned at the edges like old skin. He threw the Bible across the room and wept until his throat hurt. His wife asked what was wrong. He told her he was tired.

That was the final refuge of cowards.

Tired.

Not guilty.

Not broken.

Not damned.

Tired.

Wednesday night arrived. The sanctuary filled more slowly than it once had. Bellwether Baptist had changed since Emily’s funeral. People no longer sat where they always had. Families left empty pews between themselves. Conversations ended when someone else approached.

It wasn’t fear.

It was distance.

As though grief had become something contagious. Linda Voss no longer attended. Mayor Voss appeared nowhere, though his truck had been seen near the old railroad bridge twice. Sheriff Barrow sat in the last pew, his arms remained folded. Silas Mercer sat three rows from the front…

…That was new.

Creed saw him and nearly dropped his Bible… The undertaker wore black… Of course.

…Hands folded.

…Head slightly bowed.

…Listening.

Creed opened to Matthew. His fingers left damp fingerprints on the page.

“Whatever you did for one of the least of these...”

…He stopped… He had preached Matthew twenty-five more times than he could remember… For the first time in his ministry... He could not remember the next sentence. Silence spread through the sanctuary. He looked down… Matthew still lay open before him. The words refused to leave the page. He could not reach them. His wife leaned forward.

“Lowell...”

…He tried again.

“Whatever you did...”

…Nothing.

He looked into the congregation.

He no longer saw church members.

…He saw funerals.

Mrs. Crane spitting into Harold’s coffin. Emily’s pale wrist. The guestbook lying open in the fellowship hall. His own name written across the final page.

Pastor Lowell Creed.

Visitation: Pending.

The sanctuary lights flickered. A hymnal slipped from someone’s hands. It struck the wooden floor with a sound far louder than it should have. No one bent to retrieve it. Creed gripped the pulpit until his knuckles whitened.

“She came to me.”

The sanctuary froze.

“She came to me because she was afraid.”

His voice cracked.

“And I told her to pray.”

His wife covered her mouth.

“I told a child to pray because I was afraid of a man.”

He looked down at the Bible.

“I dressed cowardice in scripture...”

His voice failed.

“...and called it counsel.”

A woman began to cry… Another lowered her head… No one spoke… Creed lifted his eyes toward Silas.

“You...”

Silas looked up. Their eyes met across the sanctuary. Neither man looked away.

“You knew.”

Silence settled over the room. Long enough that several people wondered whether the undertaker intended to answer. When he finally spoke, his voice was almost gentle.

“You already knew.”

Pastor Lowell Creed disappeared behind the pulpit as though something holding him upright had finally let go. Several members rushed forward. Others remained where they stood. Barrow never uncrossed his arms. Silas never moved. The pastor had not been attacked.

He had been introduced to himself.

Chapter Twelve: The Furnace Room

Barrow entered the crematory after midnight. He had no warrant and no backup. No clean reason for being there except that reason had become useless days ago. Mercer & Sons stood unlocked.

That bothered him more than locked doors would have. He descended the basement stairs with one hand on his pistol. The preparation room was dark. The journals were gone now, hauled away in federal evidence crates, leaving clean rectangles of dust on the shelves.

A room emptied of memory looked obscene. Heat lingered in the furnace room. Not enough to sweat, just enough to notice. The steel skin of the Phoenix II-2 clicked quietly as it cooled. Silas stood before it, one hand resting against the furnace door.

“You shouldn’t be here,” Barrow said.

“No,” Silas replied.

“I suppose not.”

The sheriff stepped closer.

“You modified it.”

“Yes.”

“For capacity?”

“For continuity.”

“Don’t dress it up.”

Silas turned.

“You want vulgar language because it makes evil feel smaller.”

“I want a confession.”

“You already have two hundred and seventeen.”

“I want to hear it.”

The old man smiled faintly.

“There’s your problem, Amos.”

“You still think evil looks guilty.”

Barrow drew his pistol… Silas looked at it without interest. The orange glow from the furnace washed across his glasses.

“How many?”

Silas looked back at the furnace.

“Enough.”

“Give me a number.”

“Why?”

“Because I need one.”

Silence.

The furnace clicked.

“A number would comfort you,” Silas said quietly.

“It would let you believe horror has edges.”

Barrow said nothing.

Warm air drifted between them.

“You call it tragedy,” Silas said.

“Most of the time...”

“…It is indifference.”

The sheriff’s grip tightened around the pistol. The furnace breathed behind Silas. One step backwards… That was all it would take…

…Silas stepped closer.

“Put that away.”

“You won’t shoot me.”

“You sure?”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

Silas studied him for a long moment.

“Because you refuse to become me.”

Barrow stared at him… For one terrible second...

…He realized the old man was right. Not because Silas understood him. Because Barrow still believed the law meant something even when it failed.

Slowly... He lowered the pistol. Silas turned back toward the furnace. His hand remained against the steel.

“You know what this machine does better than any church?”

Barrow didn’t answer.

“It tells the truth…” “…It burns bodies….”

Barrow shook his head as he interrupted Silas... “No.”

“People did that before they ever brought them down here.”

Silas said nothing… The furnace clicked.

“When I was young,” he said at last, “I thought death had answers.”

He watched the furnace.

“It doesn’t.”

“It only has echoes.”

The room fell silent… The furnace hummed.

“Go home, Amos.”

Barrow climbed the basement stairs alone.

Silas never looked up.

Behind him, the furnace continued its slow mechanical breathing.

It did not know the difference between evidence...

…and confession.

Leave a comment

The Llano does not remember people… It remembers the wind… It remembers the buffalo. People arrived later with fences and paperwork…. The prairie never signed either one.

Long before deeds, survey lines, and county roads attempted to divide what had never asked to be divided, the grass moved like an inland sea beneath a sky too large for ownership. Every gust of wind bent a million blades into the same silent prayer before letting them rise again. Meadowlarks announced the morning. Pronghorns skimmed the horizon like living arrows. Cottonwoods gathered where hidden water still refused surrender to the elements. Everything else learned humility…even the storms. They arrived like prophets and departed like thieves, leaving only the smell of petrichor, the earthy, musky scent from rain hitting dry soil and the sharp, metallic ozone smell from lightning strikes… everyday hard lessons carved into the earth.

The prairie had been testing buffalo for ten thousand years. His ancestors crossed into this continent while mammoths still walked beneath northern skies. American lions vanished. Dire wolves vanished. Giant short-faced bears vanished. The buffalo outlived them all. The prairie remembered every one of them. Generation after generation endured another winter… Another drought… Another predator… Another thousand years… Until every old bull standing beneath the prairie sky bore the marks of everything that had failed to kill his kind. A buffalo bull can weigh nearly a ton. The prairie has spent ten thousand years deciding exactly how to build one.

The old rancher watched the herd through the cracked windshield of his pickup… They weren’t supposed to be here.

A conservation herd had drifted farther south than anyone expected after an unusually wet spring. Now thirty buffalo grazed beneath a broken windmill whose blades hadn’t turned since Reagan was president.

His grandson leaned against the truck door.

“They don’t seem scared.”

The rancher smiled.

“You don’t live that long by wasting energy.”

“Why?”

He nodded toward the old bull standing apart from the herd.

“His family never needed history books.”

The boy waited.

“They remember in bone.”

Wind rolled across the prairie.

The bull stood with the patience of weathered sandstone. Grass bent around his legs. Dust lifted against his hide. Grasshoppers clicked through the bluestem without disturbing him. Nothing else on the prairie behaved as though he didn’t belong there.

The rental SUV arrived in a cloud of caliche… Four people climbed out... Phones came out before hats came off. One dumb motherfucker laughed… Another asshole pointed… Then, in a moment of “what the fuck,” a man climbed through the fence.

The rancher sighed.

“Here we go.”

“They’re getting too close.”

“They’re about to learn the difference between seeing wildlife and interrupting it.”

The man kept walking.

Twenty yards…

…Fifteen…

…Ten…

…He reached out one hand with the confidence of a man who had mistaken access for permission…

The bull raised his head.

That was all.

The prairie had been patient.

Now it was being clear.

When the buffalo moved, the distance between them disappeared all at once.

One horn found him beneath the belt.

For the briefest instant, he hung against the New Mexico sky, suspended between arrogance and gravity.

Then the prairie took him back.

Silence settled over the grass once more.

The old bull lowered his head and tore another mouthful of prairie from the earth.

The grandson stared across the pasture.

“Granddad...”

“You wanted that to happen?”

The old man watched the buffalo disappear into the waves of grass.

“No.”

“I wanted him reminded.”

“Reminded of what?”

The rancher settled his hat against the wind.

“That this country belonged to someone long before it belonged to us.”

The buffalo had no use for justice… He understood only distance.

Respect it...

...and the prairie remained beautiful.

Ignore it...

...and the prairie became instructional.

Epilogue

There was a time when this story almost couldn’t have happened. Not because people learned respect. Because we nearly erased the buffalo from the earth.

Long before highways crossed the prairie and tourists carried cameras into places they barely understood, an estimated thirty to sixty million American bison shaped the Great Plains. They were more than animals. They were architects of the prairie. Their migrations renewed the grasslands. Their wallows caught rain. Their grazing fed an entire web of life. Indigenous nations built cultures around them because the buffalo had already built the continent around themselves. Then came railroads, repeating rifles, and commercial markets. Government policies that understood another terrible truth: destroy the buffalo, and you destroy the people who depended on them. Within a few decades, one of the greatest wildlife populations on Earth had been reduced to only a few hundred survivors.

The prairie had nearly lost one of its oldest voices.

And yet...

The buffalo never declared war on us… They never hunted us… They never sought vengeance for mountains of bleaching skulls scattered across the plains or for the calves left without mothers beneath an endless sky.

If they had been a vengeful species, the man in this story would never have walked away.

Instead, the old bull did what buffalo have always done.

He defended the space between himself and a stranger who failed to understand where he stood.

Then he lowered his head...

...and went back to grazing.

Perhaps that is the greater lesson.

The buffalo survived our worst.

Not because they were stronger than us.

Because they never became what we became.

The wind still crosses the Llano.

The grass still bends.

The prairie does not care what your name is.

Remember where you are.

Leave a comment

Before Roosevelt County had a courthouse, before New Mexico had a border, before Spain planted a cross where no one had asked for one, before the Comanche crossed the Llano behind drifting buffalo, before the first windmill lifted its tin hands above the grass, the water had already chosen where it intended to go.

It moved in darkness beneath the plains. It passed through stone and sand and the buried memory of vanished seas. It gathered where gravity allowed and waited where clay and caliche held it. It did not know county lines. It did not know deeds. It did not know the language of rights because rights were things men invented after they found something worth taking.

Men came later.

They came with survey chains and plows and rifles and family Bibles and courthouse stamps. They came with thirst and called it settlement. They drilled into the earth and brought up water older than their nations, older than their prayers, older than the names they painted on mailboxes along roads that would one day turn back into dust. They built houses and dairies and churches and schools and pivots that turned in great green circles over a country that had not offered permission.

In eastern New Mexico, people did not talk about water like they talked about money. Money could be lost and made again if a man had enough luck or enough nerve. Water was different. Water made families stay. Water made land worth fighting over. Water made a quarter section a future or a grave. Men who would loan a neighbor a trailer without asking would go quiet if the talk turned to wells. Women who brought casseroles to funerals would lower their voices afterward and ask who had inherited the rights.

Guadalupe Hernandez understood numbers better than she understood men and trusted them more.

She worked at the Roosevelt County Water Cooperative in a low building on the edge of Portales, New Mexico where the carpet held thirty years of dust and the breakroom microwave smelled permanently of old burritos and burnt cheese. Each morning, she arrived before sunrise, unlocked the front door, turned on the fluorescent lights, filled the coffee pot, and waited for the old computer to remember what century it belonged to.

Outside, the county water tank stood against the eastern sky, the float exactly where yesterday had left it. Wind pushed dust against the galvanized steel until the whole thing sounded like distant applause.

The wind had crossed these plains before Christ walked Galilee. It crossed them when mammoths wandered the High Plains, when Comanche horses stitched trails through grass, when homesteaders mistook endurance for ownership. It would still be crossing them after the names painted on rural mailboxes had weathered back into cedar

Lupe unlocked the ledger cabinet, set yesterday’s reports beside todays, and began adding columns.

She was not dramatic. That mattered later because people like their dead to have been heroic in advance. It comforts the living to believe martyrs saw the blade coming and stood there nobly with a torch in one hand and destiny in the other. Lupe was not like that. She packed beans and tortillas for lunch. She kept a ceramic Virgin Mary beside her calculator. She wore sensible shoes and hated office gossip. She believed a number either belonged or it did not. That was the beginning and end of her theology.

The first error was small. Thirty-eight dollars and eleven cents misplaced across three accounts. She corrected it and moved on.

The next week an allocation changed without a second approval.

Then a conservation transfer appeared on land whose owner had died the previous winter.

Then a signature dated nine months after the signer had gone into the ground.

Lupe printed the form and compared it to the original file. The signature matched. The date did not. She sat back in her chair and looked through the blinds at the empty lot, where dust moved in little pale snakes over the pavement.

Her supervisor, Martin Bell, told her it was a software problem.

“This system’s old,” he said. “Half the time I’m surprised it doesn’t run on coal.”

“It printed a dead woman’s signature.”

“Imported file. Bad metadata.”

“That’s not what metadata does.”

Martin looked at her then, and for the first time since she’d known him, he stopped looking for another explanation.

“Just process the correction.”

“I did.”

“Then let it go.”

Lupe did not let it go, because numbers had manners, even when men did not.

For six weeks she stayed late. She followed transfers through archived minutes, scanned deeds, conservation agreements, and water-right filings written in language so soft it felt padded. Efficiency. Stewardship. Preservation. Responsible use. County resilience. A man could bury a body under phrases like that and expect applause for the landscaping.

The pattern widened.

Rights had been gathered into holding companies and trusts. Old hardship applications had been used as authorization. Widows had signed documents they thought were tax forms. Small farmers facing foreclosure had agreed to temporary restrictions that somehow became permanent transfers. Land had stayed with families on the surface while the water below moved elsewhere on paper.

At the center of it was an unofficial body calling itself the Council of Stewardship.

The name made Lupe laugh once, alone in the office… It was not a happy laugh.

There were six men. Samuel Price, who owned land west of Elida and talked about sacrifice from behind a belt buckle large enough to shame a cathedral door. Dale Rook, whose family had outlasted drought, debt, and three generations of men who inherited land long before they inherited humility. Evan Morrow, a dairyman with clean fingernails and exhausted eyes. Clint Harrow, whose wells ran deeper than his conscience. Martin Bell, listed only as an administrative liaison. And… Wade Jenkins.

Wade was the new County Water Regulator. He was also the sort of man people trusted because he had made a discipline of never looking surprised. He loved Roosevelt County, and that was the dangerous part.

He knew the roads by memory. He knew which families still kept porch lights on for boys who had left for the military and never really come home. He knew which wells had failed and which ones would fail next. He had watched farms sell to dairies and dairies sell to corporations and old men drive past land their grandfathers had broken with mules. He had read the reports. The Ogallala was dropping. Everybody knew it. Nobody wanted to say it plainly because plain speech has a way of making cowards feel accused.

Wade decided silence was no longer governance.

The Council met on Thursday evenings in the back room of Price Equipment beneath a mounted pronghorn and a faded photograph of Ronald Reagan. There were no robes. No candles. No theatrical nonsense. Just coffee in foam cups, yellow legal pads, boots crossed at the ankle, and men who had known each other long enough for silence to carry complete arguments.

“We’re running out,” Wade said.

No one answered.

“If we wait for the county to vote itself into discipline, we’ll pump this place dead.”

Dale Rook rubbed at his jaw.

“You saying folks can’t be trusted with their own land?”

“I’m saying land and water are not the same thing.”

Samuel Price nodded slowly, relieved someone else had said it.

Wade leaned over the table.

“People think they’re entitled to water because they own dirt.”

Clint Harrow gave a dry laugh.

“The dirt don’t agree.”

No one laughed after that.

Lupe found the sentence in the unofficial minutes and underlined it twice.

The dirt don’t agree.

Wade stopped beside an old windmill whose blades had surrendered years ago to rust. The stock tank beneath it sat half full. A meadowlark landed once, drank once, and disappeared into the morning.

The windmill had arrived late, galvanized steel and chain gears. Before it, buffalo trails crossed this grass. Before the buffalo, an inland sea covered this country until its floor hardened into the caliche beneath Wade’s boots. The country had never cared what stood above it. It measured only what endured.

He checked the pressure gauge, wrote a number on his clipboard, and drove toward Portales.

Lupe brought the folder to Martin on a Tuesday morning. The blinds striped his desk with light and shadow. Dust crossed the cooperative parking lot in thin pale ribbons. Outside, nothing happened that hadn’t happened a thousand mornings before.

Martin opened the folder.

“Where did you get this?”

“Our records.”

“These aren’t our records.”

“They are now.”

He closed the folder.

“Lupe, listen to me.”

“No.”

He blinked.

“No?”

“No. I’m done listening to men explain why numbers don’t mean what they mean.”

Martin looked toward the door.

“You have no idea what you’re touching.”

“I’m touching public records.”

“You’re touching panic.”

That stopped her for half a breath.

“Maybe panic is overdue.”

He put his hand on the folder. Not hard… Not dramatic… Just… enough.

That frightened her more than shouting would have.

“These men are trying to keep this county alive.”

“By stealing from it?”

“By making choices no one else will make.”

“Then let everyone see the choices.”

“You think people can handle that?”

“I think they have the right.”

Martin’s mouth tightened.

“Rights don’t make water.”

“No,” Lupe said. “But they keep men from pretending they’re God.”

By noon Wade Jenkins had the folder.

By dusk Lupe’s access to half the system had been revoked.

By the next morning, she had made copies.

She mailed one to her sister in Las Cruces, one to an attorney in Albuquerque, and one to herself at a post office box she had not opened in years. Then she placed the originals in a manila envelope and wrote across the front in black ink:

WATER REMEMBERS DOWNHILL.

Her grandfather had said it when she was a child and the irrigation ditch behind his house filled after rain. Water goes low because low places call to it. Truth does the same, he told her. Give it long enough and it will find the bottom.

That evening, Wade was waiting by her car.

“Guadalupe,” he said.

Nobody called her Guadalupe unless they wanted something.

“I don’t have anything to say to you.”

“You should.”

“I already said it on paper.”

He looked tired… That almost made it worse.

“You think this is theft.”

“I know what theft looks like.”

“I think it’s triage.”

The wind moved between them.

“If everyone pumps what they want,” Wade said, “nobody gets water. If nobody makes hard choices, this county dies.”

“That doesn’t give you the right.”

“The aquifer doesn’t care about rights.”

“Then why do you?”

For the first time his calm face cracked, and beneath it she saw the look of a man who had carried one answer for so long he no longer remembered the question.

“Because somebody has to.”

Wade had not set out to become a dangerous man. He had simply spent too many years making decisions no one wanted to make. Somewhere along the way, he stopped believing anyone else could.

Lupe drove home with both hands tight on the wheel.

At 10:14 that night someone knocked at her door.

She did not answer.

At 10:16 the knock came again.

Not loud… Politely... That was the worst of it.

They drove her east of town in a pickup that smelled of dust, oil, and feed. Her wrists were zip-tied. A sack had been pulled over her head but not cinched, and through a fold in the cloth she saw the dark seam of county road give way to caliche. No one spoke. Men who talk are still trying to justify themselves. The argument had ended days ago over coffee and legal pads. What remained was only the work of carrying out a decision that had already learned how to call itself necessary.

The cattle guard rang beneath the pickup.

Thousands of hooves had crossed this country before steel learned to imitate them. Bison. Antelope. Horses that belonged to no nation until nations insisted on claiming them. The earth remembered weight. It had never cared what name the weight answered to.

Dust settled behind the truck… They walked her across pasture grass in silence. A grasshopper sprang from under her shoe and vanished. Ahead, the abandoned shaft waited, ringed with rust and weathered timber.

Ahead, the abandoned shaft waited.

The stone below had already grown old when the first man decided there was profit buried inside it. It watched miners descend with hope and return with broken backs. It watched companies disappear... Gravity outlived every owner the county ever recorded.

They stopped at the edge.

Wade stood beside her.

“I am sorry,” he said.

Lupe looked at him.

“No,” she said. “You’re not.”

Then hands took her.

The shaft accepted her without argument.

Two weeks passed before Roosevelt County admitted Lupe Hernandez was missing.

Her sister called. Martin said he had not seen her since Tuesday. Wade gave a statement about concern and cooperation. The Sheriff took notes and did not look directly at Wade because there are towns where eye contact is a form of accusation and accusation requires courage.

Life continued, because life has a grotesque talent for doing that. Children played baseball under lights. Women bought paper towels and green chiles. A calf was pulled from a heifer west of Dora. Men stood outside Allsup’s with coffee and spoke about wind, diesel, school board rumors… anything but Lupe.

The Council met once and did not say her name.

For a while nothing happened… That mattered.

Nothing happened so steadily that the county relaxed into it. The living love routines because it tells them the dead have failed to interrupt anything essential…

…Then Dale Rook’s north well brought up warm water.

Not hot water mind you... Not strange enough to mention twice… Just warm enough that when he cupped it in his hand before dawn, he frowned.

“Line’s been sitting,” his son said.

“Pump’s been running twenty minutes.”

They said no more.

The next week meadowlarks stopped landing in Samuel Price’s south pasture. Crows came. Hawks came. Grackles came with their oily shine and bad manners. But meadowlarks crossed the fence line and lifted again as if the field itself had spoken against them.

At the cooperative, pipes began ticking after closing.

Martin heard it first. He sat alone in his office with the lights off because he had nowhere else to put his guilt. Tick. Tick. Tick. Not regular enough for machinery. Too regular for settling.

He put both hands over his ears… The ticking continued.

At Clint Harrow’s dairy, one pivot turned after the pump had been shut down. Slowly… One degree at a time… The hired man filmed it and posted the video online until Clint made him remove it and threatened his job. The mechanic said air in the line… Faulty valve… Pressure… Something normal… There is always a normal word available if a man is frightened enough to need one.

Then a sinkhole opened beside an abandoned road section three miles from the mine shaft. County workers marked it with cones. By morning the cones were gone.

Not knocked over… Gone.

In their place, was a damp line in the dirt running east and then south, thin as a vein, visible only until the sun rose high enough to erase it.

An old woman driving to Portales saw it and crossed herself without knowing why.

The Pecos came up overnight.

No rain had fallen in Roosevelt County. No storm had come down from the north. No arroyo had run. Yet at dawn the river moved higher against its banks, brown and quiet, carrying reeds and foam and one cottonwood branch stripped clean of bark.

The Pecos had been gathering water long before Roosevelt County learned to count it. Snowmelt from mountains no one here could see. Forgotten springs. Buried seepage. Seasons stacked upon seasons until movement itself became distant memories. Rivers have never cared about who believed they owned the water. They simply carry what the land surrenders.

A rancher found her just after sunrise.

Lupe Hernandez lay among reeds on a bend of the Pecos as if the river had set her there carefully. Her clothes were torn. Her skin had gone the pale color of caliche under moonlight. Her right hand was closed around wet dust packed hard in her fist.

Maps came out… Old mine surveys were unfolded… Elevations were checked… Hydrologists were called… Men who had ignored science for decades suddenly developed a touching affection for it, like sinners discovering theology at the gallows.

The autopsy found no water in her lungs… That troubled everyone…

…Apparently, not enough though.

Wade attended the funeral and stood at the back of the church in a dark suit while Lupe’s sister wept with a sound that made decent people look at the ground. He shook hands afterward. He said the appropriate words. Then he went home and sat in his truck until dark, watching his own house like it belonged to a stranger.

Three days later Martin Bell hanged himself in his garage… He left no note.

He did leave a folder on the kitchen table with copies of transfers, signatures, council minutes, and one handwritten sentence on the top page.

Water remembers downhill.

After that, events acquired the terrible clarity of things men call coincidence because judgment is too expensive.

Samuel Price lost two wells in one morning. Not to drought. Not to mechanical failure. The casings collapsed inward cleanly, as if the earth had pinched them shut between finger and thumb. Dale Rook’s finest quarter section subsided six inches overnight, enough to crack the concrete pad beneath his irrigation motor and tilt the pivot eastward like a praying thing. Clint Harrow’s dairy lagoon breached though the berm held intact, and the waste ran not outward but down through fissures that had not been there the day before.

Wade drove from place to place saying little.

His voice remained calm. His tie remained straight. Both were mistaken for strength.

But Wade had begun to hear water.

At first only in pipes. Then beneath roads. Then under the courthouse steps when he walked in for a hearing. It was not loud. It was worse than loud. It was intimate.

At night he dreamed of underground movement. Water finding passages no map had ever recorded. Slow pressure through dark stone. In the dream, maps dissolved. County lines bled away. Deeds opened like leaves and rotted in courthouse drawers. Men stood above the land naming and renaming things while beneath them the water passed on without witness.

He woke each time with his mouth full of dust.

The hearing was scheduled for Thursday.

By then the folder had done its work. Reporters stood outside the courthouse sweating through shirts and pretending they understood Roosevelt County because they could pronounce Ogallala. The attorney general promised seriousness… Commissioners promised transparency… Every guilty man discovered legal language about process.

Wade testified for three hours.

He said conservation.

He said difficult choices.

He said future generations.

He said administrative irregularities.

He did not say Lupe.

Not once.

When the hearing ended, he walked alone to his truck. Across the courthouse lawn, sprinklers ticked in little arcs over grass that had no moral right to be green. Children played near the war memorial. An old man slept on a bench in the shade. Portales continued with the stubbornness of places that have survived too much to be impressed by scandal.

Wade drove east without deciding to.

The town fell behind him. Houses thinned. Then trailers. Then fences and fields and pump houses and cattle standing dumb and holy in the heat. The town fell behind him. Houses thinned. Then trailers. Then fences. Then nothing but the Llano stretching in every direction until distance stopped pretending it had an end. He passed the cooperative. He passed Price Equipment. He passed land he had helped transfer on paper from the desperate to the powerful in the name of saving everyone from themselves.

At the old gate he stopped.

The mine shaft lay beyond the fence in a pasture gone yellow beneath the sun. He climbed through the wire and tore his sleeve. Grasshoppers lifted and fell before his boots. The ground felt hollow in places, though perhaps it had always felt that way and he had never been listening.

The shaft waited… Wade stood at its edge.

Wind crossed the Llano without slowing for him. The same wind had carried Spanish dust, Comanche smoke, buffalo scent, diesel exhaust, and now the quiet breathing of a man who had mistaken stewardship for dominion.

“I did what I thought was right,” he said.

The land did not answer. A pebble slipped from the rim and fell. He never heard it strike bottom. Instead, far below, impossible and unmistakable, he heard water moving. Not rushing… Not roaring… Moving. Passing through darkness with the patience of a thing that did not need to hurry because hurry belonged to creatures with short lives.

Wade stepped back.

He had spent his life believing he was the architect of Roosevelt County’s future. Standing alone beneath a sky too large for ownership, he understood at last that he had been only a brief interruption in a landscape that measured time in aquifers, buffalo trails, caliche, and wind. Elections passed. Boards dissolved. Deeds yellowed in courthouse drawers…

…The land had never learned their names.

His well went dry that evening….

…So did Price’s.

…So did Rook’s.

…So did Harrow’s.

The town wells ran clear.

For a while.

Investigators later wrote reports full of competent words. Infrastructure failure. Groundwater depletion. Subsurface instability. Fraudulent conveyance. Criminal conspiracy. Homicide. Suicide. Coincidence appeared nowhere in the official documents, though it remained the preferred explanation among men who had once believed paper could command water.

Lupe Hernandez was buried in Portales beneath a stone paid for by women who had never met together before and never stopped meeting afterward.

The Council of Stewardship dissolved in disgrace.

New boards were formed.

New regulations drafted.

New men sat in rooms with coffee and legal pads and spoke carefully about the future.

Beyond town, the wind crossed the cattle guards and empty fields. Grass grew where no one had seeded it. A cracked pivot stood against the horizon. It would never finish another circle. At night, pipes in older houses ticked and settled, and sometimes children woke saying they had heard someone counting beneath the floor.

Their mothers told them it was only water… They were not wrong.

Beneath Roosevelt County, beneath every argument of ownership and need, beneath the old hunger of men who mistook stewardship for dominion, the Ogallala continued in darkness.

It had survived mammoths.

It had survived empires.

It had survived prayer.

It would survive deeds.

And somewhere under the caliche, where no courthouse could summon it and no council could command it, the water kept moving downhill.

Leave a comment

“You’re an asshole.”

“You’re an asshole.”

“You’re an asshole.”

The words echoed through the Walmart juice aisle like someone had mistaken public humiliation for a personality.

I looked at my wife, Kamille.

She looked back at me and started laughing.

“Holy shit,” she whispered. “It’s Larry.”

Larry looked like somebody had fed the Keebler Elf biscuits and regret for forty years before stuffing him into cargo shorts.

He pushed his shopping cart toward me with the determination of a man who had confused confrontation with cardio.

“You’re an asshole!”

I smiled.

“Jesus loves you, Larry. I’ll pray for your soul.”

He thought about that for approximately half a second.

Then shouted, “Fuck you.”

Fair enough, I thought to myself… Since I am an asshole, I don’t want to disappoint you. I raised my voice just loud enough for everyone comparing orange juice prices to hear.

“Larry... I told you before... you cannot touch my penis.”

The entire aisle froze.

Yogurt shopping ceased.

Time itself considered getting involved.

One woman quietly moved her cart between Larry and her husband…

…Apparently, she’d already reached a verdict.

Larry turned a color usually reserved for emergency flares.

“I never...”

“Then stop asking!”

Larry opened his mouth to respond and nothing came out. Even his comeback abandoned him. At that point, the trial had already concluded in the Court of Walmart Opinion.

Somewhere behind us, I heard a child ask, “Mommy, what’s an asshole?”

Note to self: Larry had accidentally become this week’s homeschooling curriculum.

I swear I saw a Walmart employee leaning around the end cap like he’d already placed five bucks on the outcome.

Yep… Fuck you, Larry.

Now you’re probably wondering why Walmart’s answer to the Keebler Elf has dedicated what appears to be the remainder of his natural life to announcing that I’m an asshole.

Fair question.

A few weeks earlier, Larry decided it was his civic duty to confront a group of protesters in town. I happened to be there doing my independent photographer and reporter thing. Larry proceeded to perform an interpretive dance called How to Embarrass Yourself in Public while I calmly documented the whole production.

Cameras have one unforgivable habit… They remember.

Ever since then, Larry has appointed himself President, CEO, and sole shareholder of the “Jon Is an Asshole” Appreciation Society. Membership currently stands at one, but I admire his commitment to a dying organization.

So now, whenever our paths cross, Larry tries his absolute best to bait me into a confrontation. At this point, I’m pretty sure hating me has become part of Larry’s daily routine.

I imagine Larry wakes up every morning, pours himself a cup of coffee, stares thoughtfully out the window, and thinks:

You know what would make today productive?

Finding that asshole from Walmart.

I’m sixty years old.

I’ve survived wars, watched friends die, been shot at by people with considerably better aim, and collected enough scars to qualify as a historical landmark. Being called an asshole by a grown man who treats every Walmart like it’s the Roman Coliseum doesn’t exactly register on my threat assessment.

The funniest part is that Larry has somehow confused persistence with victory. Every time he sees me, he’s convinced this will be the day I finally get angry. Instead, he keeps entertaining strangers who were just trying to buy orange juice.

The jury has already made up its mind.

I don’t need to win.

Larry keeps doing that for me.

Leave a comment

I was here before your first fire. Before your first word. Before the first frightened child pressed a paint-covered hand against the wall of a cave and unknowingly left something that would outlive them. I kept it. I have kept everything.

I remember rivers that no longer exist. I remember languages spoken by mouths that turned to dust before your oldest monuments were imagined. I remember every God you have ever worshipped, the forgotten ones, the victorious ones, and the murdered ones.

I remember the canyon where stone became scripture, where generations returned to the same walls and covered them with stories written in ash, ochre, and the imprint of a human hand.

I remember the valley where the dead were buried facing the morning sun for longer than kingdoms would endure.

I remember the day words learned they could burn, and ignorance celebrated its first victory.

I remember the grasslands where the earth once shook beneath countless hooves until silence inherited the horizon.

I remember the mountain that stood long before nations existed, until someone discovered what lay beneath it was worth more than what stood upon it.

Every civilization eventually comes to me with the same bargain.

“Just this once.”

Just this once, open the mountain.

Just this once, flood the valley.

Just this once, cut down the grove.

Just this once, move the people.

Just this once, the cave must give way.

Just this once, the old stories must make room for the new.

It is always temporary.

It is always necessary.

It is always progress.

You have been making that promise for twelve thousand years.

I have watched empires redraw borders until they forgot who first drew them. I have watched flags replace flags, gods replace gods, kings replace kings, and ideologies replace kingdoms. Every generation becomes convinced it has finally discovered the one idea worthy of sacrificing everything that came before it.

You speak often of preserving the past. You rarely notice you are standing on it. The oldest songs become parking lots. Sacred ground becomes a mining claim. The oldest stories become environmental impact assessments. Memory becomes an obstacle to efficiency.

You call it development.

You call it growth.

You call it necessity.

I call it forgetting.

You imagine I disappear in catastrophes. I do not. I disappear quietly.

One permit.

One signature.

One vote.

One rationalization at a time.

I survive in broken pottery buried beneath highways. I survive in cave paintings hidden behind collapsed stone. I survive in lullabies remembered by the last grandmother who still knows the words. I survive wherever someone refuses to forget.

I will outlive you, as I have outlived every empire that mistook itself for permanent. But you inherit only what you choose not to destroy.

When the last sacred place has been paved, when the last forgotten language falls silent, and when the last child asks where they came from, do not tell them nothing was lost.

I was there.

I remember.

You have always called me History.

I have always remembered you.

Humanity did not lose its past one century at a time.

It lost it one rationalization at a time.

Leave a comment

By the third time someone apologized for the passing of my mother, I stopped correcting them.

The first was a girl at Allsup’s.

“I’m sorry about your mama,” she said, sliding my coffee across the counter.

“My mother died before you were born.”

She nodded like she was listening to someone else.

“Still sorry.”

The second was an old man outside the courthouse.

“She didn’t mean to leave you.”

He kept feeding cracker crumbs to pigeons that weren’t there. The third was a boy outside the Do Drop In eating a cinnamon roll.

“I liked your dog,” he said.

“I never had a dog.”

“You wanted one when you were nine.”

He bit into a cinnamon roll and smiled at someone behind me.

That night my phone lit up. It was an Unknown Number… “You buried the butterfly behind the propane tank.”

I had forgotten… Until I hadn’t… Blue wings… Small hands.

My six-year-old grief had no language for guilt. I buried it behind the propane tank, then dug it back up two days later because I thought apologies worked backward if you meant them enough.

Then, another message arrived. “You cried when no one came looking.”

Before sunrise I drove east, past Portales, toward a place my grandfather called Hungry Land. The mesquite gave up first, then the fence posts. Even the wind seemed unwilling to cross the last stretch of caliche. An abandoned irrigation well stood alone. There was no pump, no cattle, and no birds. The dirt around it held no tracks. It was as if nothing ever arrived… Or ever left.

I looked down... There was no water… There was no bottom. Only the awful impression that I had caught something pretending not to watch me. It spoke in my father’s voice, then my wife’s, then mine… Then the voice I use when I dream.

“You have lived less of your life than you think.”

“What are you?”

Silence… Then… “I’ve known you since before you had a name.”

Cold air drifted upward. It told me everything…

…Not what happened.

…What almost happened.

The truck that almost crossed the centerline outside Clovis.

The son we almost had.

The person I almost became.

Then it told me about you… You paused there… Most people do… You think you’re reading my story.

No… I need you to keep reading. You buried yours deeper.

Not bodies… Just the parts of yourself you couldn’t bear to keep.

News Flash: Nothing forgotten disappears… It drains.

Down through memory.

Down through shame.

Down beneath whatever town taught you how to lie.

I know what you buried.

You do too.

That’s why you kept reading.

If you don’t remember me tomorrow...

I’ll know you’ve already forgotten yourself.

Leave a comment

“The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either, but right through every human heart.”

Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago

Part I: When Civilizations Build Libraries

Every civilization eventually leaves behind two monuments.

The first is built from questions.

The second from answers that fear them.

Eventually, we give them names.

The Library.

The Tribunal.

One exists to discover truth.

The other exists to defend approved truth.

Every generation decides which one deserves another stone.

The stone changes… The instinct does not.

The Library begins with a question.

The Tribunal begins with a verdict.

The Library assumes reality still has something to teach us.

The Tribunal assumes reality has already been settled.

History has a cruel sense of humor… and it is unforgiving.

It delights in humiliating civilizations convinced they have always stood on the side of enlightenment.

Every generation eventually believes it has escaped the mistakes of those who came before it… Every generation is wrong.

Between the eighth and thirteenth centuries, much of the Islamic world experienced what historians call the Islamic Golden Age.^1

While much of Western Europe remained politically fragmented after the fall of Rome, scholars working under Islamic rule were translating, preserving, debating, criticizing, and expanding the accumulated knowledge of Greece, Persia, India, and Rome.

This was not a civilization standing still… It was one asking questions.

Al-Khwarizmi gave the world algebra.

Ibn al-Haytham transformed optics by insisting that observation and experimentation carried greater authority than inherited assumptions. Many historians of science regard his work as one of the earliest systematic demonstrations of the experimental method.^2

Avicenna wrote The Canon of Medicine, a text that remained standard reading in European universities for centuries.^3

Astronomers refined measurements of the heavens.

Physicians advanced surgery, pharmacology, and ophthalmology.

Mathematicians invented new languages of numbers.

Geographers mapped a wider world.

Philosophers argued with Aristotle rather than simply worshiping him.

Knowledge was expected to withstand examination.

It was not expected to avoid it.

Libraries flourished in Baghdad, Cordoba, and Cairo.

Among them stood the legendary House of Wisdom… It was more than a library.

It was a civilization announcing what it believed deserved protection.

Inside its walls, Christian, Jewish, and Muslim scholars translated ancient manuscripts, challenged one another’s conclusions, compared competing ideas, and preserved works that might otherwise have disappeared forever.^4

That image matters… Not because it flatters Islam.

Because it reminds us what civilizations look like when they possess enough confidence to invite disagreement.

History is less a story of isolated civilizations than of borrowed ideas crossing borders that politics could never completely close.

Europe’s first universities did not emerge from a vacuum.

They inherited centuries of preserved philosophy, mathematics, medicine, astronomy, and logic that flowed through Islamic Spain, Sicily, and the great translation schools before becoming woven into Europe’s own intellectual tradition.^5

Civilizations rarely invent themselves.

More often, they inherit one another.

The Renaissance did not arrive alone.

It arrived carrying books someone else had refused to let die.

The Islamic world would later experience periods in which intellectual openness narrowed, philosophical inquiry yielded to religious orthodoxy [in many places], and scholars found fewer spaces in which difficult questions could safely be asked.^6

The point is not that one civilization was enlightened while the other was barbaric… History is never that generous.

The point is that every civilization eventually chooses what it will protect.

Some protect inquiry… Some protect conclusions.

Some, for a brief and extraordinary moment, manage to protect both.

Then history turns.

Notes

1. The House of Wisdom; The Venture of Islam.

2. The House of Wisdom;

3. The Canon of Medicine; The House of Wisdom.

4. The House of Wisdom; The House of Wisdom.

5. Aristotle’s Children; The Venture of Islam.

6. The Closing of the Muslim Mind. (Included as one interpretation of the later intellectual history of parts of the Islamic world; many historians debate aspects of Reilly’s thesis, which is precisely why it belongs alongside the other works rather than replacing them.)

Part II: When Questions Become Crimes

Then history turned.

In 1258, the Mongols sacked Baghdad.

The House of Wisdom disappeared beneath fire and blood.

Books that had survived empires vanished in smoke.

Knowledge itself became collateral damage.^1

History would eventually remember the destruction.

It would remember something else as well.

Nearly two and a half centuries later, in 1486, two Dominican clergymen published a book that would become one of the most infamous manuals in European history.

The Malleus Maleficarum.

The Hammer of Witches.

Not a work of astronomy.

Not a medical encyclopedia.

Not a philosophical inquiry.

A manual explaining how to identify witches, evaluate evidence, interrogate suspects, obtain confessions, and prosecute people accused of serving Satan.^2

Read that sentence again.

One civilization had spent centuries preserving the intellectual inheritance that would eventually help fuel Europe’s Renaissance.

The other produced a manual for converting fear into evidence and suspicion into law.

That contrast is not meant to humiliate Christianity or romanticize Islam.

History refuses to flatter either civilization.

Both have given humanity breathtaking achievements.

Both have also convinced themselves, at various moments, that they had finally reached conclusions too sacred to examine.

The Malleus Maleficarum did not ask whether witches existed.

It assumed they did.

Its purpose was not to discover truth.

Its purpose was to make doubt impossible.

Somewhere, a frightened woman stood before educated men carrying a book that assured them God required her death.

They believed they were defending truth.

She was trying to survive.

History doesn’t need embellishment.

Reality has always been perfectly capable of horrifying us without fiction’s assistance.

Before someone rushes to Salem, let’s be historically honest.

The Salem witch trials did not burn people at the stake.

Nineteen people were hanged.

Giles Corey was pressed to death beneath heavy stones after refusing to enter a plea.

Burning alleged witches occurred far more frequently in parts of continental Europe than colonial America.^3

The truth is already terrible enough.

It requires no exaggeration.

This is where history stops being about Christians or Muslims.

It becomes about us.

Every civilization eventually discovers that knowledge and power are uneasy companions.

Knowledge has no loyalty except to evidence.

Power prefers loyalty over evidence.

Knowledge asks uncomfortable questions.

Power prefers comfortable answers.

When power grows tired of being questioned, it stops building libraries.

Every civilization eventually mistakes one of its opinions for eternal truth.

The moment an opinion becomes sacred, disagreement begins looking like heresy.

That mistake has worn crowns.

It has worn robes.

It has worn uniforms.

Today it often wears hashtags.

The rest of history is the consequences.

The real conflict has never been Christianity versus Islam.

Or East versus West.

Or ancient versus modern.

The conflict has always been between civilizations confident enough to ask questions...

…and civilizations frightened enough to outlaw them.

The distance between The Library and The Tribunal is measured by the number of questions a civilization is willing to forbid.

Civilizations are defined less by the answers they cherish than by the questions they allow to be asked.

As Carl Sagan once observed:

“It is far better to grasp the universe as it really is than to persist in delusion.”

The Library understands this.

The Tribunal fears it.

Neither building believes itself evil.

That is what makes history so dangerous.

The inquisitor believed he was protecting souls.

The censor believed he was protecting order.

The revolutionary believed he was protecting justice.

The bureaucrat believes he is protecting safety.

Every Tribunal has believed itself necessary.

Very few have believed themselves wrong.

History has no interest in flattering our ancestors.

It has even less interest in flattering us.

Every generation eventually encounters its own version of The Library and The Tribunal.

Ours is no exception.

Notes

1. The House of Wisdom; The House of Wisdom.

2. The Malleus Maleficarum; The Malleus Maleficarum and the Construction of Witchcraft.

3. The Witch; European Witch Trials.

Part III: The Mirror We Inherit

One contemporary example illustrates why this history still matters.

At its 2026 Annual Meeting, the Southern Baptist Convention overwhelmingly approved the first step toward a constitutional amendment intended to further clarify that cooperating churches should affirm that only men serve in the office and function of pastor. The denomination has long held that the office of pastor is reserved for qualified men under its understanding of Scripture. The proposed amendment seeks to make that conviction even more explicit within the Convention’s governing documents.^8

The Southern Baptist Convention has every constitutional right to organize itself according to its understanding of Scripture.

My argument is not about that right.

My argument is about history.

Many critics of Islam rightly point to restrictions placed upon women in numerous Muslim-majority societies.

Those criticisms deserve to be heard.

Yet some of those same voices defend remarkably similar restrictions on women’s religious authority within their own churches.

When a religious tradition concludes that public authority belongs permanently to men because questioning that arrangement would be questioning God Himself, it has crossed from investigation into orthodoxy.

Whether that conclusion comes from the Bible, the Qur’an, or any other sacred text is historically less important than many people imagine.

The comparison is not theological.

It is structural.

The histories differ.

The doctrines differ.

The legal traditions differ.

The cultures differ.

But when viewed through the lens of authority rather than theology, the underlying architecture begins to look remarkably familiar.

The garments differ.

The language differs.

The scriptures differ.

History rarely repeats itself.

Its hierarchies often rhyme.

Too often we condemn patriarchal authority when it appears in traditions we consider foreign while defending remarkably similar structures when they appear in our own.

That isn’t historical analysis.

It’s tribal loyalty masquerading as moral consistency.

Not because one religion is uniquely susceptible to dogmatism.

Every great civilization has, at one point or another, mistaken inherited authority for eternal truth.

Every great civilization has also produced men and women courageous enough to question it.

The struggle has never belonged to one faith.

It belongs to humanity.

Thomas Aquinas could not have become Thomas Aquinas without Aristotle.

Europe could not have recovered Aristotle without generations of Muslim and Jewish scholars who preserved, translated, debated, criticized, and transmitted those texts across centuries.^9

Civilizations are indebted to one another far more often than they are willing to admit.

History is less a story of isolated civilizations than of borrowed ideas crossing borders that politics could never completely close.

Perhaps that is the deepest irony of all.

The civilizations that imagine themselves completely separate are often built from one another’s stones.

The Library survives because someone believes truth has nothing to fear from investigation.

The Tribunal survives because someone fears investigation might uncover the wrong truth.

Someday historians will write about us.

They will not care which political party we joined.

They will not care which denomination claimed us.

They will not care which slogan we repeated most loudly.

They will ask a far older question.

When your generation had the chance...

...did you build another Library?

Or another Tribunal?

The only unanswered question is which monument our children will be forced to inhabit…

…Every stone is already in our hands.

Notes

1. Jim Al-Khalili, The House of Wisdom: How Arabic Science Saved Ancient Knowledge and Gave Us the Renaissance (New York: Penguin Press, 2011); Marshall G. S. Hodgson, The Venture of Islam, Vols. 1–3 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1974).

2. Jim Al-Khalili, The House of Wisdom; Jonathan Lyons, The House of Wisdom: How the Arabs Transformed Western Civilization (New York: Bloomsbury Press, 2009).

3. Avicenna, The Canon of Medicine; Jonathan Lyons, The House of Wisdom.

4. Richard E. Rubenstein, Aristotle’s Children: How Christians, Muslims, and Jews Rediscovered Ancient Wisdom and Illuminated the Middle Ages (New York: Harcourt, 2003).

5. Jonathan Lyons, The House of Wisdom.

6. Hans Peter Broedel, The Malleus Maleficarum and the Construction of Witchcraft: Theology and Popular Belief (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2003); Richard Kieckhefer, European Witch Trials (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1976).

7. Ronald Hutton, The Witch: A History of Fear, from Ancient Times to the Present (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2017).

8. Southern Baptist Convention, proceedings and actions of the 2026 Annual Meeting; see also contemporary reporting on the proposed constitutional amendment regarding the office and function of pastor.

9. Richard E. Rubenstein, Aristotle’s Children; Marshall G. S. Hodgson, The Venture of Islam.

Further Reading

If you disagree with me, good.

Don’t argue with memes.

Don’t argue with headlines.

Read history.

The books below do not all agree with one another. Some openly challenge each other’s conclusions. That is precisely why they belong on the same shelf.

If The Library teaches us anything, it is that truth rarely emerges from reading only the authors who already agree with us.

Primary Sources

• Heinrich Kramer, Malleus Maleficarum (1486).

• Avicenna, The Canon of Medicine.

Historical Scholarship

• Jim Al-Khalili, The House of Wisdom.

• Jonathan Lyons, The House of Wisdom.

• Marshall G. S. Hodgson, The Venture of Islam.

• Hans Peter Broedel, The Malleus Maleficarum and the Construction of Witchcraft.

• Ronald Hutton, The Witch: A History of Fear, from Ancient Times to the Present.

• Richard E. Rubenstein, Aristotle’s Children.

• Robert R. Reilly, The Closing of the Muslim Mind.

Reilly’s work is an intentionally challenging inclusion. Many historians dispute aspects of his thesis regarding the later intellectual development of the Islamic world.

That is exactly why it belongs on this list.

A library worth entering contains disagreement.

A tribunal permits only one approved conclusion.

Leave a comment

The age of consent is not the age of maturity. And if the only way you ever learned was through humiliation, force, fear, or pain, you may grow into the sort of person who assumes everyone else must be taught the same way. That is the moral logic of the asshole. He universalizes his wounds, mistakes damage for wisdom, and calls cruelty honesty because it is the only language that ever got through to him.

We live in a culture infested with people who confuse brutality with clarity. They call themselves truth tellers. They pride themselves on being blunt and they boast that they do not sugarcoat things, as if tact were treason and cruelty were proof of moral seriousness. They imagine themselves to be surgeons of the soul, cutting away delusions with the clean blade of hard truths… They are not surgeons at all. They are wounded people swinging hammers in a room full of glass and congratulating themselves for the honesty of the wreckage.

There is a difference between truth and aggression. There is a difference between correction and humiliation. There is a difference between demanding accountability and taking pleasure in another person’s collapse. Adults are supposed to know that difference. Assholes either do not know it or know it perfectly well and have built an entire philosophy around pretending they do not.

The most dangerous version of this person is not the obvious sadist. That one is easy enough to spot. The dangerous one is the self-appointed realist, the veteran of private wars who has decided that because suffering once taught him something, suffering is therefore the best teacher available to mankind. He does not merely remember his pain, he canonizes it… He builds a pulpit out of it… He turns his scars into a curriculum and then wonders why everyone around him leaves class limping.

Somewhere along the way, a lot of people absorbed a grotesque little lie: that whatever hurt you must have helped you, because otherwise the pain would have been meaningless. It is an understandable lie. Human beings are desperate to redeem suffering. We want our injuries to mean something. We want the humiliation to have forged character, the neglect to have produced resilience, the abuse to have created toughness, the loneliness to have made us wise. Sometimes adversity does produce strength. Sometimes pain does sharpen perception. But pain is not therefore sacred, and damage is not automatically instruction. A house fire can teach you to respect smoke. That does not make arson a mentoring strategy.

This is where the moral logic of the asshole takes root. He cannot bear the possibility that some of what formed him was not noble, not necessary, not instructive, but merely cruel. Instead, he retrofits cruelty into a principle. He calls it discipline… He calls it realism… He calls it preparation. He says the world is hard and therefore people must be hardened. He says feelings do not matter, that shame builds character, that embarrassment creates strength, that public humiliation teaches lessons gentleness never could. He says all of this with the grave confidence of a man who has mistaken surviving a beating for proof that beatings are educational.

And because human beings are masters of self-deception, he can even make this sound virtuous. He can say he is just being honest. He can say he is holding the line. He can say he refuses to coddle weakness. He can wrap his cruelty in the language of standards and persuade himself that what he enjoys is not domination but moral seriousness. That is the trick. The asshole rarely experiences himself as an asshole. He experiences himself as the last sane man in a nation of cowards. He thinks he is preserving civilization when in fact he is often just reenacting his own injury with better vocabulary.

You can see this everywhere once you know what you are looking for. You see it in parents who mistake intimidation for guidance and then act bewildered when their children learn to hide rather than to trust. You see it in coaches who humiliate instead of teach, in bosses who belittle instead of lead, in pastors who berate people from the pulpit and call it conviction, in internet prophets who excoriate people for emoji applause and brand it authenticity. You see it in every grown adult who has confused emotional blunt-force trauma with mentorship.

These people love the phrase hard truth because it flatters them. It allows them to imagine that the hardness lies in the truth itself rather than in their own delivery. But truth does not require theatrical cruelty to remain true. A thing can be painful without being abusive. A correction can be sharp without being demeaning. A boundary can be firm without becoming sadistic. The problem is that many people have no idea how to separate firmness from contempt because contempt was the atmosphere in which they were raised, coached, corrected, married, or loved. They learned through injury, and now they cannot imagine education without blood in its mouth.

The truly grim part is that this logic reproduces itself. The humiliated become humiliators. The cornered become cornerers. The publicly shamed become connoisseurs of public shame. Not always, thank God, but often enough to poison families, workplaces, churches, friendships, and entire political cultures. One generation learns that pain is proof of seriousness, and the next generation inherits the same bullshit dressed up as toughness.

None of this is an argument for softness, cowardice, or the modern cult of pretending that every uncomfortable feeling is violence. Some truths do hurt. Some people do need correction. Some behavior deserves confrontation, and some illusions need to be smashed with a chair. But the purpose of correction is illumination, not degradation. The point is to make a person more capable of seeing reality, not less capable of trusting another human being ever again. If your method leaves people smaller, more frightened, more concealed, and more ashamed than before, there is a fair chance you are not teaching. You are merely exporting your damage.

I know this because I know what it means to have grief weaponized.

I know what it means to be a child with both parents dead and still somehow be handed the blame for the wreckage left behind. I know what it means to have an adult with custody over you take your mother’s depression, your mother’s suicide, and all the confusion and devastation that came with it, then turn it into a weapon and aim it at a child. I know what it means to be told that your mother killed herself because she hated you. I know what it means to be taught, in the ugliest possible terms, that weakness is fatal, that need is shameful, that tears are dangerous, that trust is for fools, and that love is just another word people use before they leave.

That kind of childhood does not make you wise. It makes you armed.

It teaches you to scan every room for betrayal. It teaches you to assume every kindness has an invoice attached to it. It teaches you that no one will ever love you for yourself, that everyone has an angle, that the dead were the only people who might have loved you without negotiation and now they are gone, so you had better learn to survive without tenderness. It turns a child into a lookout post. It turns a human being into a bunker with a pulse.

And for a long time, that bunker works.

It keeps you alive. It keeps you moving. It keeps you from asking for help, because asking for help feels like exposing your throat to people who have already shown you what they do with exposed throats. It teaches you how to take a hit and stay standing. It teaches you how to lock pain in a basement and keep walking above it like the floorboards are not creaking. It teaches you endurance, suspicion, hypervigilance, self-containment, and the sort of grim internal discipline that can drag a body through hell long after softer philosophies have tapped out.

I am not naive enough to pretend that trauma gave me nothing. That would be another lie. Some of the brutality of my youth was preparation for the brutality of my life. It is part of how I survived strokes, a brain hemorrhage, life flights, and dying three times in emergency rooms. Somewhere in that wreckage, my nervous system learned how to survive catastrophe. Somewhere in all that ruin, my body learned how to keep crawling after the building had already collapsed.

But survival is not sainthood, and damage is not wisdom.

That is the distinction the asshole cannot make. He takes the fact that pain hardened him and mistakes it for proof that pain improved him. He takes the fact that cruelty prepared him for war and decides cruelty must therefore be a virtue in peacetime. He confuses adaptation with enlightenment. He turns scar tissue into scripture. He builds a philosophy out of his untreated injuries and then demands that everyone else kneel before it.

That is why some people worship hard truths, cruelty, and public humiliation. Not because they are brave enough to face reality, but because they are too wounded to imagine any other method of instruction. They are not defending truth. They are defending the only pedagogy their pain ever gave them. They are not protecting standards. They are preserving an inheritance of damage.

Maturity begins when you finally learn to tell the difference.

It begins when you can say, without flinching, that some of what kept you alive also cost you too much. That some lessons were not noble, only necessary. That some forms of strength are really just untreated fear wearing combat gear. That surviving cruelty does not obligate you to call cruelty wise.

The age of consent is not the age of maturity. Maturity is not the ability to endure pain, inflict pain, or sneer at pain in others. Maturity is the discipline to stop canonizing what wounded you. It is the refusal to turn your private damage into public doctrine. It is the decision to tell the truth without needing to draw blood.

Anything less is not wisdom.

It is just scar tissue with a microphone.

Leave a comment

When I was seven years old my parents committed what modern courts would probably classify as a hate crime.

They sent me to Jesuit French Camp.

In New Mexico.

Take a moment and appreciate how absolutely insane that sentence is.

I grew up in a place where people spoke English, Spanish, Spanglish, Cowboy, Rancher, and occasionally Drunk.

Nobody spoke French.

French was something that happened to other countries as punishment.

Yet… somehow… my parents looked at a perfectly good New Mexico summer and said:

“You know what this child needs?”

“French Catholics.”

The camp was hidden somewhere in the mountains like it was ashamed of itself.

The moment we arrived I knew something was wrong.

No kids were running.

No kids were laughing.

No kids were throwing rocks at each other.

The natural activities of childhood had apparently been outlawed.

Instead, there were pale little weirdos walking around carrying prayer books and speaking French.

One kid looked at me directly in the eyes and said something that sounded like a goose having a stroke.

I asked if he was okay.

Turns out he was just ordering lunch.

The counselors were worse.

Every one of them looked like they’d recently lost an argument with joy.

They wore black robes.

Walked silently.

Appeared suddenly behind trees.

You’d turn around and there’d be a Jesuit priest standing there looking disappointed.

Not in you specifically.

In humanity.

The first morning they woke us up at five-thirty a.m.

Not with whistles.

Not with music.

With fucking Gregorian chants.

Imagine being seven years old and waking up to what sounds like fifty ghosts filing a noise complaint against the living.

My little ass launched out of bed convinced the Second Coming had arrived and I wasn’t making the roster.

Every day started the same.

Prayer.

French.

Prayer.

French.

More prayer.

More French.

At one point I wasn’t entirely sure which language God spoke anymore.

Lunch wasn’t lunch.

Lunch was “an opportunity for contemplation.”

That’s how they described beans.

Beans.

The same food that has haunted campfires, jail cells, cattle drives, and Greyhound bus stations since the dawn of human disappointment, proving that no matter how far civilization advances, somebody eventually says, “Fuck it, serve the beans.”

Every day.

Beans.

Sometimes French beans.

Sometimes holy beans.

Sometimes contemplative beans.

Still… motherfucking… beans.

One afternoon a priest asked me what I had learned.

I told him I’d learned beans have more denominations than Christianity.

He didn’t laugh.

That happened a lot.

By week three the chanting had started following me.

I’d hear it in the shower.

In the woods.

In my sleep.

One night I woke up and heard voices outside.

I looked through the cabin window.

There were twenty priests carrying candles through the trees singing in Latin.

Now maybe that was perfectly normal.

Maybe.

But if you’re seven years old and witness what appears to be a medieval exorcism happening in the New Mexico wilderness, you’re going to have questions.

Mostly concerning escape routes.

The breaking point came during French immersion.

A counselor informed me that for the next forty-eight hours we would only speak French.

I informed him that for the next forty-eight hours he could kiss my entire seven-year-old ass.

Unfortunately, I didn’t know how to say that in French… Fuck. My. Young. Life… Definitely, a missed educational opportunity.

« Pour les quarante-huit prochaines heures, il peut aller me lécher le cul en entier. » That’s the closest, idiomatic French equivalent that keeps the bite, the contempt, and the full-body dismissal of the original.

The rebellion began that night.

Twenty-eight campers met behind a storage shed.

Our demands were simple.

Less France.

More America.

Maybe a goddamn burrito smothered in Hatch green chile sauce, New Mexico style.

The movement collapsed almost immediately because nobody could agree on leadership and half the members got distracted by dessert.

Honestly, it was the most authentic democratic experience of my life.

Finally… graduation day arrived.

My mother picked me up.

I climbed into the truck looking like I’d survived the fall of Constantinople.

She smiled.

“So, Ian.”

“Did you learn French?”

I stared out the passenger window.

The mountains were shrinking behind us.

The chapel.

The candles.

The chanting.

The priests.

The beans.

God help me, the beans.

Then I answered.

“No.”

“What did you learn?”

I looked her dead in the eye.

“I learned that New Mexico was already weird enough.”

My mother laughed.

I didn’t.

The truck rolled south.

Mile after mile.

The farther we got from camp, the better I felt.

The chanting faded.

The smell of incense disappeared.

The urge to confess things I’d never actually done started wearing off.

For the first time in six weeks, I felt human again.

Then I reached into my duffel bag.

There was a mason jar.

I didn’t remember packing a mason jar.

Inside was a single bean.

Just one.

Perfectly centered.

Floating in water.

Attached was a tag.

Brother Étienne’s handwriting.

FOR EMERGENCIES.

I threw the damn thing out the window near Las Vegas, New Mexico.

Three days later it was sitting on my dresser.

My parents claimed they’d never seen it before.

That should have concerned them more than it did.

Years passed.

I grew up.

Joined the military.

Saw combat.

Traveled the world.

Visited countries where people were actively trying to kill me.

Honestly, most of those experiences felt less unsettling than Jesuit French Camp.

At least terrorists usually explain why they’re angry.

The French never do.

Then one day, decades later, I was sitting in a diner outside Tucumcari, New Mexico.

Minding my own business.

Drinking coffee.

Trying to enjoy the last few peaceful minutes before humanity inevitably disappointed me again.

A little old man walked past my booth.

Black coat.

Thin smile.

French accent.

He stopped.

Looked directly at me.

And said: “Brother Étienne says hello.”

Then he walked out.

I never saw him again.

The waitress swore nobody had entered the restaurant.

I paid my check and left.

Some mysteries aren’t worth solving.

A few years later I finally Googled Saint Ignatius French Immersion Camp.

Nothing.

No records.

No website.

No photographs.

No tax filings.

No maps.

Nothing.

The camp officially never existed.

Which would have been comforting if thirty-seven former campers hadn’t found each other online and discovered we all remembered the exact same things.

The chanting.

The candles.

The priests.

The beans.

One guy in Arizona still wakes up screaming in French.

The weird part?

He doesn’t speak French.

None of us do.

Not consciously.

Last month one of the former campers posted a photograph.

It showed the old chapel.

The mountains.

The camp sign.

Everything exactly as we remembered it.

Except for one detail.

There were forty-eight children standing in front of the chapel.

The problem is there were only forty-seven campers that summer.

We counted.

Repeatedly.

Because there wasn’t a hell of a lot else to do.

At the bottom of the photograph somebody had written:

THE FORTY-EIGHTH STUDENT FINALLY CAME HOME.

I don’t know what that means.

I don’t want to know what that means.

And if anybody reading this knows French, I’d appreciate it if you kept that shit to yourself.

Because I’m fifty-nine years old now.

And every night around 2:17 a.m., right before I fall asleep, I hear Gregorian chanting somewhere outside my bedroom window.

The same chanting.

The same voices.

The same melody.

Always getting a little closer.

And every morning when I wake up... there’s another goddamn bean on my nightstand.

The jar is full now.

I don’t remember filling it.

Last Tuesday, for the first time in fifty-two years, the beans started chanting back.

Not loudly.

Not all at once.

Just one bean.

Then another.

Then another.

Tiny little French whispers coming from the nightstand.

At 2:17 a.m.

Every night.

Getting clearer.

Getting closer.

Last night I finally understood one of the words.

It was my name.

And this morning...

for the first time since 1974...

there were forty-eight beans in the jar.

Forty-eight.

The exact number of children standing in that photograph.

I stared at the jar for a long time.

Then one of the beans cleared its throat.

In perfect English it said: “Brother Étienne would like a word.”

I stared back.

The bean stared back.

For a moment neither of us moved.

Then it sighed.

Exactly the way Brother Étienne used to sigh whenever someone asked a reasonable question.

That was the moment I realized the camp had finally found me.

Which was impressive…. Because I’d spent thirty years letting hostile governments, enemy combatants, and the Internal Revenue Service believe I was somewhere else.

I’ve slept with a loaded pistol ever since.

Not because I think it’ll help… But… Because doing nothing feels un-American.

Last night I woke up at 2:17 a.m.

The jar was gone.

All forty-eight beans were lined up on my dresser.

Facing east.

Chanting.

And sitting in the middle of them was a tiny burrito smothered in Hatch green chiles.

A peace offering?

Or a warning?

With the French, it’s impossible to tell.

I ate the burrito anyway.

Some lessons take fifty-two years to learn.

It was the best burrito I’d ever had.

Which worries me more than the beans.

Share

Leave a comment

In the beginning, the forest was quiet.

Not peaceful…quiet. The kind of quiet that has weight... The kind of quiet that remembers things.

Then humans arrived, and the quiet died screaming.

You came with your neon jackets and your Bluetooth speakers and your belief that the world is your open‑concept living room. You walked into the woods like you owned the deed. You left trash, noise, footprints, and the faint smell of anxiety.

And the forest watched.

We all watched.

The owls kept record… The ravens kept score... The wolves kept receipts.

And I, Bartholomew, kept patience.

But patience has teeth.

THE FIRST SIGN: THE HUMANS WHO DO NOT LISTEN

You wander into the woods and ask me:

“Do bears shit in the woods?”

As if this is the mystery of the universe… As if the cosmos hinges on my bowel movements.

Meanwhile, you people are out here:

• microwaving fish in office break rooms

• buying water bottles the size of toddlers

• arguing with strangers online like it’s a sacrament

• jogging at 5 a.m. for “fun”

• inventing new ways to ruin cheese

And I’m the one you interrogate?

The forest has judged you. The verdict is “unfit for continued stewardship.”

THE SECOND SIGN: THE RACCOON COUNCIL

The raccoons have convened. They have donned their ceremonial trash‑crowns. They have declared humanity a “failed experiment.”

Their minutes read:

“Humans cannot be trusted with fire, food storage, or common sense. We recommend replacement.”

The owls approved the motion. The squirrels abstained because they were fighting. The deer wept softly.

THE THIRD SIGN: THE RAVENS SPEAK PROPHECY

The ravens, who know everything, perched on the dead pine and croaked:

“The age of humans ends not with war, but with stupidity.”

And honestly? They’re not wrong.

You people are one TikTok trend away from self‑extinction.

THE FOURTH SIGN: THE BEAR RISES

I am a simple bear.

I enjoy fish… I enjoy naps… I enjoy watching tourists attempt to reverse a camper like they’re defusing a bomb.

But I have seen the omens.

I have seen hikers who bring no water. I have seen the campers who leave food out “just for a second.” I have seen the man who tried to hand‑feed me a Pop‑Tart.

And I have had enough.

The forest has had enough.

The old roots are stirring… The mountains are listening… The river is sharpening its voice.

THE FINAL SIGN: THE QUESTION

You ask me:

“Do bears shit in the woods?”

Yes. I shit in the woods. I shit with purpose. I shit with cosmic inevitability.

But the better question, the one you should fear is:

“Has the bear been watching me?”

Because I have.

And I have seen your species:

• argue about whether birds are real

• eat laundry detergent for internet points

• build houses in flood zones and act surprised

• create HOA boards

• invent leaf blowers

• elect people who don’t believe in weather

The forest has taken note.

The reckoning is not violent. It is not loud. It is not cinematic.

It is simply this:

The next time you’re walking through the woods wondering whether bears shit out here, remember something.

The answer is yes.

The better question is whether the bear has been watching you.

Because he probably has.

And based on what he’s seen...

the wildlife is beginning to suspect the wrong species got opposable thumbs.

Share

Leave a comment

My father always said a man should never trust food that came in a can. This was a bold stance from a man who treated Vienna sausages like communion wafers and once described gas‑station chili as “the closest thing I’ve had to a religious experience that didn’t involve tequila.”

Dad had survived two marriages, one tornado, three layoffs, and a prostate exam he still calls “a war crime with gloves.” With that in mind, for this Father’s Day, I decided to reward that resilience with the worst possible gift I could find.

A can of Campbell’s 100% Organic Soylent Green Soup.

I found it in an antique store outside Tucumcari, New Mexico, sitting beneath a glass case labeled:

NOT FOR SALE UNLESS YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE BUYING ABSOLUTELY NO REFUNDS ABSOLUTELY NO EXORCISMS ON PREMISES

Naturally, I bought it immediately.

The old woman behind the counter had hair that looked like it had been assembled from cigarette smoke, static electricity, and the regrets of men named Earl. Her eyes carried the permanent disappointment of someone who had watched civilization unfold and concluded we were a failed pilot episode.

“That one’s for fathers only,” she said.

“That sounds like a threat.”

“You got a father?”

“Unfortunately.”

“Twenty dollars.”

She said it like she was charging me for my own funeral.

The can sat beneath the glass smiling like a lie. Green and white… Cheerful… Innocent…

It looked like Andy Warhol had a nervous breakdown in a fallout shelter. The label promised:

SOYLENT GREEN SOUP 100% ORGANIC A HEARTY FAMILY FAVORITE SERVES FOUR, OR ONE GUILTY MAN BEST BEFORE: THE TRUTH COMES OUT… MAY CONTAIN: REGRETS, UNFINISHED BUSINESS, AND TRACES OF AUNT CAROL… DO NOT PREPARE WHILE THINKING ABOUT YOUR MISTAKES AND FOR GOD’S SAKE, DO NOT PREPARE WHILE SOBER!

I laughed… The old woman didn’t.

That should’ve been my first clue. My second clue was that the can felt warm, like it had a pulse. My third clue was that it whispered, “Finally,” when I picked it up.

Father’s Day

Dad opened the gift bag, looked inside, then looked at me like he was trying to remember which of his sins had grown up and learned to drive.

“What the hell is this?”

“Father’s Day lunch.”

“This some kind of vegan bullshit?”

“It says organic.”

“That’s worse. That’s vegan with a superiority complex.”

He turned the can over.

No ingredients. No barcode. No nutrition facts. Just a warning:

DO NOT PREPARE WHILE REMEMBERING THE DEAD AND DO NOT PREPARE WHILE BEING A LITTLE BITCH ABOUT IT

Dad squinted… “That’s oddly specific.”

“Probably marketing.”

“Marketing doesn’t warn people. Marketing convinces idiots to buy trucks with monthly payments that outlive their marriages.”

Then he carried the can into the kitchen.

That should’ve been my fourth clue. But I was raised by a man who once fixed a propane leak with electrical tape and a prayer, so bad decisions are hereditary.

The Kitchen

Dad’s kitchen hadn’t changed since 1987. Same wallpaper. Same magnets. Same stove. Same clock that had been five minutes slow since Reagan and seemed determined to die with the wrong time no matter how many times it was reset.

The moment the opener punctured the lid, the house made a god-awful sound… it didn’t just creak… It didn’t just settle… It groaned. It was like something ancient rolled over beneath the foundation and muttered, “Oh hell, he’s back.”

Dad looked up.

“You hear that?”

“The pipes said no.”

“The pipes can eat me.”

Then… the smell hit us… immediately.

It wasn’t necessarily rotten.

It smelled like cafeteria vegetables, wet pennies, old church carpet, and generational trauma. Underneath the odors lurked something familiar: awkward family reunions, burned pot roast, Thanksgiving arguments, and the scent of pretending Grandma wasn’t racist after her third sweet tea.

Dad leaned over the can.

“Huh…”

“Huh good or huh call a priest?”

“Huh like beef stew if the cow knew what happens after death and came back angry.”

He dumped the contents into a saucepan.

The soup slid out slowly… Too slowly... Like it was reconsidering its contract with reality.

It made a sound like boots being pulled from mud.

Then something inside the pot sighed.

A bubble rose, popped, and whispered, “Don’t let him add salt.”

Dad immediately reached for the salt.

“Dad.”

“What?”

“The soup just talked.”

“It’s a can of vegetables, not the Book of Revelation.”

“It specifically asked you not to add salt.”

“That’s how you know it needs salt.”

He dumped in half a teaspoon.

The pot screamed like something buried had just realized it wasn’t staying buried.

The Faces

Green vapor rose from the pot and twisted into faces. One wore glasses. Another had a mustache. A third looked exactly like every assistant principal who ever enjoyed suspending children.

The fourth looked like my grandfather.

Dad froze.

The vapor leaned forward.

“Harold.”

My father’s name was Harold.

I looked at him.

“Dad?”

Nothing.

The ghost continued.

“You ate the last piece of pie.”

Dad pointed at it.

“Oh, bullshit.”

“Thanksgiving. Nineteen seventy‑nine. Your mother saved it for me.”

“You were dead.”

“I was watching.”

“That’s creepy as hell, Pop.”

“You blamed the dog.”

“The dog had priors.”

More faces emerged.

“You never returned my socket wrench.” “You backed into my mailbox.” “You told Linda my potato salad was store‑bought.” “You said my chili tasted like wet ambition.” “You borrowed my ladder in ’93 and returned it shorter.” “You told people your second wife was ‘a learning experience.’”

Dad pointed at the bowling‑shirt ghost.

“You DID wear a toupee, Frank. I saw that thing catch a thermal over Clovis.”

Frank gasped like a Victorian widow and then quickly dissolved.

The Creature

The burner clicked on by itself.

The soup rose from the saucepan, forming a torso, arms, and a head with no eyes and a mouth full of alphabet noodles. It looked like a Michelin Man made of expired pesto and unresolved grudges.

When it spoke, its voice sounded like a funeral director trying to upsell cremation and a timeshare.

HAROLD EUGENE PARKER. FATHER. HUSBAND. OWNER OF SEVEN FLASHLIGHTS. NONE OF WHICH CONTAIN BATTERIES.

Dad crossed his arms.

“They had batteries when I put them away.”

The creature turned toward me.

SON OF HAROLD. BUYER OF NOVELTY GIFTS. BEARER OF RESENTMENTS. STILL OWES FORTY‑SEVEN DOLLARS TO BLOCKBUSTER.

“Fair.”

The Reckoning

“He missed your tenth birthday,” the soup whispered.

Dad lowered the spoon.

“I was working.”

“I know.”

“We needed money.”

“I know.”

“You said you understood.”

“I was ten.”

A silence settled over the kitchen, not movie theater silent… family silent. The kind that knows where the bones are buried and who buried them and which uncle helped.

Dad exhaled.

“I also bowled that night.”

“I know.”

“I bowled a 142.”

“That part hurts more.”

The creature leaned closer.

CONFESSION IMPROVES FLAVOR. DENIAL MAKES IT SPICY.

Dad stared into the pot.

“I missed more than I should have.”

The bubbling stopped.

The refrigerator went quiet.

Even the old clock paused, like it wanted to hear this.

“I thought providing was the same thing as being there,” he said. “It matters. But it isn’t the same thing.”

Damn him. The old bastard had found the truth.

The Meal

Dad ladled the soup.

My noodles spelled:

CALL MORE OFTEN

His spelled:

APOLOGIZE WITHOUT MAKING IT WEIRD

We sat down.

The soup smelled different now. Less apocalypse. More tomato basil with unresolved emotional baggage and a hint of generational shame.

Dad raised his spoon.

“To fathers.”

“To sons.”

We ate.

It tasted like every family dinner we’d ever survived. Salt. Pepper. Heat. Memory. Love. Regret. A little disappointment. A little forgiveness. And the faint aftertaste of a ghost judging your cholesterol.

Then the house exhaled.

The faces vanished. The cabinets shut themselves. The empty can collapsed inward with a tiny metallic burp.

Dad chewed thoughtfully.

“Needs crackers.”

I laughed so hard I nearly choked.

He laughed too; the quiet laugh older men use when they discover they’re still loved despite all the reasons they suspect they shouldn’t be.

THE AFTERMATH

Three weeks later another can appeared on Dad’s porch.

This one was meatloaf.

The label read:

WE ARE STILL DISCUSSING THE TREADMILL
AND YOUR CHOLESTEROL
AND THE INCIDENT WITH THE RACCOON
YOU KNOW WHAT YOU DID

Dad called immediately.

He sounded terrified.

He said he threw it away.

I believed him.

But the next morning the can was back on the counter.

Sitting upright.

Facing him.

Like it had something to say about his sodium intake and his first marriage.

Personally, I think that’s fair.

Some ghosts come from graveyards.

Others come from Father’s Day.

The cruelest ones are the things we never say to the people we love while they’re still alive enough to hear them.

Share

Leave a comment

This article is a companion to my previous essay, “What If We Spent Less Time Guarding Gates and More Time Building Tables?” The first piece asked why we spend so much time deciding who belongs. This one asks a different question: Why are human beings so eager to find someone who doesn’t?

Spend enough Saturdays near the courthouse square in Portales, New Mexico and you will begin to notice something. There is a group of humans out there protesting. The signs change. The slogans change. The causes change. The people holding them sometimes change. Yet the message against them rarely does. Someone is ruining everything. Someone is corrupting the culture of this town. Someone is destroying the country. Someone is responsible for our frustrations. All that remains is deciding who gets assigned the role this week.

Meanwhile, business owners unlock their doors and hope customers still come downtown. City council members hear complaints from every direction. Ordinary citizens try to buy “things,” drink coffee, attend community events, and enjoy a Saturday morning while another argument unfolds in public. The strange part is that the accused are rarely strangers. They are often people who shop at the same stores, attend the same churches, support the same local businesses, and wave to each other across the courthouse square. Yet once a person becomes a symbol, it becomes easier to forget they are neighbors.

That is the danger.

Throughout history, the distance between neighbor and enemy has often been measured by nothing more than a story people were willing to believe.

Every generation likes to imagine it has evolved beyond the barbarism of those that came before it. If you look back at the Salem witch trials, religious persecutions, Southern lynch mobs, 1950s’s political purges, and the long history of American ideological crusades, you might come away with a mixture of horror, or perhaps something else. If you take time to read history books, you might find yourself asking how ordinary people could have participated in such things.

The answer is an uncomfortable one.

Because they were ordinary people.

They were not monsters. They were neighbors, teachers, clergy, business owners, parents, and patriots. The frightening truth is that history’s greatest outrages were rarely carried out by villains. They were carried out by people convinced they were doing the right thing.

Technology changes. The clothing changes. The slogans change. Human nature does not.

The French thinker René Girard spent much of his life examining a pattern that appears throughout history with alarming consistency. When communities become anxious, divided, fearful, or unstable, they often seek relief in the same way… They find someone to blame.

We call that person a “scapegoat.”

The target changes.

The individual changes.

The accusations change.

The mechanism remains.

The reason scapegoating survives century after century is because it delivers a genuine reward. For brief moments, confusion becomes clarity and complex problems become simple. It is a simple calculus, personal responsibility becomes unnecessary and the burden moves… The anxiety eases… The crowd feels united.

In reality, nothing is solved, but everyone feels better.

It is fucking pathetic, but human beings have always been willing to mistake relief for truth.

The process is almost embarrassingly predictable. A community experiences tension. Economic stress. Political uncertainty. Cultural change. Social disruption. The anxiety builds until it becomes unbearable. Then someone points toward a person or group and says, “There. That’s the problem!”

The moment that happens, people who disagree about everything suddenly discover unity. Not because they solved the problem, but because they found someone to blame for it. The scapegoat becomes social glue. The sacrifice becomes a source of temporary peace.

History is littered with the wreckage left behind from moments like these.

I wish I could pretend this temptation belongs to other people. It doesn’t. I’ve felt it myself. Every one of us has. The desire to simplify a complicated problem by attaching a face to it.

The desire to believe our frustrations would disappear if the right people would simply shut up, move away, lose influence, or cease to exist in our field of vision. It is one of humanity’s oldest fantasies: that removing a neighbor can heal a wound inside ourselves.

That impulse is older than politics, older than religion, and older than civilization itself. The difference between a functioning society and a collapsing one is not whether that impulse exists… The difference is whether enough people learn to resist it.

Civilization is often described as roads, laws, governments, markets, and institutions. That is only partially true. Civilization begins much closer to home. It begins in the space between an impulse and a decision... Between anger and restraint… Between fear and courage… Between suspicion and understanding.

The gap between impulse and action is where civilization lives.

It is where the human being either becomes noble or becomes an animal with better tools.

One of the strange things about small towns is that proximity creates the illusion of understanding. We recognize faces. We know names. We know where people work. We know who their parents are. Hell, sometimes we know who their grandparents were. Yet, we often know almost nothing about the burdens they carry. The diagnosis they have not shared. The marriage struggling behind closed doors. The child keeping them awake at night. The grief they carry through Farmers Country Market while smiling at everyone they pass.

Human beings are always more complicated than the stories we tell about them.

For Christians, the irony is difficult to ignore. The central story of faith is the story of a scapegoat… Of a frightened crowd… Political leaders protecting stability… Religious leaders protecting authority... Ordinary people convinced they were defending righteousness.

An innocent man standing at the center of their certainty.

Two thousand years later, we still tell ourselves we would have behaved differently.

History suggests otherwise.

Sometimes the loudest defense of faith looks remarkably similar to an advertisement against it.

The greatest danger facing any community is not that it contains sinners.

It is that it contains people convinced they know exactly who the sinners are.

That question is not being answered in Washington. It is being answered right here in Portales, New Mexico. It is being answered when a public official decides whether they represent all citizens or only the ones who agree with them. It is being answered when a pastor decides whether faith is an invitation or a weapon. It is being answered when a parent chooses certainty over a relationship with their child. It is being answered when a citizen decides whether a neighbor is a human being or merely a category they can assign blame to.

The person being blamed today is rarely a stranger. They are often the same people we graduated with, the same people whose children sit beside ours in school, the same people we pass at Farmers Country Market, the same people we see at the Roosevelt County Fair, and the same people we wave to across the square. They are the same people we stand beside at funerals when life reminds us how temporary our arguments really are.

That reality should make us cautious whenever we feel absolutely certain about another human being. History’s worst mistakes were rarely committed by people plagued with doubt. They were committed by people who were convinced they understood exactly who deserved blame.

Because… long after the protest signs come down, long after the election is over, and long after social media finds a new outrage to monetize, we still must live together. We still share the same streets, the same schools, the same churches, the same businesses, and the same community.

For all the noise we make about our differences, most of us are carrying the same burdens. Trying to pay bills. Trying to raise decent kids. Trying to care for aging parents. Trying to make sense of a complicated world. Trying to find a little peace.

Girard warned that anxious societies look for scapegoats. History shows what happens when they find them. The better path has always been harder. It requires self-mastery. Humility. Restraint. The courage to question our own certainty before questioning someone else’s humanity.

And perhaps that is the real lesson.

The problem was never Pride… The one celebrated every June.

The problem was always pride.

The ancient kind… The human kind… The shit nested in our DNA.

The kind that convinces us our anger is righteousness, our assumptions are facts, our tribe is virtuous, and our enemies are the source of our suffering. The kind that convinces us we would have opposed the mob in every generation while never noticing we have become part of one in our own.

In the end, civilization survives not because people agree. Civilization survives because enough people refuse to believe that destroying a neighbor will heal a wound inside themselves. History suggests it never does.

That choice belongs to every one of us.

Every day.

In Portales, New Mexico.

Not in theory.

Not online.

Not in slogans.

Here.

In the conversations we have.

In the assumptions we make.

In the grace we extend.

In the strangers we choose to see as neighbors.

In the gates we guard.

And in the tables we choose to build.

Because every generation gets a choice.

The crowd.

Or the chair.

Leave a comment